Asia Watch: Hong Kong Has Been Shanghaied
William Pesek | March 17, 2010
Related articles
Hong Kong Won’t Become a Tibet or Xinjiang, Say Analysts 11:26am Feb 4, 2012
Hong Kong Paper Runs Ad Insulting Mainland 'Locusts' 1:02pm Feb 1, 2012
Dogs and Locusts: Name-Calling Feud Between Hong Kongers and Mainlanders 9:35am Jan 27, 2012
Asian Hedge Fund Shuts Down as Assets Fall 11:13pm Jan 9, 2012
New Hong Kong Government Office Contaminated 12:25pm Jan 3, 2012
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
Be the first to write your opinion!
Donald Tsang, consider yourself shanghaied.
It happened on March 5, as Hong Kong’s chief executive visited Beijing. There, local news media confronted Tsang with an article pointing out that Shanghai’s economy exceeded the size of Hong Kong’s for the first time in at least three decades.
Tsang’s retort was predictable: Shanghai’s rise is “not a threat.” Here is mine: Who are you kidding?
For years now, Hong Kong has argued the city’s uniqueness enshrined its prosperity. Its rule of law, economic freedoms and role as the gateway to China have trumped concerns such as long-term relevance and bad air quality. Also, investors haven’t made lots of money betting against Hong Kong.
Yet the day Hong Kong has long pooh-poohed is here. Shanghai is rapidly regaining its position as China’s dominant financial center. And investors betting on Hong Kong’s once-indisputable place in Asia should think again.
Financial Secretary John Tsang said last week that Hong Kong was at the early stage of a recovery. Its economy is growing at about 2.6 percent — not bad in a global context. The problem is the longer-term picture.
Here, Forbes magazine’s latest billionaires list is worth considering. The headlines in Asia focused on “Superman.” That would be Li Ka-shing, whose fortune jumped 30 percent to $21 billion over the past year. It was deemed good news; Li is often portrayed as personifying Hong Kong’s ups and downs.
The real story, though, was the wealth boom on the mainland. For the first time, mainland China has the most billionaires outside the United States. Perhaps that’s as it should be, given China’s 1.3 billion-person population. A similar argument can be made about gross domestic product. Shanghai has about 19 million people to Hong Kong’s 7 million. According to 2008 figures, Hong Kong’s per-capita GDP is $30,977; Shanghai’s is $10,713.
Yet the trajectory is clear. Even if China grows more slowly in the next few years, its need for a middleman economy like Hong Kong’s is dwindling. Shanghai is now China’s biggest port and stock market operator.
HSBC Holdings, Europe’s biggest bank, may soon be the first foreign company to list in Shanghai. Policy makers there are wooing more overseas issuers seduced by China’s potential. That dynamic is likely to siphon off capital that might otherwise gravitate to Hong Kong.
Really, how much longer will bankers, investors and corporate executives feel the need to stop by Hong Kong on the way to China? Over time, going directly to the source of demand makes far more sense.
As more and more buildings appear in China, there may be less support for Hong Kong’s all-important real-estate market. Economic growth might become more restrained and the city’s credit rating could easily take a long-term hit.
Shanghai’s day is coming faster than many appreciate. As Shanghai replicates Hong Kong’s strengths, Hong Kong will only become less relevant.
It’s not just Shanghai, but also Shenzhen. Sitting just north of Hong Kong, the booming city’s population is already bigger. The skyscraper-strewn city is attracting capital that a couple of years ago might have gone to Hong Kong. And this forgets the several other cities dotted around China looking to become the next Shanghai or Shenzhen.
If there’s a silver lining here it’s the catalyst effect. Shanghai makes it harder for Hong Kong to continue resting on its laurels. It’s no longer enough to rely on the arts and theme parks such as Disneyland and Ocean Park to boost growth. Walt Disney, by the way, is now moving into Shanghai.
A better idea would be to empower entrepreneurs who will create jobs and buzz. Each year, the Heritage Foundation and the Wall Street Journal, which publish the annual Index of Economic Freedom, rank Hong Kong as the freest economy — perfect conditions for such entrepreneurs.
True, the city features the free entry of foreign capital, a first-world legal system and low taxes. It’s also an economy of oligarchs; a handful of tycoons tower over it. Their dominance sucks up much of the innovative oxygen that could enliven the economy.
Unless China falters, Shanghai will be a growing problem for Hong Kong. That should concern investors betting on the city’s future.
William Pesek is a Bloomberg columnist.
- Malaysian Girl Speaks Indonesian After Freak Accident: Report
- Indonesians Buying Up Most Expensive Homes in Singapore
- Funeral on Friday for Student Killed in Rafting Accident
- Indonesia Woman Kills Teenage Brother Over Sock Insult
- Adek Berry: The Lady Behind the Camera
- Concerned for Orangutans in Indonesia, US Girl Scouts Lobby for Sustainable Palm Oil
- 7 Motorcycle Girls Arrested for Beating Up Their Own on Bali
- Will Lady Gaga Finally Set Foot in Jakarta?
- 5 More Prisoners Found After Jakarta Jail Break
- Opening Eyes to Tolerance Via Film
-
5:30pm | Malaysian Girl Speaks Indonesi...
nonredneck No, I am most definitely not the serigala who has posted a number of times in recent months. -
5:18pm | Indonesians Buying Up Most Exp...
Saudi royal families..eat your heart out :P. Money is indeed the root of all evil hehehehe -
4:59pm | Malaysian Girl Speaks Indonesi...
'Serigala-Berbulu-Domba' are you the same person as 'Serigala' ?? or many just wants to be the serigala in indo? -
4:58pm | Shocking Images Show Animal Cr...
cows are bred to satisfy human need thereby we have a duty of care to them. Ants are not. In addition (from many humans point of view) ants are not -
4:56pm | Axis of Hostility: Iran, Israe...
NRN - I appreciate your point of view and there is merit - however never before has Ajd been under such internal and external pressure - he is a ve -
4:56pm | Jail Break No More: All 12 Pri...
This article tells a lot about Indonesian prisons. I have never heard about somebody succeeding in hiding a chainsaw in his pocket. Amazing Indones -
4:56pm | Jail Break No More: All 12 Pri...
All 12 in 2 days caught but nunun was on the run 2 years.... -
4:51pm | Concerned for Orangutans in In...
Girls, don't forget to campaign for the poor people whose lives depends on the Palm Oil industry too, okay. These people have every right to earn
