Europe Watch: IMF Will Serve EU Better Than Pride
Matthew Lynn | March 09, 2010
Related articles
Freezing Conditions Paralyze Danube River Shipping 8:16am Feb 9, 2012
IMF Calls on Hungary to Make Progress On Its Economy Prior to Setting Loans 9:15pm Jan 13, 2012
IMF Urges Members to Approve Funding Hike 9:21am Dec 23, 2011
IMF Chief Warns of 1930s Style Global Crisis if Nations Fail to Work Together 8:14pm Dec 16, 2011
Britain’s Hague in Washington After EU Deal Snub 8:56am Dec 12, 2011
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
Be the first to write your opinion!
Who you gonna call?” wasn’t just a catchphrase in the 1984 film “Ghostbusters.” If the worst happens in Greece, Spain or Portugal, we’re going to hear it all over again and Europe’s taxpayers will want to know the answer.
The European Union? The European Central Bank? Or the International Monetary Fund?
Senior officials, including ECB President Jean-Claude Trichet, have suggested it would be a humiliation for a euro zone country to call on the IMF for a rescue package to prevent a sovereign-debt default. European problems must have European solutions, they insist.
That’s where they are wrong.
This is no moment for pride. If emergency funding has to be organized, it should be the IMF that takes the lead. It has the expertise, it can absorb all the flak and the “no bailout” rule would remain one of the fundamental principles of the region’s common currency.
In the last few weeks, Greece in particular has been publicly toying with the idea of calling on the resources and skills of the IMF to help with the financing of the country’s budget deficit, equal to 12.7 percent of gross domestic product.
Greek Prime Minister George Papandreou said last week that the Washington-based lender might have a role in resolving the crisis. “If markets don’t respond as we would like them to, due to their speculative behavior, then the final resort would be the International Monetary Fund,” he said on March 3.
The next day, Trichet made a point of ruling that out. Calling on the IMF wouldn’t be “appropriate,” he said at a press conference in Frankfurt. Most European leaders would agree. German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble has even backed a European Monetary Fund as an alternative to the IMF.
Some clarity is needed. It’s not just Greece that has a huge fiscal deficit. So do Portugal, Spain, Ireland and, to a lesser extent, Italy. Any of those countries might find itself under attack from the debt markets. In extremis, it might be impossible to sell the bonds to finance those deficits. It needs to be clear who they turn to for help in those circumstances.
The reluctance of senior EU and ECB officials to see the IMF leading a rescue package is understandable. The euro is meant to be a strong currency for strong countries. The IMF flies in to help poor countries in disarray.
There is no question it would be embarrassing if a euro member had to go cap in hand to the IMF. The reputation of the whole region would be tarnished and the euro’s future would be in jeopardy.
And yet there are good reasons for them to swallow their pride and let the IMF come in and do its work.
First, it has the expertise in dealing with countries that have lost the confidence of the global capital markets. It has the people and the experience to handle those situations.
The ECB or a new European Monetary Fund could develop those skills but, let’s be honest, if you had a heart attack, wouldn’t you want an experienced cardiac team looking after you? Or would you prefer doctors who turn up with textbooks under their arms, promising that they learn fast? A crisis is no time to experiment.
Second, the medicine is going to be brutal. For any euro zone country that has to narrow its deficit, there will have to be deep cuts in public spending. Wages will be reduced, jobs lost and retirement ages raised — the kind of measures the Irish have been taking to bring their public spending under control. It isn’t going to be popular. The IMF is better suited to being the “bad cop.” It can take all the criticism and divert public anger away from the EU and the euro.
Third, calling in the IMF will preserve the no-bailout rule. When the euro was established, it was decided that member states shouldn’t have to bail each other out in the event of a fiscal crisis.
That was important. Taxpayers in Germany don’t want to feel they are being made to pay for less-responsible governments in Greece or Portugal. If they are forced to, they might decide it’s not a club they want to be in anymore.
Seeking help from the IMF gets around that situation. The world’s main developed countries are the members and they contribute to its funding.
If an emergency loan needs to be organized for Europe’s laggards, it would not be the euro members helping them out. It would be the whole world. The key “no bailout” pact between euro members would therefore remain in place.
Of course, the crisis could also be resolved within the euro area. The common-currency members are meant to be a family of nations in a zone of economic cooperation. It is not much of a family if the various members aren’t willing to help each other.
The IMF solution still makes more sense. That should be sorted out now, so that next time the bond markets attack a euro-member state, we all know who they’re going to call.
Matthew Lynn is a Bloomberg columnist.
- Malaysian Girl Speaks Indonesian After Freak Accident: Report
- Indonesians Buying Up Most Expensive Homes in Singapore
- Indonesia Woman Kills Teenage Brother Over Sock Insult
- Funeral on Friday for Student Killed in Rafting Accident
- Concerned for Orangutans in Indonesia, US Girl Scouts Lobby for Sustainable Palm Oil
- 7 Motorcycle Girls Arrested for Beating Up Their Own on Bali
- Will Lady Gaga Finally Set Foot in Jakarta?
- 5 More Prisoners Found After Jakarta Jail Break
- Opening Eyes to Tolerance Via Film
- Indonesian Operators Ban Access to LGBT Advocacy Web Site
-
8:48pm | Breaking News: Dozens Feared D...
It's amazing there are not a lot more accidents of this severity, given the crazed manner in which many bus drivers 'pilot' their vehicles on th -
7:40pm | Shocking Images Show Animal Cr...
I can definitely tell you that in Islam we do not discriminate animals based on their habit or size. All animals should be loved and not unnecessar -
7:18pm | Malaysian Police Detain Saudi ...
Is that something that interpol do ? Do they have to follow certain guideline on what can be classified as a crime ? -
7:13pm | Shocking Images Show Animal Cr...
Sorry Bawel, my brother... What do you do with Eid Al Adha? Slice (or watch the slicing of) the throat of the goat and let i -
6:48pm | Malaysian Police Detain Saudi ...
vanu - i suspect if the said deity existed he/she would not want his followers to kill people, and yet they do and he/she says nothing... draw your -
6:28pm | Opening Eyes to Tolerance Via ...
agoz - methinks the lady doth protest too much. Suggest you watch 'The Kite Runner' - your type of film buddy. -
6:23pm | Indonesia Partners Catholic Ch...
Church cleric abuse children for decades? It doesn't mean that Catholicism is bad right? Seriously. Or may be the side effect of c -
6:21pm | Concerned for Orangutans in In...
waky - sorry, but what is your argument - that anything can be sacrificed to sustain human existance. If this is what you are saying I totally disa
