Cleavage, Ghouls and Other Cliches in Indonesian Cinema
Marcel Thee | February 22, 2011
A glimpse of current local movies and those “coming soon” provides a grim summary of what we are in for should Hollywood boycott screening films in Indonesia. “Cewek Saweran” loosely translates to “Chip in Girl,” which refers to street entertainers who busk for change. The synopsis sells the story as a village girl’s struggle to become a famous dangdut singer, its buttock-centric poster states, “Low-budget ‘Showgirls.’ ” Other titles seem even more predictable: “Pocong Ngesot” (“Sliding White Shrouded Corpse”), “Arwah Goyang Karawang” (“Karawang Dancing Ghost”), and “Jenglot Pantai Selatan” (“South Beach Tiny Vampire”). (JG Illustration) Related articles
Indonesian Child Star Allegedly Exploited By Director 12:01pm Mar 29, 2012
‘The Raid’ Has Moviegoers Out in Force as Critics Rave 9:53am Mar 24, 2012
‘Mr Bean’ Confirmed to Play Ghost Role in Indonesian Movie 8:48am Mar 23, 2012
'The Raid: Redemption' Lives Up to the Hype 9:14pm Mar 20, 2012
Jakarta Film Festival Urges Environmental Activists to Shoot With a Wide Lens 1:34pm Feb 27, 2012
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
424192Why would people pay to watch 3rd rate sinetron at the cinema when 5th rate sinetron is free on TV?
I agree with you @poopinjay . If they follow the local majorit taste, it means they will have full booked tickets...the fact is..their movie always fails..
the producers of this kind of movies always use excuses such as 'following the local majority taste', while in fact, it's they who build that 'majority taste'.
somebody should kick these producers (*cough*Parwez*cough*) outta this country!
Ah, and I remember. Because of the "Indonesian movies - must be bad" stigma, people won't waste their time to even look at the story and stuff. they will judge that all movies are the same. Once i watched Denias, it's a good movie in my opinion..sadly, there are only 15 people watching the movie....
I always try to stay positive. But I have lost my trust in Indonesian movies. yes, we do have great movie like Laskar Pelangi, Arisan, KING, Denias but still the percentage of bad movies are way higher than good movies. So, what's our hope suppose to be for Indonesian movies? If we dont fix this I believe most of the cinemas will be closed down since no one bother to go and watch the movie..
Lets wait and see
- Previous
- 1
- Next
So here we are counting down the days to what will arguably be a local monopoly of the cinema. Without imported films we will have to entertain ourselves with homemade offerings — something that many of us have worked hard to avoid for years.
Why? It isn’t exactly unfair to say the local film scene has been a laughing stock for too long now. Apologists will try to defend it by referring to the laughably rare better-than-average local releases — many of which are, in truth, merely “acceptable” and can be praised only in comparison to their exceptionally unwatchable peers.
Yes, this means the same exhausted circus of cleavage and ghouls. But then again, what cannot be considered “average” in comparison with most of our horror film releases?
The sad truth is, bosoms and Satan are not the only things keeping us away from the cinema.
Apologists tend to defend Indonesian films not infused with horror or sex simply because they bypass those two commercially viable themes.
In a recent review I wrote of a local film about a boy whose dream is to play with the national soccer team, I critiqued (with conscious subtlety) the acting, directing and clumsy editing — among the movie’s other flaws.
The villagers quickly picked up their pitchforks and chased me to the woods with their online comments. Most claimed that since the movie promotes nationalism, has a (horrendous Disney-esque) “moral message,” and contains no glimpses of breasts or bleeding ghosts, it should automatically be praised as if it were the Indonesian “Citizen Kane.”
This is like claiming that a serial killer that murdered seven people is a nice fellow because most of the others roaming around have killed more than 10.
The best way to support the local cinema is to hold our movies to the same standard with which we judge international films.
Yet a glimpse of current local movies and those “coming soon” provides a grim summary of what we are in for should the government policy be implemented.
“Cewek Saweran” loosely translates to “Chip in Girl,” which refers to street entertainers who busk for change in villages, street parties and the like. The rough translation may not do justice to how unbearably corny the title is. While the synopsis sells the story as a village girl’s struggle to become a famous dangdut singer, its buttock-centric poster states, “Low-budget ‘Showgirls.’ ”
Other upcoming and currently-running titles seem even more predictable: “Pocong Ngesot” (“Sliding White Shrouded Corpse”), “Arwah Goyang Karawang” (“Karawang Dancing Ghost”), and “Jenglot Pantai Selatan” (“South Beach Tiny Vampire”).
While previous years have seen local cinemas pushing Oscar contending films to the forefront during the weeks leading up and after the awards ceremony, this year moviegoers will have to settle for either watching a DVD copy of the nominated films at home or give in to watching local films in the theater.
There’s still hope for local films, though it’s hard to be optimistic. The revenge thriller “Tebus” (“Redeem”) seems to promise a thrill in the vein of “The Strangers.” While “Rumah Tanpa Jendela” (“House Without a Window”) might provide an interesting glimpse into the lives of street children. But these are very few and far between and past examples of “better-film-ideas” have not been executed well for the most part.
So here’s a summary of why most people aren’t going to watch commercially released local movies. Until I see proof otherwise, I will say with confidence 90 percent of them are just plain bad.
- Hard-Line FPI Buys 150 Tickets to Stop Lady Gaga Concert
- Bali Offers to Host Lady Gaga Concert
- Indonesia's National Police Says it Might Allow Lady Gaga Show
- Lady Gaga No Longer Speechless, Talks About Jakarta Concert
- Jakarta Police Would Dispatch Up to 4,000 Officers for Lady Gaga Show
- Lady Gaga Rocks Philippines, Defies Critics
- Some Experts Say Indonesia's Blackberry Service Is Declining
- Hard-Line FUI Says Lady Gaga Promoter Offered it a Bribe
- Bali’s ‘Subak’ Technique Makes Unesco World Heritage List
- Insight: Indonesia Tycoon Bakrie Gears Up for Presidential Bid
-
12:51pm | Australia Denies Corby Deal Wi...
den2114 - I do-not know of one person amongst my English friends who at some point in their lives have not taken marijuana in some way. You would f -
12:49pm | Jakarta Police Would Dispatch ...
@Yme: Maybe some people would like to spend their money on art and entertainment, concepts might be hard for you to grasp. -
12:45pm | Indonesian Maid Spiked Boss' C...
yucks... common people "The maximum penalty for the offense is a year in jail and a fine." Singapore actually have law covering t -
12:42pm | Hard-Line FPI Buys 150 Tickets...
I still could not fine any picture of Gaga with her little cross.... help ;p -
12:39pm | Ask Atheists, Christians, Shii...
Just becasue you were the wife of a president doesnt make you a politician.... err similar trend in Indonesia too.. maaf Bu.. -
12:34pm | Hard-Line FPI Buys 150 Tickets...
I hope Lady Gaga use this picture as a fashion reference for her concert attire! She did use the Barong Filipino as a reference for her Manila Tour -
12:34pm | Hard-Line FUI Says Lady Gaga P...
@SirAnthony very nice story to pretty much sum up what kind of people are in FPI and FUI. -
12:29pm | Jakarta Police Would Dispatch ...
If they have enough money to buy the tickets, they'll surely have money to buy 3 square meals in a day plus pay their tuition fee.
