A Hidden Past Revealed: One Viewer’s Personal Reflection on Cutting Through the Silence of 40 Years
Armando Siahaan | July 01, 2009
A production still from the documentary “40 Years of Silence: An Indonesian Tragedy.” (Photo: Courtesy of Elemental Productions) Related articles
Komnas HAM Report Lays Blame for 1965-6 Killings Primarily on Suharto 9:09am Jan 18, 2012
TV's History Channel Sets Ambitious Miniseries 12:06pm Jan 4, 2012
Cold, Dim Room Sheds Light on Singapore History 11:19am Sep 19, 2011
Retracing the Chinese Riot 12:16am Jun 21, 2010
Lying Low at Prince of Thieves’ Hideout 6:25pm May 28, 2010
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
Be the first to write your opinion!
Growing up under the rule of President Suharto, I was raised to believe that Communists were sadistic and evil. Through formal education, monuments and a film that was shown on television every year, I was taught that on the night of Sept. 30, 1965, Communist members gouged out the eyes and castrated six high-ranking military officers.
Through Lemelson’s documentary, and other revelations I heard at a recent history conference in Singapore, I learned that the New Order regime had distorted the events of the time. To start with, historians contend, based on formal autopsies, none of the six was mutilated.
More important, “40 Years of Silence” showed me how barbaric the Indonesian Armed Forces were in their retaliation. Using Kereta’s personal account as my reference, I tried to visualize what it would feel like to witness my father stabbed with a sword, beaten until his brain splattered out and his eyes gouged out with a pick.
One historian told me that it wasn’t uncommon to find dead bodies of pregnant women suspected of Communist affiliation with their stomachs cut open and the baby ripped out. Such spectacles were displayed to terrify the Communists.
Also surprising to me, in a country that treasures family ties, Kereta’s father was turned in by his own nephew, and Degung is open about his hatred for his mother. The anti-Communist purge ruptured families and spread hatred between close relatives.
The history of 1965 was exploited by Suharto to consolidate his regime, through the depiction of a battle between the Army, cast as national heroes, and Communists as the evil villains. Having only recently learned of the mass slaughter, I found myself asking who were the real evildoers.
I’m also embarrassed that, for more than 30 years, Indonesians have been misled into revering and glorifying the Army, the force responsible for such brutal slaughter. The idea of valuing the death of six generals over the slaughter of up to a million citizens simply appalls me. How could the deaths of so many have even been concealed?
And now that the New Order regime has fallen, I find myself asking why this part of our history remains untold? The stigma against communism still prevails in Indonesia and few of our citizens know of our dark past.
Victims like Budi, who is descended form suspected Communists, are still ostracized in society. The year 1965 is still remembered on a national scale solely for the failed coup. Even the national curriculum and official history textbooks ignore the resulting slaughter. Of 10 people on the street, I would be surprised to find one with knowledge of the mass killings.
What transpired in 1965 was a gross violation of human rights, so why doesn’t the current government have the courage and willingness to confront the past? Shouldn’t those responsible be brought to justice? At the very least, shouldn’t the government ensure that Indonesians know the truth about this dark chapter of our history?
Yes, what happened was shameful, but that doesn’t justify us ignoring it. Taking legal action against those responsible may be the ultimate resolution to the struggle of the victims and following generations. But what I feel is more important is for people to know that Indonesia once executed its own people and the government covered those actions without a trace.
Correction of this period in history must occur so Indonesia, as a nation, can avoid the misperception that history must repeat itself.
- Malaysian Girl Speaks Indonesian After Freak Accident: Report
- Indonesians Buying Up Most Expensive Homes in Singapore
- Funeral on Friday for Student Killed in Rafting Accident
- Adek Berry: The Lady Behind the Camera
- Indonesian Police Arrest Czech Tourist in Papua
- 7 Motorcycle Girls Arrested for Beating Up Their Own on Bali
- Concerned for Orangutans in Indonesia, US Girl Scouts Lobby for Sustainable Palm Oil
- Indonesian Operators Ban Access to LGBT Advocacy Web Site
- Opening Eyes to Tolerance Via Film
- Final Farewell to Singapore's Dr. Toh Chin Chye
-
10:38am | Opening Eyes to Tolerance Via ...
Two out of ten may be homosexuals or bisexuals therefore should the FPI make a vocal appearance how many would you think be among them?? -
10:33am | Trial of Accused Bali Bomber P...
It is Halloween all over again. Trick or treat...Most embarrassing picture of the year. -
10:31am | Indonesian President’s New Pla...
I wonder if one of his personal pilots will be from the 'flyhigh club'? -
10:29am | Shocking Images Show Animal Cr...
The pot calling the cattle black... Whether some may look at it as a color scheme tit for tat;the Southern nation has always been qu -
10:28am | Shocking Images Show Animal Cr...
Dez + padt.... Like many, whenever there's a new thread, I start from the first entry. Well, my mind immediately began to construct -
10:13am | Ariel Could Be Released From J...
marko1 - Do you know something we don't? Please share because good news is desperately needed. -
10:09am | Ariel Could Be Released From J...
Arifinto (PKS) should follow the example from India where 3 state ministers resigned when caught watching porno during local assembly. The Muslims -
10:02am | House Slights Supreme Court Or...
President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono cannot directly interfere in the dispute between the GKI Taman Yasmin Protestant church congregation and the Bog
