Govt Economic Projections Overly Bullish, Analysts Say
Dion Bisara & Mohammad Al Azhari | March 29, 2011
The government expects consumer spending to drive the economy, but analysts say its projections may be too optimistic. (JG Photo/Yudhi Sukma Wijaya) Related articles
ADB Trims Indonesia’s 2012 Economic Growth Forecast 9:17pm Apr 11, 2012
Euro Woes May Hit Local Economy: BI 9:24pm Feb 10, 2012
SBY Calls on SOEs to Do More for Country’s Growth 1:22am Feb 9, 2012
Economists Expect Bank Indonesia to Maintain 6% Rate 9:26pm Feb 8, 2012
Indonesian Economic Growth Holds Firm at 6.5 Percent 12:55pm Feb 6, 2012
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
Be the first to write your opinion!
While the government expects the economy to grow 6.6 percent next year, worries about rising oil and food prices eating away at consumers’ purchasing power have analysts less bullish.
Consumer spending is the main driver of Indonesia’s economic growth, accounting for two-thirds of the country’s gross domestic product.
Finance Minister Agus Martowardojo revealed the government’s 2012 economic targets during a cabinet meeting at the State Palace in Bogor on Tuesday. It expects the economy to grow 6.6 percent next year after projecting 6.4 percent growth in 2011. It assumed the rupiah would trade at 9,150 against the US dollar and put headline inflation at 5.5 percent.
The government uses seven assumptions to calculate the state budget, including economic growth, the rupiah’s exchange rate against the dollar, the inflation rate, three-month Bank Indonesia certificates, oil prices and oil production.
Hatta Rajasa, the coordinating minister for the economy, said the government would protect the people from the impact of volatile global oil prices. He said the government acknowledged the Indonesian Crude Price, the international price index for crude oil from Indonesia, had reached $113.03 per barrel, but he said the government would “escort the economy and guard consumer purchasing power.”
Analysts told the Jakarta Globe they were not so sure.
“It will be hard for the economy to grow beyond 6.5 percent,” said David Sumual, an economist from Bank Central Asia. “It will be overheating because our economy still relies on non-tradeable sectors, which is bad as it does not absorb much labor.”
He said the complicated bureaucracy and poor infrastructure hurt potential growth.
“Poor infrastructure conditions are hampering the competitiveness of our labor-intensive manufacturing sector,” he said. “Our cost of production remains higher compared to rivals such as China even though we offer cheaper labor costs. It’s because of our poor infrastructure.”
Infrastructure spending in the state budget increased significantly to Rp 126 trillion ($14.5 billion) this year, the largest allocation in six years, from Rp 108 trillion in 2010. The country needs an estimated Rp 1,400 trillion until 2014 to build much-needed infrastructure projects such as seaports, airports and roads to ease the distribution of goods.
Purbaya Yudhi Sadewa, an economist at the Danareksa Research Institute, said the government’s target was attainable if consumption remained strong and foreign investment continued to flow into the country.
“We can grow even more if government comes through with its infrastructure projects,” he said. “The increase may seem slow because they have not implemented all their programs.”
Data from the Investment Coordinating Board (BKPM) shows foreign direct investment in Indonesia could hit $14 billion this year, from $10.5 billion last year.
Fatchur Rochman, chairman of the Toll Road Business Association, criticized the government for its slow movement, including on land acquisition laws.
“They said they could finish it last year, then early this year, but as of now it has not been finished yet,” he said.
“The problem in bureaucracy is they are reluctant to point out who failed to do something. Even President [Susilo Bambang] Yudhoyono is like that. If they worked more like in private sector — ‘Hey, you failed at this. Fix it.’ — I think they would perform better. More continuous and rigorous monitoring should be implemented to ensure things get done.”
He suggested the government give up its rights on infrastructure planning and development to provincial governments for better resource allocation.
- Bali Offers to Host Lady Gaga Concert
- Indonesia ‘Most Tolerant Country in the World’: Religious Minister
- Lady Gaga No Longer Speechless, Talks About Jakarta Concert
- Jakarta Police Would Dispatch Up to 4,000 Officers for Lady Gaga Show
- Indonesian Maid Spiked Boss' Coffee With Her Menstrual Blood
- Ask Atheists, Christians, Shiites and Ahmadis: Indonesia Is No Model for Muslim Democracy
- Some Experts Say Indonesia's Blackberry Service Is Declining
- Hard-Line FUI Says Lady Gaga Promoter Offered it a Bribe
- FUI: 'Christians Should be Upset With Gaga'
- Australia’s Corby Gets Five-Year Sentence Cut
-
10:26pm | Australia’s Corby Could Walk F...
Is this the same guy who said, just a few hours ago, that she is "comfortable" in prison? Is this a try to turn Indonesian citizens against SBY' -
10:16pm | Indonesia ‘Most Tolerant Count...
Dear lord let him be sterile we dont need anymore morons in indonesia. Who voted this waste of space into government? "The president and i go to c -
10:06pm | Indonesia ‘Most Tolerant Count...
Ҩ(° ̯˚)Ҩ -
10:05pm | Indonesia ‘Most Tolerant Count...
The gov' of Indonesia should not recognize its country's six official religions because the religions make conflict in Indonesia all over the arc -
9:59pm | Some Experts Say Indonesia's B...
@D88 "...at least Indonesia is democratic country, unlike Singapore or Malaysia" Are you also "slumberless"? Or just lovers? ".. -
9:59pm | Indonesia ‘Most Tolerant Count...
"Yellow diamonds in the LIE," "Is a sky full of LIERES," "In another LIE," And that's coming from a man with a -
9:54pm | Churchill Set for Arbitration ...
hope the money goes to the people in the area -
9:51pm | RIM to Develop Indonesian ITB ...
xpat , theyre lucky enough to be given this opportunity , what makes you think this isn't based on mutual interest ? just because there's an econ
