•    HOME   
•    NEWS   
•    BUSINESS   
•    INTERNATIONAL   
•    TECH   
•    SPORTS   
•    LIFE & TIMES   
•    OPINION   
•    MY JAKARTA   
•    BLOGS   
•    EYEWITNESS   

Dubai. An advisor to Goldman Sachs has defended the US bank’s $2 billion Islamic bond program against criticism it may contravene religious principles, in a controversy that could affect Western banks’ ability to enter the Islamic debt market.

In October, Goldman registered the sukuk program with the Irish Stock Exchange. It set up a Cayman Islands-registered special purpose vehicle, Global Sukuk, to issue a sukuk based on murabaha, a cost-plus-profit arrangement that complies with Islamic law.

Some analysts, however, have suggested Goldman might use the proceeds of the issue to lend money to clients for interest, which would be against Islamic law, and that the issue might not trade at par value on the Irish exchange, which would also contravene sharia law.

Asim Khan, managing director at Islamic finance advisory firm Dar Al Istithmar, said such speculation was groundless.

“Bulge-bracket banks such as Goldman Sachs can bring to Islamic finance their sophistication and depth of experience in liquidity management and equity/quasi-equity investment, which can take Islamic finance closer to its true ideals, so long as they adhere to the generally accepted sharia principles,” Khan said.

“So far there is no basis to speculate otherwise,” Khan, whose London and Dubai-based company advised Goldman on the sukuk, wrote in a column contributed to Reuters.

As the euro zone debt crisis poisoned conventional debt markets last year, several big Western banks considered raising money through Islamic finance, which is based on religious principles and bans the payment of interest and pure monetary speculation.

The Arab Gulf, home to billions of dollars of Islamic investment funds, has been relatively untouched by the financial crisis.

HSBC’s Middle East unit became the first Western bank to issue a sukuk last May with a $500 million Islamic bond carrying a maturity of five years. French bank Credit Agricole has said it is considering issuing an Islamic bond or creating a wider sukuk program that could lead to several issues.

Unlike HSBC with its HSBC Amanah brand, however, Goldman does not have an established presence in the Islamic banking sector, and its entry into the market has caused controversy.

Khan said the prospectus had informed investors that the sukuk should only be traded at par value, and had warned investors there was not expected to be a secondary market in the instrument. He argued that the Goldman deal had a legitimate murabaha structure.

Goldman has said that its sukuk could be denominated in United Arab Emirates dirhams, dollars, Saudi riyals or Singapore dollars.

Reuters