Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Thu, May 24, 2012
Archive Search
January 29, 2012 | by Armando Siahaan

Jakarta Journo: Lessons Learned From a Deadly Crash

The accident close to Tugu Tani in Central Jakarta on Sunday claimed the lives of nine pedestrians. (JG Photo/Yudhi Sukma Wijaya) The accident close to Tugu Tani in Central Jakarta on Sunday claimed the lives of nine pedestrians. (JG Photo/Yudhi Sukma Wijaya)

What happened a week ago this morning was a tragedy. After a night of clubbing, a heavily intoxicated woman smashed into 12 people with a Daihatsu Xenia, killing 9 of them, including a 2-year-old baby.

When the collision occurred, the first question that popped into my mind was: how many years will she spend behind bars?

Then we quickly learned that the charges being prepared against Afriani Susanti would carry a prison sentence of merely up to 12 years.

But those charges, some of which apply to her three companions in the car also, do not derive from the taking of those nine innocent lives. The culprit’s heaviest charge comes from the allegation she and her friends had been taking methamphetamine, ecstasy and alcohol.

This raises an obvious question. Does this country need a law on vehicular homicide, the act of murder resulting from the negligent use of a vehicle?

Based on Indonesia’s criminal code, the heaviest punishment one can get for killing people in a car accident, irrespective of the number of casualties, is six years in prison.

From a layman’s perspective, it doesn’t make sense. Six years for killing nine people?

The Indonesian legal system should start considering deadly collisions like this as second-degree murder. It may not be premeditated, but it is still murder.

A charge of vehicular manslaughter was applied once, in 1994, after a sleepy Metromini driver drove his bus into a river in Sunter, killing 32 passengers.

The driver, who attempted to run away, was captured and received 15 years in prison. Apparently, the Supreme Court has the power to apply such a penalty.

The Metromini case should be used as a precedent for the Xenia disaster, which should serve as a warning to reckless drivers.

Looked at in the larger context, we all know that this country, Jakarta especially, is no stranger to crazy motorists. Gigantic public buses, for example, are driven like sports cars that own the city. Many people treat our crowded city as if it was a Formula 1 circuit.

If these drivers know that their recklessness could result in murder charges, then there is a chance it could reduce the craziness.

This leads to another point. Indonesian law enforcers are not big on promoting a “Don’t drink and drive” campaign. Remember those stories last year about the number of cases where drunken motorists plunged into the Hotel Indonesia Circle fountain?

If Afriani is punished for vehicular homicide, hopefully that might cause people to think twice before driving under the influence.

Here’s another interesting point. In her confession, Afriani said that she had been at Stadium, the notorious multi-story disco in the Hayam Wuruk area. Afterwards, there were reports that city authorities would conduct drug raids on clubs and bars.

But will law enforcers have the guts to actually shut down those nightclubs in Jakarta that are well-known havens for drugs? Or will they simply target the consumers, while ignoring suppliers and dealers?

While punishing vehicular homicide is a top priority, cleaning the streets of drugs should also be a goal to keep in mind.

We all know that Afriani has taken her share of public anger, as evidenced by the merciless tide of rage distributed against her on the Internet and through social media.

But that’s not enough. What we need is justice. Drunk or not, reckless drivers who take the lives of others should be treated as murderers and we should take seriously the mission to rid the city of substances that turn people into reckless drivers.

Armando Siahaan is a reporter at the Jakarta Globe. Follow him on Twitter @jakartajourno or e-mail him at armando.siahaan@thejakartaglobe.com.

Share This Page
1
0
0
1
Share with google+ :
Post a comment

Please post your comment here! Comments will be moderated before they are published. Please take into account that your comment will not be displayed immediately.

Only links and plain text are allowed.

Write your comment within 1000 characters.

Please login to post comment


COMMENTS
NaufalFileindi
11:47pm Feb 14, 2012

"Does this country need a law on vehicular homicide, the act of murder resulting from the negligent use of a vehicle?" - We do. Check the UU Lalu Lintas.

"The Indonesian legal system should start considering deadly collisions like this as second-degree murder" - Indonesia's legal system doesn't recognise 'second degree murder'. It's a term used in the Common Law.

" irrespective of the number of casualties" - our legal system doesn't recognise cumulative penalties. So, if you murder 9 people, the sentence would still be like if you did 1 murder.

"The Metromini case should be used as a precedent for the Xenia disaster" - The Metromini Case is a misused example of the manslaughter article. Studies have showed that.

"This leads to another point. Indonesian law enforcers are not big on promoting a “Don’t drink and drive” campaign" - There isn't any law that forbids explicitly on drink driving or driving drunk.

  • Previous
  • 1
  • Next
Follow Us on Twitter
About Jakarta Journo

Also a weekly column in the Jakarta Globe, Jakarta Journo takes an irreverent look at the main issues dominating the headlines in Indonesia.

MORE JAKARTA JOURNO POSTS
MOST READ ON JG BLOGS

Schweinsteiger, the Tragic Hero

The First and Biggest Indonesia's Online Shopping Festival

Watatita: Do Not Abandon Our Indonesian Heritage

SSJ100 Accident: Reflections After a Week

Which Kind of Health Insurance Policies Are Necessary?

Keep It NBA: Pacing Back to Relevance

Great Sexpectations: The Danger of False Hope of a Budding Relationship

The Endless Effort of Women Survivors

RECENT COMMENTS ON JG BLOGS

2:18pm | Great Sexpectations: The Dange...
@OVOxo please do not insult Indonesian men. I have known many great Indonesian men who are way better than the so-called "more educated westerners

11:14am | Which Kind of Health Insurance...
just make you read the fineprint

10:59am | Schweinsteiger, the Tragic Her...
Schweinsteiger literally translates as Pig Climber. With a name that ridiculous you're destined to fail in life.

10:43am | Great Sexpectations: The Dange...
"Tame Indonesian boys" That's true, they're all about 5'2 and look like kids.

8:32am | The First and Biggest Indonesi...
I ordered something from this website and when I tried to follow up after I paid I got the runaround from automated messages. There was no contact
COLUMNS

Ask Atheists, Christians, Shiites and Ahmadis: Indonesia Is No Model for Muslim Democracy

For Businesses, Going Green Begins at the Office and Ends With a Profit

The Thinker: Good Neighbors

When in Singapore, Act Like a Singaporean

The Thinker: Let Yogya Be Yogya

Would High-Speed Railways in Indonesia Be a Fast Track to Wasted Money and Disaster?

Ethnic and Religious Criteria Still Steer Indonesian Democracy

Are You Gambling With Your Money?

Safety 360: Lightning Risks Higher Than Most Believe

Is the Philippines Ready to Become An Economic Leader in the Region?