Bank Century: Will Indonesia's Top Officials Survive the Fallout?
Janeman Latul & Muhammad Al Azhari | September 07, 2009
Related articles
Sri Mulyani Backers Want Political Party Law Reviewed 4:48pm Jun 15, 2011
Senior Democrat Wants Sri Mulyani To Represent Party in 2014 Race 10:38am Jun 4, 2011
Ex-Bank Century Owner Dragged Back to Court For New Trial 12:33pm Apr 29, 2011
Sri Mulyani Causes a Stir on Her Return 3:40pm Apr 9, 2011
Boediono Urges Tough Line With Reform Program 9:17am Feb 17, 2011
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
328380If I were to produce a movie on this issue, I'd title this film "TARP THE SEQUEL'. An appopriate title, don't you think so?
The irony here after all the ballyhoo, are that most critics are still underwhelmed by this move. We need to spur more ferocious debates on this. How many "bail outs" have we read about in the last decade? This is becoming endemic in Indonesia not to mention diabolical.
Although beating up on the Banks may be politically and morally satisfying, it's beside the point. We need to eradicate bad deals and punish all the wrongdoers. The powers to be are seeing the signs written on the wall and if they decide to continue to be reticent towards this problem, the economy of Indonesia will remain depressed.
Let me repeat a posting I made recently:
"These simple rules of discrimation are common among the world's businessmen and politicians. In deciding between whose favor they should curry and whom they should attack, they all tend to grovel before the wealthy and powerful and act viciously toward the poor and weak."
Nathan, I''ll stand in queue with you if such a periodical can be made available. Just in case a propsective publisher needs a good title, I would suggest "THE NAKED TRUTH' - (Unexpurgated)
You’re right Valk, I’m starting to see the pattern of cheap Journalism. Hopefully Indonesian press will soon realize that there are many of us interested in quality reporting and that they can make tangible profits out of that (through subscription or more advertisements).
Indonesia suffers from transparency problems. Private sector often blames the government’s bureaucracy and corruption for creating high cost economy; while Businesses are as guilty when they – on a daily basis - manipulate accounting, raise prices through monopoly and price fixing.
Nathan, not in your wildest dreams it will happen. I have tried with several related controversial issues on other sites and you can guess, what happened!
It's very frustrating indeed! Reports only lead us to trek along the perimeters and we always will be up against the wall when endeavouring an attempt to permeate further.
I personally will never stop and I hope others like yourself, will from to time join in the crusade for the betterment of this nation.
JG writers, regardless the controversy, can you elaborate more with Investigative Journalism? I wouldn’t mind paying for the content; I am referring to more financial detail of this bank and others.
American University School of Communication runs an online report which tracks American banks’ financial health. They post information such as assets, deposits, non-performing loans, troubled asset ratio; this type of information on Indonesian banks would be very useful for the public. JG, can you publish or elaborate on where readers can find such information?
Off course it is common knowledge that many - if not most of Indonesian companies cook their books to the level beyond anyone’s wildest dreams. However, more public exposure will result in more public scrutiny – applied on their financial reporting.
The government and the press share the responsibility in educating the public to avoid this bailout event from occurring in the future.
- Previous
- 1
- Next
Economic and political analysts said over the weekend that the Rp 6.7 trillion ($663.3 million) Bank Century bailout controversy would not generate enough political steam to put serious pressure on two of the country’s most senior officials — Vice President-elect Boediono, the former Bank Indonesia governor, and reform icon Sri Mulyani Indrawati, the finance minister and acting chief economics minister.
“I don’t think the case is strong enough to have them removed from office. This Century fiasco has been hijacked by a number of political interest groups to attack their track records,” said Adrinof Chaniago, a political analyst at the University of Indonesia.
“It is definitely the central bank’s mess if we look into the case closely. That means that Boediono is the one who is primarily responsible, but he won’t go down unless they find he did something illegal,” he said. “I think that some of the central bank’s management will be forced to step aside because of this, but Boediono will remain untouchable.”
Poerbaya Yudi Sadewa, an economist at the state-owned Danareksa Institute think tank, said the market’s perceptions of Sri Mulyani and Boediono as reformers remained unchanged, despite the Century imbroglio.
“It’s hard to blame them for what they did as the economic crisis was then at its height,” he said. “Century’s failure could have posed a big threat to our financial system, even though the bank’s problems were mainly caused by the bank’s owner.”
He agreed with Adrinof that the fiasco would have little chance of seeing Sri Mulyani or Boediono kicked out of office, although he added that the findings of the Supreme Audit Agency (BPK) would have to be published before it became clear what really happened.
“Silence on the part of both Boediono and Sri Mulyani is a good tactic to keep the markets calm,” he added.
Lawmakers and pressure groups have ratcheted up criticism of the roles played by Boediono, who was BI governor when the bailout took place in November 2008, and Sri Mulyani, who was finance minister. It is alleged that huge amounts of taxpayer funds were spent to save big depositors with the bank, including one of the country’s biggest business families, the Sampoernas, state-owned tin miner PT Timah, and state pension fund PT Jamsostek.
Natsir Mansyur, a lawmaker from the Golkar Party and a member of House Commission XI, which oversees the financial sector, urged President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono on Sunday to suspend Sri Mulyani as finance minister and chairwoman of the Financial System Stability Committee (KSSK), arguing that she was ultimately responsible for the affair.
Andi Rachmat, a legislator from the Prosperous Justice Party (PKS), said the House was seeking a Supreme Court clarification as to whether the bailout was legal, although the government has repeatedly stated that it was entirely legal under the Indonesia Deposit Insurance Corporation Law.
“We are going to seek the Supreme Court’s opinion on this,” he said.
Meanwhile, Danang Widoyoko, the chairman of Indonesia Corruption Watch, insisted on Saturday that the bailout had primarily benefited large-scale depositors.
“Big depositors withdrew Rp 5.6 trillion from the bank between December 2008 and July of this year,” Danang said. “They’re the ones who took advantage of the situation.”
Iman Sugema, an economist at the Institute for Development of Economics and Finance (Indef), blamed the controversy on Bank Indonesia’s failure to take robust action, rather than endemic weaknesses in the supervisory system.
“The bank had problems since 2003 but no firm action was taken by the regulators,” he said.
“They claimed the bank was too important to fail, but this is only a small bank. Its assets only account for about 0.05 percent of all the assets in the banking system."
- ‘The Phantom of the Opera’ Unveils Itself to Jakarta Audience
- Malaysian Girl Speaks Indonesian After Freak Accident: Report
- Indonesians Buying Up Most Expensive Homes in Singapore
- Funeral on Friday for Student Killed in Rafting Accident
- Adek Berry: The Lady Behind the Camera
- Indonesian Police Arrest Czech Tourist in Papua
- 7 Motorcycle Girls Arrested for Beating Up Their Own on Bali
- The Thinker: Let's Talk About Sex
- Indonesian Operators Ban Access to LGBT Advocacy Web Site
- Final Farewell to Singapore's Dr. Toh Chin Chye
-
4:35am | The Thinker: Let's Talk About ...
agentmacgyver, would you agree that common sense is not listed in the vocabulary... Why do girls and boys marry at an alarming young age bec -
2:03am | Axis of Hostility: Iran, Israe...
An Iran with nuclear powers could well be the beginning of the end of the world. alwa at 4:02 doesn't seem to realize that Iran is -
1:51am | Is Atheism Illegal in Indonesi...
It's amazing that the state puts itself above the Gods, and decides what six religions people are allowed to believe in in Indonesia. -
11:27pm | Indonesians Buying Up Most Exp...
@agentmacgyver, so it is not true you think ? perhaps I should rephrase it this way, 30% corrupt Indonesians (.. and 60% corrupt Indonesians who al -
11:08pm | Rehab, Not Jail for Lion Air P...
Hi Weegie Im a 59 year old who has been a regular vistor to Indonesia for 35 years I think that the crime and corruption is much greater per capita -
10:42pm | 12 Detainees Pull Off Brazen J...
Jailbreak happens all over the World Governments should give education and hope to the poor or else the Higly organised Mega Rich Crime will destro -
10:15pm | Notorious Gang Boss Could Be B...
Every Big city in the World has a huge crime problem So Jakarta no different. Honesty is the best policy. My father said to me when I was a young ... -
10:07pm | Israel’s Stance on Iran Could ...
Strike is a made up war from the free mason and illuminati, they need to justify a war to reduce the worlds population by 90%. A nwo will be create
