Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Fri, February 10, 2012
Archive Search

Depok to Shut Down Karaoke Houses
Camelia Pasandaran |

Share This Page
17
0
0
3
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

Valkyrie
6:57am Oct 7, 2009

PeterR:

are you observing the opposing ideals between Depok and Tanggerang? I am wondering what the "controlling factor" is. Kudos for "otonomi daerah."


santosoheru
5:51pm Oct 6, 2009

I think Nurmahmudi should also shut down hotels in Depok then. Hotels can be dangerous and can be used by people to conduct adultery (if that's what the Depok's government want to prevent by shutting down karaoke house).

Anyway, I'm not surprised. He's from PKS. He wants to make Depok the Javanese version of Aceh.


peterR
11:20am Oct 6, 2009

Surely the way to go is not to shut down places that people go to enjoy karaoke but to supervise them properly. Or is that to simple? Or just maybe, it would not seem sufficient enough reaction for their main purpose of sucking up to certain groups?


  • Previous
  • 1
  • Next

The Depok municipal administration in West Java said it will close all karaoke businesses in the city, saying local bylaws don’t permit them.

Administration spokesman Fachmi Muhamad said authorities would begin closing establishments which violated local regulations.

The Public Order Agency was reported to have set a deadline of Sunday for all karaoke operators to voluntarily close or face forced closure.

“Some of the businesses opened karaoke houses but requested permits for restaurants or music studios,” Fachmi said. “However, under Depok bylaws, karaoke houses are not categorized as recreational businesses so they should never have been opened.”

Under the 2003 bylaws covering permits for tourism businesses, recreational businesses are said to include swimming pools, bowling allies, billiard halls, event venues, movie theaters, fitness clubs, and art and cultural studios. There is no mention of karaoke houses, which are hugely popular.

Several ulama earlier this year asked the government to ban karaoke houses, alleging they were places used for immoral acts. Some are used as fronts for brothels.

Depok has been criticized previously for enacting Shariah-style laws. Depok Mayor Nur Mahmudi Ismail is from the Islam-based Prosperous Justice Party (PKS).

There are at least three karaoke houses which are well known in Depok: Nav, Inul Vista and Venus.

Rini, a 34-year-old housewife and a Depok resident, said the government was overreacting.

“My two children like to go to karaoke houses,” she said. “But the places have been shut down.”

She said the government’s reason to ban karaoke houses in Depok was unreasonable.

“It is better for those who like to sing to go to karaoke houses than sing loudly with a home sound system that may disturb their neighbors,” she said.

Rini said she often took her children to Nav karaoke house but did not find it a dangerous place.

“It is a safe place, where children can spend time with their families,” she said. “It’s not like other karaoke houses, which have seedy elements to them.”

“However, if the government did not agree with this business, it should have shut the karaoke houses much earlier, not now when they’ve been operating for this long a time and people have grown to like them,” she said.




  • 9:24am | Shocking Images Show Animal Cr...
    Shocking and its not the double standard the upsets me , its human nature as a whole....
  • 9:15am | The Thinker: Let's Talk About ...
    We need comprehensive sexuality education here. Without good sex ed, people run to porn to satisfy their curiosity. We all know porn is not good pl
  • 9:06am | Malaysian Girl Speaks Indonesi...
    I do hope that nobody in the Ministry of Education reads this article. God knows what they will do to the new curriculum.
  • 9:04am | Shocking Images Show Animal Cr...
    Will there be a ban imposed on their own domestic cattle industry ? Hmm... less likely... Then why did they quickly impose a ban on us ? Fu
  • 8:57am | Indonesian President’s New Pla...
    The headline of this article is presuming that at some stage in the future Indonesia will actually have a "Leader". I am sure everyone is lookin
  • 8:55am | ‘Rude’, ‘Anonymous’ Tweeters B...
    I have to admit that I really don't like rude, senseless and ignorant comments on the net. But I think regulation on such comment by the governmen
  • 8:54am | Indonesians Buying Up Most Exp...
    Following the Asian crisis in the late 90's, billions of dollars were robbed from Indonesia by the politicians and bureaucrats. It has be said th
  • 8:45am | Nasrep, Tommy and the Smiling ...
    @Trueblue: Thank you for your comments. I actually agree with more consolidation of Indonesian political parties. First of all, it w