Last updated at 1:30 AM. Friday 19 March 2010

Go to comments January 07, 2010

Dessy Sagita

Technicians fixing a door on a Transjakata bus. (JG Photo)

Technicians fixing a door on a Transjakata bus. (JG Photo)

Fare Deal? No, Say Critics of Jakarta's Busway

An attempt by the Jakarta Transportation Agency to increase the fare for the inefficient and problem-plagued TransJakarta busway has sparked howls of protest from the City Council and the Indonesian Consumers Foundation.

“With the bad service they provide and their poor safety records, the idea of increasing the busway fare is completely ridiculous,” Andyka, a member of the City Council, told the Jakarta Globe on Wednesday.

Andyka, from the Great Indonesia Movement Party (Gerindra), said increasing the Rp 3,500 (38 cents) fare without improving the service could convince many busway users to switch back to private vehicles.

“The busway has just started to appeal to road users as a decent transportation system,” Andyka said. “If we increase the fare without making any positive changes, they’ll go back to using their cars and the traffic jams will get even worse.”

Earlier this week, Hendah Sunugroho, head of the land transportation division at the Transportation Agency, said he was considering proposing a fare increase for the busway to reduce the subsidy provided to the system by the Jakarta administration.

He declined, however, to say how big any proposed fare increase would be.

Any proposed increase, however, would have to be approved by Jakarta Governor Fauzi Bowo and the City Council.

Andyka said there was nothing to necessitate a fare increase, such as a rise in fuel prices.

He also said the TransJakarta Management Body (BLU) should improve its infrastructure and safety performance before any fare increases were discussed.

“Some corridors have been ready for more than a year but the buses are still not available. The corridors have been damaged even before they have been used,” he said.

Tulus Abadi, chairman of the Indonesian Consumers Foundation (YLKI), said the Transportation Agency should focus on improving its performance rather than increasing fares.

“The busway has not yet proved to be a fast and reliable form of mass transportation for Jakartans,” Tulus said. “Asking the public to pay more for such a poor performance is definitely wrong.”



Post a comment

Login or register to post comments!

Comments

peterR

6:03 PM January 7, 2010

Same old story as far as I can see. Cheapest build; bad planning; lack of expertise, and no determination to make it work. Just loads of hype and sound-bites. And most probably riddled with corrupt practices from the off.

Simon P

3:55 PM January 7, 2010

Usual problem, not enough cash spent on it. It could be so much better. Some of the ramps are pretty dangerous too. And when are they going to open the Gatot Subroto corridor??? The shelters were built a year ago and are already looking shabby before anyone's even used them. As for fare prices, a balance must be struck. If the price goes up, less people will use the service for sure so it's not necessarily going to make the system more money.

Leslie_Williams

3:25 PM January 7, 2010

I have been resident in Jakarta now for some 15 months and am a regular user of Transjakarta - also a strong advocate for the services it provides. Whilst it is encouraging to see some of the shelters on Corridor 1 - in particular Harmoni Interchange - being extended to facilitate easier passenger movement, it is sad to see how much overall services have deteriorated during this period. In the beginning, I could rely on a maximum wait of 10 minutes and then find buses arriving in groups of three, but now, regardless of on which corridor I am traveling there are no such things as "schedules" any more - or if there are, they are certainly not adhered-to.

It would also appear that there are grossly insufficient funds allocated to regular Repairs and Maintenance to both Plant and Equipment. As an example, entry roller-doors and one passenger sliding door at Sumber Waras shelter were "rusak" for a period in excess of six months before recently being repaired. The deterioration of the bus fleet - in particular the original units operating on the Kota/Blok M route is saddening - broken interior panels not replaced, rubber weather strips on doors missing, seat covers torn and most buses in a general state of dis-repair.

It is imperative that a fleet maintenance programme is established and followed-through meticulously to maintain the value and reliability of the the existing bus fleet and to protect the huge capital investment made in the existing fleet and the 130+ units which are projected to be purchased in the coming year. Vehicles which should still be in prime condition give the appearance of being in excess of 10 years old.

Before even thinking about a fare increase, Transjakarta's management must get their act in order - establish schedules and maintain these (get authorities working to keep private vehicles out of dedicated bus lanes), maintain the bus fleet and shelters to make people want to travel - and give the already-pleasant and courteous staff a product of which they can be justifiably proud.

Perhaps senior management - and government officials who are charged with overseeing Transjakarta and the facilities and services it provides - should be compelled to regularly ride as passengers on each Transjakarta Corridor so they can see first-hand where the inadequacies exist. Let them see for themselves how the Security personnel so prevalent at Harmoni in non-peak periods manage to "vanish" when they are needed most. Let them experience conditions such as at Duku Atas 2 on any peak period (forget about holiday times with crowds waiting to travel to Ragunan), attempt to board a Kalideres bus during peak hours at Senen Central - and having to "run the gauntlet between parked buses" at Pologadung Terminal at any time of day or night whilst in transit between corridors. I'm sure that if this were the case, we would soon see a dramatic improvement in services across-the-board - and also some very shocked and at times distressed officials.

Get the remaining corridors open - so that the system is operational in its entirety - as a matter of top priority - publish clear and easily-interpreted route maps and make these readily-available to intending passengers (and then adhere to the published routes!) - keep to schedules and provide clean, well-maintained buses and shelters - and Transjakarta will be well on track to building its reputation and gaining support from its passenger-base.