Is This Statue So Divisive it Has to Go? In Bekasi, Yes
Zaky Pawas, Ulma Haryanto & Arientha Primanita | May 19, 2010
The ‘Tiga Mojang’ statue of three women wearing traditional Sundanese clothing at a housing complex in Bekasi. (JG Photo/Yudhi Sukma Wijaya) Related articles
New Study Finds Very Few Islamic Terrorists US 9:23am Feb 8, 2012
Graft, Paybacks and Religion Shake the Maldives 9:31pm Feb 6, 2012
Indonesia’s Islamic Vigilantes ‘Turning to Terrorism’ 7:15pm Jan 26, 2012
Muslim Activists Scuttle Rushdie Video Address 9:43pm Jan 24, 2012
Radical Islamists Main Threat Against Norway: Intelligence 9:39pm Jan 17, 2012
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
375787So I guess all the pictures of the president and vice president in Bekasi government offices, schools etc have to go to? They portray human beings.
Better check with Murhali I think.
It must also be haram to posses a passport because it has the image of a human being.
Although in the case of many of these protestors that could be argued I guess.
Just a small point. Does it really have to be destroyed. I am quite happy to put it in my gardens, behind the maze and next to the gazebo and gaze at it while sipping my Bintang.
Username - you are of course correct when you say, " These people never have and never will represent or act in the name of Islam and the people of Indonesia." Unfortunately no one in public office - the President, the army, the politicians, the police, appear to have the guts to stand up and say so. And because of this, confusion is reigning - and these thugs are getting away with crimes against the State and people of Indonesia by disregarding human rights disrupting public order. The question are - Why are they being allowed to get away with it? Why will no one in authority speak out and act against them?
I keep asking these questions and no one will answer me.
I think I know the answers.
It's fortunate that the pea-brained goons who defaced this (in my opinion not bad-looking) statue can't get into the Bogorian Palace Grounds and destroy the statues that are on display there. What in the world has happened to tolerance and wise, cool reasoning? I hate to say this, but under the late Soeharto's reign extreme Muslim groups wouldn't have dared to do what they do now.
It's the Banyam Buddhas all over again. No human forms allowed ay? Well the FPI may wish to have a go at some of the statues of war and independence struggle heroes in town in that case, that should bring this whole depressing Islamo-fascist/Nationalist conflict to a head.
The Bekasi municipal authorities, apparently bowing to pressure from hard-line Muslim groups, have ordered the destruction of an imposing steel statue of three women in a private residential development.
The 17-meter-tall statue, “Tiga Mojang” (“Three Girls”), by leading sculptor Nyoman Nuarta, depicts three Sundanese women in traditional attire. It is also known as the welcome statue of Bekasi’s Harapan Indah residential complex.
“Bekasi Mayor Mochtar Mohammad has officially [told] the residential complex’s developer, PT Hasanah Damai Putra, to destroy the statue within 21 days,” Bekasi Police Chief Sr. Comr. Imam Haryanto told the Jakarta Globe on Tuesday. He said the decision was reached in a meeting of the municipal administration, local ulemas and the property developer on Monday.
On Friday, about 1,000 members from 60 hard-line Islamic organizations protested for hours at the site of the statue, and spray-painted it and covered it with white cloth. The protesters, from the Islamic Defenders Front, (FPI), the Bekasi Front Against Apostates, the Islamic Missionary Council (DDI) and the Islamic Ummah Forum, claimed that the statue incorrectly represented the communities in Bekasi.
The protest followed attacks in Bekasi this month on a Catholic school and the forced closure of a church a month earlier.
“This was done to avoid conflict among the people of Bekasi and so that security and some peace can be restored,” Imam said.
Murhali Barda, head of FPI Bekasi, said the mayor was wrong if he thought the people were only protesting the statue itself.
“That is not the main reason. The statue is illegal because it has no permit. In any case, the people of Bekasi completely reject that statue. It portrays the form of living beings, and that is forbidden,” Murhali said.
Islam prohibits picturing human beings as this could be seen as an attempt at copying God, and thus an act of transgression.
But a Bekasi administration spokesman, Endang Suharyadi, said: “The statue does not possess an IMB [permit to be built]. It must come down. If after the time limit developers do not demolish it, the administration will. There has been no move so far from the developers to get a permit for this.
“Yes, I agree, there has been pressure from local communities to bring it down. [But] in fact, one of the requirements for a permit to be issued is to secure approval from locals that the structure can be built.”
Sociologist Ganda Upaya, from the University of Indonesia, said the incident showed that these groups were trying to force their brand of values. “That is why in a pluralistic society like ours, respecting differences has to be taught and reminded over and over again,” he said.
The artist, Nuarta, has several public works on show in Jakarta, including the grandiose statue of Arjuna’s chariot at the southwest entrance to the National Monument park.
- Another Indonesian Pilot Busted in Airline Drug Test
- ‘The Phantom of the Opera’ Unveils Itself to Jakarta Audience
- 12 Detainees Pull Off Brazen Jakarta Jail Break
- Indonesia Property Demand to Rise With Economy
- Bali’s Rising Violent Crime Rate Could Threaten Tourism Industry
- Sumitomo Bets on Indonesia’s Growing Need for Electricity
- Malaysian Girl Speaks Indonesian After Freak Accident: Report
- Indonesian Police Arrest Czech Tourist in Papua
- Jakarta 'Healer' Touches Clients’ Penises to ‘Remove Evil Spirits’
- Indonesians Buying Up Most Expensive Homes in Singapore
-
12:27pm | Justice Minister Removed From ...
ETHICS = a system of moral principles. "Ethics Board" in Indonesian Government..gimme a break! -
12:22pm | Editorial: When 240 Million Mo...
One major and drastic move to ensure food security is to educate our people to shift from eating less rice and noodles. Rice is a cr -
12:17pm | Indonesians Buying Up Most Exp...
Money laundering at its best. New high end condominiums in Singapore will start selling in Jakarta first before they sell to locals. Of course, in -
12:14pm | Indonesia Property Demand to R...
Taking into consideration of Indonesia's surging economy, growing urbanisation, relative political stability, strong savings and income growth, co -
12:11pm | Justice Minister Removed From ...
Hmm....that was a swift decision by the president. At that talk show,a noted personality said something to the effect that a true leader has -
12:10pm | Foreigners Buy a Third of Priv...
What's the point? Indonesians who probably buy expensive homes in Singapore are of the few rich Chinese families. Don't they count as Chin -
11:58am | The Thinker: Let's Talk About ...
Inconclusive findings..besides, stats for 717 students in basically one territory is not good sample size. Assuming that the data are enough -
11:56am | Malaysian Girl Speaks Indonesi...
There is a thin line that divides fact from fantasy and in Noraini's case of suddenly being able to speak Bahasa Indonesia, Mandarin, Japanese and
