Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Thu, May 24, 2012
Archive Search

Letter to the Editor: Study Indonesia First, Don’t Bash Opinions
Yohanes Sulaiman | February 21, 2012

Share This Page
1
0
0
55
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

nonredneck
10:42pm Feb 23, 2012

DD: While I agree with you absolutely on the concept of trust & core-team, this is not applicable in labor-union vs. bussines-assoc.

I put "vs." because this is the current view, there is no trust (on national level) between employees & employers.

This level of family-like trust at your company, is highly unlikely to happen at national level.

And your suspicion that the workforce are just being used as pawns, I have no doubt.

But as I previously mentioned to SAKB, there is no way to manipulate the workers IF the path to progress is focused on advancing the worker's skill, capability, & their own efficiency through training & learning programs funded by labor-union vs. bussines-assoc. Win-win-screwgovt situation.


nonredneck
10:41pm Feb 23, 2012

SAKB: You said "I'm not advocating violence at all. In the history of labour struggles it's pretty clear which is the violent side."

Of course, none of us are advocating violence, BUT, can you prevent violence?

When the emotion is high on the street, the air is dusty-hot-stuffy-sweaty, the shout on loud speakers not heard, provocator/infiltrator started with little talk here &there,

one thing leads to another, before you know it,

the tiniest spark turned into wildfire, we're no gandhi.

And remember this, any side resorting to violence is a guaranteed to get violent replies, all sides will bleed.


nonredneck
10:39pm Feb 23, 2012

SAKB: Don't think yohanes includes himself in this group of people who explicitly/implicitly want to run others' lives.

As for Reagan: I know u're anti-reagan, anti-hitler, anti-stalin, anti-imperial, anti-liberal, anti-religion, anti-fascist, anti-monarchy, anti-authoritarian, anti-socialist,etc basically anti-everything. So what aren't you anti- of ?

Ur question: "So where's Indonesia's empoyEEs' association?"

Here: http://www.thejakartaglobe.com/news/indonesian-activists-worry-about-unions-growth/499895

We both know how this "union" or "association" will be abused if the "protest path" is encouraged from within. There is no way to prevent infiltration, all organizations are prone to this.

However through the path of upgrading skills, improving efficiency, learning new techniques or new 'how to'-[create/fix sth], etc all the programs which enable its members to enhance themselves for future use, what is there to manipulate ??


DrDez
2:37pm Feb 23, 2012

EJ

The pendulum has swung too far of that I am certain. when it swings back it will no doubt do more damage - as is the way of most things

On this debate, its fair to say that all parties are actually right, certainly from where they stand

My own fear is that the workforce are just being used as pawns - and to what ends??

But as NRN suggests I am perhaps prone to looking on the darker side and so I am sure like all reasonable men they will sit around and find a solution.. I predict new cars for the union leaders as the short term solution


SirAnthonyKnown-Bender
2:20pm Feb 23, 2012

"Anyway, I am bowing out from this debate. This is not a productive use of my time."

I see, very hoity. Well you get to ya Reagonomics classes then. Good luck Sir.


I would like to thank Mr. Sigfried S. Looho for his comments. While Mr. Looho raised many interesting points in his reply to my Feb. 3 article titled “When It Comes to Taming Labor Unions, Indonesia Can Learn a Lot From Reagan,” unfortunately his replies were marred by careless reading.

Let me address his third point first, which is built upon grave mischaracterization of my argument. I argued that trust in the Indonesian judiciary is declining, which would raise the issue of fairness, whether the court is influenced by the moneyed interests or the pitch-fork-wielding mob. Regardless of who wins, there will be someone crying foul: thus the difficulties to rely on the judiciary as the disinterested party.

Mr. Looho, however, seems to argue that the workers should instead disregard the judiciary system because “lawsuits are long and expensive.” While such action would seem to be appropriate from the comforts of the ivory tower in the prosperous and stable the United States or Great Britain, without trust in law enforcement, could any state function?

Like I argued in one of my recent articles, people then would rely on the mob, causing social and religious conflicts. Such anarchic condition, which will cost many in terms of property and even life, seems to be a welcomed development for Mr. Looho. Unfortunately, Indonesia had enough of its share of social unrest, which happened in the early years of Reformation and caused much economic and social hardship, and not to mention deaths. A second helping is not welcomed.

In fact, such was the fear of many Indonesians that the anarchic actions by labor unions and many other groups are not that popular. In my article I suggested the labor unions behave strategically, ensuring that the population remains behind their back thanks to their orderly and wise course of actions. Thus the lesson from Reagan: because people do not like massive public discomfort, unions should avoid causing just that.

In short, I believe the esteemed commenter must carefully consider what’s going on in Indonesia before embarking upon such opinion bashing.

Yohanes Sulaiman is a lecturer at Indonesian Defense University (Unhan).




  • 9:29pm | Nearly Every High School Stude...
    I can already imagine how many future Nobel prize laureate will be coming from the ranks of these students. And of course how many Nobel Prize winn
  • 9:28pm | Lady Gaga Refuses to Tone Down...
    Ladygaga is my new heroine, she has more balls than our President and so-called majority peace-loving moderate but silent Muslims.. Now bataks shou
  • 9:24pm | Update: Australia, Indonesia D...
    blightyboy, The cases emerged my friend was pointing out were in their late thirties up to late forties. Most of the cases go indetected according
  • 9:06pm | Most Still Unaware of Indonesi...
    tell that to the journalist that just got stabbed by the government minister. The US needs to hurry up and sell these apes some artillery so they c
  • 9:02pm | Indonesia ‘Most Tolerant Count...
    Jubal.Harshaw: post of the day sir.
  • 8:47pm | Most Still Unaware of Indonesi...
    Good one, i believe it's the first country in the region(S.E.Asia) doing so, beside Australia and kiwi.
  • 8:36pm | Some Experts Say Indonesia's B...
    @JohnnyFool I strongly believe everyone is entitled to speak freely on any topic . Those thugs have so many different fundamental b
  • 8:29pm | Indonesia ‘Most Tolerant Count...
    22 - read the artice - most the people they reffering to are Indonesians NOT overseas. Its ok anyway because Indons have the highes