Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Thu, May 24, 2012
Archive Search

SBY and His Ministers Need to Stop Playing Footsie With the Hard-Liners
Bramantyo Prijosusilo | September 30, 2011


Share This Page
0
1
0
6
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

DrDez
1:23pm Sep 30, 2011

Can't really add much more to Roland and Maurice's posts = good article

Asoe - No it just gets worse and worse for ever - look towards the ME for several examples - We also have the potential to be much much worse because of our ingrained ethnic issues too -

I have said it before the elite et al have created and sponsored a monster believing they could always control it - but as soon as they started supporting radical arabic Islamic influences then they made a fatal error - people will do the most heinous crimes for God and in their hearts think it is ok -


Asoegenie
1:06pm Sep 30, 2011

Since violence begets violence, my only hope is that the negativity and downright evil within the ranks of hardliner Muslims will ultimately destroy them and their deviant faith. Islam as is now practiced by many in Indonesia and many other countries has far deviated from when it called itself "The Religion of Peace." It will destroy itself.


Roland
12:22pm Sep 30, 2011

Mr Bramantyo Prijosusilo - I did like your article very much and I do hope that the majority of Indonesians would embrace your thoughts and your proposed actions.

However, I do believe that due to systematic misinformation in schools even the young generation does not have a clear opinion about the sad state of affairs in their own country. For the older generation I believe all hope is lost to embrace their power to stand up against the mal-service the government is providing for them. There are a few factors for this.

- Lack of education (this counts for at least 70% of Indonesia;s population).

- A strong religious influence of local clerics who refuse to provide their congregations with clear thoughts. Reasons for that are loss of their local power bases and in many cases loss of financial contributions provided by the very same groups who want to destroy Indonesia.

- Complete apathy in regards of the political situation, also due to the influence of TV. If one turns to local channels all can be seen is escape from reality via hour long shows about the life of celebrities, brainless soap operas, permanent product advertisement to consume even more and more and more, pseudo-religious TV preachers, police shows (however seldom about the real white collar criminals supposedly leading our country into a better future - logical though because they do own the TV stations) but as good as never a critical voices pointing out the dire state of affairs. Or, if they are for once willing to show something critical are getting pressured by hardliners, with the support of the law enforcement (because they simply resort to non-action to "not offend") - one example would be the recent cancelled movie "?" by SCTV

- lack of a real middle class which could make a change in the political landscape. So far, a majority of Indonesians have to count every day every Rupiah to survive the next day and these people can easily be bought with a kilo of rice, a t-shirt and a small financial contribution. The ones who would not care for these cheap tricks to buy their votes are probably less than 20% of Indonesians, but unfortunately these 20% are in many cases also just the first generation of people who came so far and all their thoughts are not about political issues but about how to polish their image and to display their new found "wealth".

- And of course lack of law enforcement. May it be the police who is entangled in corruption cases itself and rather prefers to make headlines fighting petty crimes instead of the real culprits (we know why - because some of the REAL culprits are within their very own ranks), the sad state of justice itself, easy-handedly giving heavy sentences to people who disturb the moral (dictated by the very same hardliners they should actually fight) just to appease to them as pious, but fail completely to punish the ones who rob the country of every resource to build up a proper education system, infrastructure etc. which would then automatically open the eyes of the general population to the misdeeds of these people and would lift huge percentages of the population out of poverty.

So were we are standing is that voices promoting democracy and pointing out the imminent danger we are facing are getting not heard or they are getting intimidated (remember last year's case of the ICW fellow who got a beating but the perpetrators got never found and punished, despite assurances of the police), the vicious circle of lack of education, lack of infrastructure to keep the majority mindless and careless about the political state as their imminent worries are logically just within their personal problems to have a roof over their head and food on the table. I believe actually that it happens purposefully from a few directions like that. From the government itself, at least by the ones whose personal and political background suggests that they are not actual supporters for a democracy and also from the religious quarters which also knows well that they would quickly lose their lucrative power bases as soon people would be able to see behind the carefully set up stages, words and "moral" pressure points. The only ones we hear over and over again are the loud screamers, the various hard-line groups who are able to influence court proceedings, political decisions, who are able to intimidate the "little people", who are able destroy, kill, bomb...

Well, I stop now, because I start ranting all along, but there is one quote (I forgot though who said or wrote it) which goes at about like that " A true and strong democracy can only be achieved with a strong middle class" and I have all reasons to believe that this is true!


mauriceg
11:33am Sep 30, 2011

This is a great article. Thank you for reminding us that there are citizens out there who give a damn about Indonesia's sky falling, and that there are ways to and means to combat the hardliners.

For those outside these shores, i hope it serves to open some eyes as to the dark, evil powers that are being exercised to undermine Indonesia's fragile democracy.

Of course, if there was a leader in power who was not beholden to some corrupt and / or religious agenda, then this situation might not be so dire. It speaks volumes for the country described by President Obama as a model of religious tolerance one year ago, that it is clearly and undeniably murderously intolerant, and apparently so, by dint of certain governmental ministers' negligence or agenda.


TGIF
11:27am Sep 30, 2011

In this picture, I did not know that the hardliners wear converse shoes and jeans instead of sandals and white robes....LOL


Just as he did following the Cirebon Police mosque bombing in April, after last Sunday’s suicide bombing at a Solo church, the minister for communications and information technology, Tifatul Sembiring, announced his intent to block Web sites that could inspire terrorism.

Although he claims to have shut down 300 such sites, the main ones where you can monitor the development of pro-terror Islamism in Indonesia are still active and easy to access.

The most notable of these Web sites is perhaps the Arrahmah site, which is still condemning kafir (infidels, in Arabic) and salibis (a derogatory terms for Christians derived from the Arab word salib , meaning cross). It is also eloquent in cursing the government, the United States and the West in general, while bestowing praise upon the Taliban in Afghanistan, Osama bin Laden, the Bali bombers and others of their ilk.

In its discussion forum, you can find people who can teach visitors how to make a bomb at home, and others who attempt to egg visitors on to actually commit suicide in a martyrdom operation against the kafir.

That this site still operates prompts the question — what was on the 300 closed sites that were blocked?

Still fresh in our memory is the scandal of Arifinto, the lawmaker who was caught watching pornography during a plenary session in the legislature. Arifinto, who, like Tifatul, is from the Islam-inspired Prosperous Justice Party (PKS), lied at first, saying he was only opening a link in an e-mail. Later, he said he would resign, but this proved to be a lie too. Instead, he seems to be waiting for people to forget that he was among those advocating the controversial Anti-Pornography Law.

The fact that Tifatul backed his PKS colleague’s lie is a black mark against his judgement. Considering his fundamentalist views on women and HIV/AIDS patients, the minister appears to share some things in common with Islamic hard-liners.

It is worth remembering that the PKS has its roots in the Muslim Brotherhood movement that began in Egypt and entered Indonesia via university campus mosques in the 1980s.

So it comes as no surprise that even though Tifatul claims to be working hard at making the Internet less of a useful tool for terrorists, Web sites like those of the Islamic Defenders Front (FPI), al-Muhajirun, VOA-Islam and others are still updating frequently, employing radicalizing language that foments hatred against the state, the West, Jews and Christians.

Of course all this is part of the larger movement to make Indonesia a Shariah state. They should be seen as part of the same ideological struggle that has manifested itself in the brutal murders of the Ahmadis in Cikeusik, Banten, the stabbing of a minister in Bekasi, the lame prison sentences these criminals received and the audacity of the Bogor mayor who continues to defy a Supreme Court ruling ordering him to allow the Yasmin Christian congregation to worship in its own church.

Before we blame President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono’s incompetence for the rise of Islamic radicalism here, we must remember that it was Suharto who, approaching the end of his rule, began to court Islamists.

At that time, analysts observed that the military was polarizing into two groups: the Islamists and the nationalists. Suharto’s successor, B.J. Habibie, further emboldened the Islamists. It was during his rule that the guard-dog organization (according to WikiLeaks) FPI was formed by elements of the military and the police.

Since then, the Islamist faction of Indonesian politics has flourished. Even Hizbut Tahrir, the transnational Islamist party that rejects this republic’s democracy outright and agitates for the establishment of a caliphate that will cure all our social, political, economical and cultural ills, receives support from the state.

Of course Yudhoyono, in his capacity as head of government, could do much more than merely expressing his concern, and his lack of action triggers speculation as to why he is so accommodating toward anti-state movements that carry religious banners. Waiting for this government to make an intelligent move is like waiting for Godot: it will never happen.

Many of us have been observing that often terrorist attacks occur at times when the government is under pressure over corruption cases. Most can see that there are members of the elite who profit from the attention given to these attacks.

Although this cynicism might be misplaced, it is not without reason given that not a single major corruption case has been solved during Yudhoyono’s time in office. But then again, all the previous governments were just as useless on this issue, or in regards even worse.

Perhaps the more useful question should be, considering that the government is doing nothing to stem religious violence and instead often “supports” it, what should we, as citizens, do?

Perhaps the best thing we can do is to support the fight against corruption. We can also give our support to the struggle for human rights. Minorities like Christians and Ahmadis need our backing, and cases like the 2004 murder of activist Munir Said Thalib or the murders of students and the rape of the Chinese during the 1998 troubles need to be pursued so that those responsible are held accountable.

In relation to jihadi Web sites, perhaps Tifatul needs some prodding. Send the minister letters, or sue for religious defamation Web sites that use derogatory terms to describe Christians. When the government is hopeless, citizens should come to the fore and save the day.

Bramantyo Prijosusilo is a writer, artist and broadcast journalist in East Java.




  • 9:29pm | Nearly Every High School Stude...
    I can already imagine how many future Nobel prize laureate will be coming from the ranks of these students. And of course how many Nobel Prize winn
  • 9:28pm | Lady Gaga Refuses to Tone Down...
    Ladygaga is my new heroine, she has more balls than our President and so-called majority peace-loving moderate but silent Muslims.. Now bataks shou
  • 9:24pm | Update: Australia, Indonesia D...
    blightyboy, The cases emerged my friend was pointing out were in their late thirties up to late forties. Most of the cases go indetected according
  • 9:06pm | Most Still Unaware of Indonesi...
    tell that to the journalist that just got stabbed by the government minister. The US needs to hurry up and sell these apes some artillery so they c
  • 9:02pm | Indonesia ‘Most Tolerant Count...
    Jubal.Harshaw: post of the day sir.
  • 8:47pm | Most Still Unaware of Indonesi...
    Good one, i believe it's the first country in the region(S.E.Asia) doing so, beside Australia and kiwi.
  • 8:36pm | Some Experts Say Indonesia's B...
    @JohnnyFool I strongly believe everyone is entitled to speak freely on any topic . Those thugs have so many different fundamental b
  • 8:29pm | Indonesia ‘Most Tolerant Count...
    22 - read the artice - most the people they reffering to are Indonesians NOT overseas. Its ok anyway because Indons have the highes