Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Fri, May 25, 2012
Archive Search

Editorial: Local Auto Industry Must Be Sustainable
January 09, 2012

Share This Page
1
1
0
8
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

enakajah
4:24pm Jan 9, 2012

In effect what the government is saying is that people like these students cannot go out, register a company, design, develop and seek finance to start their own car manufacturing business, because the government thinks it is their domain to dictate what you can and cannot do in industry. Can you imagine if Steve Jobs was Indonesian? It would have had to be a National computer not Apple. Bill Gates and National Windows not Microsoft..... Anything to get their hands on the money... You give foreigners far to much credit JPB most of the colonialism is domestic, the Dutch handed it over to domestic colonial elite and you still have not managed to get rid of them.

At least the last two paragraphs in the article show some reason in this 21st century world.

The government cannot allow........ And you blame foreigners..... Wake up. Use your vote wisely.


enakajah
4:14pm Jan 9, 2012

JPB- Marsuki said that the government cannot allow .... There plain as day is your colonialism... your elitist cronies that want to grab the money and not allow people like your goodself develop anything you want to. They think in terms of a National car.... Like Proton I suppose but how many other countries have a "national" car and how many car manufacturers are owned or controlled by the government? There is your colonialism... the megalomanic elitist government officials who do not think the people are entitled to privately make their own product.

Forget the foreigners you don't get that far, your own government puts a stop to it before they get a look in.

The arrogance is breathtaking by the clown Marsuki but his sentiments are that " give the common people a house, a job, food and roads and leave the elite to make the rules and govern. The common people are not intelligent enough" his words....


Jeanne Hachette
3:27pm Jan 9, 2012

Please stop blaming the foreigners for everything in this country. A lot of problems in this country is related to the desire of some local politicians and business men to make money quick, basically greed. It is much easier to start digging for coal than to set up a high tech company. I am living in the middle of the main industrial zones in East Jakarta and there are very gperformant Indonesian companies working for the Japanese automotive industry. One of the main problems is the lack of leadership. This country needs a president who has a clear idea about the future of the country, who can understand the country needs to focus on education if Indonesia wants to occupy the place it deserves. But unfortunately, it is easier to manipulate poor uneducated people during the election by giving them tshirt and instant noodle. Jchay, I agree with you, I cannot understand why most of the canned fruits here are coming from Thailand. This is a shame. But nothing to do with the colonial time


jchay
3:20pm Jan 9, 2012

@jpb: forget foreigners, at this point I just want us to believe that Indonesia must first free themselves from their own "local" colonialists (such as House representatives and government officials) who constantly push more imports of natural produces such as rice fruits salt etc (for their own benefits) and push away the wellfare of our own farmers! Seriously if we want to talk about sustainability, we have much more chances to be "sustainable" and even be known as the best in the world in these areas where our strength is. Let's first yield those "low-hanging" fruits before we start talking and being all emotional about national car or plane..


SirAnthonyKnown-Bender
3:20pm Jan 9, 2012

It is indeed, JPB, the solution being Indonesians putting aside the religious and ethnic differences that have been used to divide and conquer them and realising their common interests. These interests, at an economic level, might include identifying their common enemies, namely neo-liberal trans-national economic power and the country's venal domestic elite who conspire with said power for their 30 pieces of silver.


Even legislators, it now seems, want to get in on the act. The nationalistic fervor created by a group of vocational school students from Solo who built a car is sweeping through the nation’s corridors of power. On the weekend, the House of Representatives said it would seek to revive the national automotive industry in response to the public enthusiasm toward the Kiat Esemka. The legislators intend to provide funds for the project and involve state-owned enterprises in the endeavor.

Aria Bima, the deputy chairman of House Commission VI, which oversees on trade and industry, said the commission would soon invite officials from the State Enterprises Ministry, the Industry Ministry, the automotive industry, the railway industry, the Indonesian Institute of Sciences (LIPI), government officials and academics to a meeting. The aim of the meeting is to come to a decision to accelerate the development of a national automaker. But are the legislators getting ahead of themselves? The last time a national car project was undertaken, it did not end very well.

House Speaker Marzuki Alie has said that the government cannot allow such a project to be run by private funds, probably because of its strategic nature. But his views were rebuffed by State Enterprises Minister Dahlan Iskan who wants state firms to stay clear of the project and allow the private sector to take ownership of it. It is important that legislators and politicians think clearly before they rush into throwing money at a project that has not been well developed. There needs to be a clear plan, a thorough feasibility study and most importantly the right legislation to encourage and support a domestic automotive industry.

Instead of asking state firms to lead the project, the government should draw up a comprehensive industrial masterplan that encourages national competitiveness and entrepreneurship. This issue is not about having a national car for the sake of it but having a competitive industry and economy. In their eagerness to pander to public sentiment, legislators and government officials should not mistake the trees for the forest. We must go beyond the Esemka to develop industries where Indonesia has a competitive advantage.

Such a strategy must incorporate the private sector as a key partner, otherwise it will be money down the drain.




  • 9:29pm | Nearly Every High School Stude...
    I can already imagine how many future Nobel prize laureate will be coming from the ranks of these students. And of course how many Nobel Prize winn
  • 9:28pm | Lady Gaga Refuses to Tone Down...
    Ladygaga is my new heroine, she has more balls than our President and so-called majority peace-loving moderate but silent Muslims.. Now bataks shou
  • 9:24pm | Update: Australia, Indonesia D...
    blightyboy, The cases emerged my friend was pointing out were in their late thirties up to late forties. Most of the cases go indetected according
  • 9:06pm | Most Still Unaware of Indonesi...
    tell that to the journalist that just got stabbed by the government minister. The US needs to hurry up and sell these apes some artillery so they c
  • 9:02pm | Indonesia ‘Most Tolerant Count...
    Jubal.Harshaw: post of the day sir.
  • 8:47pm | Most Still Unaware of Indonesi...
    Good one, i believe it's the first country in the region(S.E.Asia) doing so, beside Australia and kiwi.
  • 8:36pm | Some Experts Say Indonesia's B...
    @JohnnyFool I strongly believe everyone is entitled to speak freely on any topic . Those thugs have so many different fundamental b
  • 8:29pm | Indonesia ‘Most Tolerant Count...
    22 - read the artice - most the people they reffering to are Indonesians NOT overseas. Its ok anyway because Indons have the highes