Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Fri, May 25, 2012
Archive Search

Few High Schoolers Fail English, But Hit Snag On Bahasa
Nurfika Osman | June 11, 2011

Share This Page
111
153
0
5
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

devine
8:02pm Jun 11, 2011

Comello, most certainly. As padt pointed out: it's a joke. And as to 90%+ it was actually 99.2%. So if we got by the Govt and how proud they are we certainly have to smartest and best educated kids on earth...

The whole thing is just a total empbarrassment... I really wonder if these people at the National Education Ministry can sleep well at night above such bull(edited)...


padt
3:34pm Jun 11, 2011

I have in front of me one of the variants of the Yr 9 English exam - 50 multiple choice questions based on reading/comprehension.

Hardly an examination of language skills. No grammar; no essay; no translation; no spelling or vocabulary. A very rum exam!

And most of them nearly everywhere got 99% to be sure.

It's a joke.


Comello
2:59pm Jun 11, 2011

Ah, is this the same charade as the National Exam where 90+% pass?

And if not, why is 90+% of Indonesians still unable to express themselves in English?


pm89130
2:50pm Jun 11, 2011

Very interesting article, although I would never, ever in my whole life dream of considering that the English examined in the national exams is anywhere close to the actual English language. I was never able to score perfectly on my English national exams, even when I scored a perfect 677 on my TOEFL. Just saying.


charyza
1:39pm Jun 11, 2011

Oh,I like the Indonesian language TOEFL based idea.. Good one.


  • Previous
  • 1
  • Next

Far more high school students failed the Indonesian language test than the English test during last month’s national exams, the National Education Ministry revealed on Thursday.

According to ministry data, 1,786 of the 4,648 students who failed the exams did so after coming up short on the Indonesian language test, compared to just 152 who failed the English exam.

Fasli Djalal, the deputy education minister, said the results highlighted a “sad” downward trend in the average score for the Indonesian language exam over the past several years.

“This is due to the decrease in interest among students to read Indonesian,” he said.

He added students tended to dismiss the importance of studying the Indonesian language because they used it in their daily conversations.

“They think that it’s something they don’t need to study to be good at,” Fasli said.

“But language is like sports — the more you practice, the better you get. For Indonesian language, the more you read, the better you understand how to get the main idea of the texts, and the more creative you become in re-writing those ideas.”

Charisma, a student at a senior high school in East Jakarta, said Indonesian did not make for an interesting subject.

“The classes are a bit boring and the teachers don’t motivate us to learn,” she said.

“I know it’s an important subject, but the exam is about formal Indonesian, whereas we use colloquial Indonesian in everyday use. Besides, I think the English class is more interesting.”

Fasli said the high number of failures was also a worrying sign that Indonesian language teachers were not qualified to teach students properly.

“They don’t have good methods of teaching or of evaluating the students’ language,” he said.

Fasli called on educators to adopt teaching methods that would encourage students to actively learn the language.

“Sometimes teachers need to work a little harder in teaching their students,” he said.

“Teach them how to read, write, listen and speak in the proper way. Teachers should also be able to teach them speed reading so that they can comprehend a given text faster.”

However, he conceded that the lack of qualified teachers had always been part of the challenge facing the government in the education sector.

“We’ve realized, particularly among elementary school teachers, that most of them don’t even have a bachelor’s degree yet.”

He added another issue was that the country still did not have a comprehensive standardized test for the Indonesian language, like the TOEFL for English, to test students’ understanding and use of the tongue.




  • 9:29pm | Nearly Every High School Stude...
    I can already imagine how many future Nobel prize laureate will be coming from the ranks of these students. And of course how many Nobel Prize winn
  • 9:28pm | Lady Gaga Refuses to Tone Down...
    Ladygaga is my new heroine, she has more balls than our President and so-called majority peace-loving moderate but silent Muslims.. Now bataks shou
  • 9:24pm | Update: Australia, Indonesia D...
    blightyboy, The cases emerged my friend was pointing out were in their late thirties up to late forties. Most of the cases go indetected according
  • 9:06pm | Most Still Unaware of Indonesi...
    tell that to the journalist that just got stabbed by the government minister. The US needs to hurry up and sell these apes some artillery so they c
  • 9:02pm | Indonesia ‘Most Tolerant Count...
    Jubal.Harshaw: post of the day sir.
  • 8:47pm | Most Still Unaware of Indonesi...
    Good one, i believe it's the first country in the region(S.E.Asia) doing so, beside Australia and kiwi.
  • 8:36pm | Some Experts Say Indonesia's B...
    @JohnnyFool I strongly believe everyone is entitled to speak freely on any topic . Those thugs have so many different fundamental b
  • 8:29pm | Indonesia ‘Most Tolerant Count...
    22 - read the artice - most the people they reffering to are Indonesians NOT overseas. Its ok anyway because Indons have the highes