Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Fri, May 25, 2012
Archive Search

Aceh Muslims Speak Out in Support Of Punks’ Treatment
Arientha Primanita & Antara | December 22, 2011

A detained youth cries as she sings a song during a religious class at Sekolah Polisi Negara, a police school in Seulawah, Aceh Besar, Indonesia’s Aceh province on Wednesday. Police detained about 65 youth punks when they attended a rock music show on December 11. The youths are expected to be released on Friday 23 after completing disciplinary education. (Reuters Photo) A detained youth cries as she sings a song during a religious class at Sekolah Polisi Negara, a police school in Seulawah, Aceh Besar, Indonesia’s Aceh province on Wednesday. Police detained about 65 youth punks when they attended a rock music show on December 11. The youths are expected to be released on Friday 23 after completing disciplinary education. (Reuters Photo)
Share This Page
8
22
0
43
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

DrDez
5:54pm Dec 27, 2011

JPB

Oh deary me... It looks like te majority of these homeless kids are actually employed* or studying at university

In fact looking at the picture they look mid late 20's aged

*I say employed but actually many have lost their jobs now...

Reported on TVRI this afternoon

So I guess you will go back into hiding and blame the evil MTV


DrDez
3:33pm Dec 24, 2011

anyway JPB I have to go and watch the carols - welcome back and Merry Christmas - I am sure you will spend the days deep in prayer or other such peaceful activity. On the other hand the 40 million Christians around the nation will be looking to Indonesia's finest to hopefully deliver the same thing.. Unless of course you are in Bogor or any other hotbed of radical idealism and hate - then the police wont help if the religion of peace wishes once again to use violence

Happy Christmas all the same may 2012 bring you what you deserve and nothing more


DrDez
3:23pm Dec 24, 2011

JPB

Avoiding the issue AGAIN - you cry for Islamic rights then when they are presented ie the 1990 CDHRI you summarily ignore it because it suits you... What a flipping hypocrite

Islamic law shows this to be wrong...


DrDez
2:46pm Dec 24, 2011

PS lets not forget that Iran in 1948 had just come off worst by aligning as an axis power - ie they sided with the Hitler and was in turmoil as the Qajar dynasty tried to wrestle power

Lets also not forget modern (sic) Iran is one of the worst offenders of Human Rights in the world including extra judicial killings, deaths in custody, capital punishment based on testimony, political deaths/prisoners, massive gender inequality and violence, LGBT, let alone the religious violence which they promote cross border... Yes I can see why an Iranian would say no thanks to a Human rights bill... Don't you ever think beyond 1 sentence?


justapasserby
2:37pm Dec 24, 2011

I've never heard of any secular law against prostitution in Indonesia. The only reason they get rounded up is because it is against public decency and sense of morality. You will never hear any of these prostitutes being put in jail, they are instead sent to social institutions for some education (which includes things like hand crafting skills so that they can survive on more decent works when they got out). The same with these kids. As for what you call "base" treatment, you read what the police said: they are being put into a boot camp at a police school.. so some marching drills, bruises, hair cuts,etc. are to be expected. It is normal, in fact every civil servant usually do similar camp whenever they get promotion in their job. A good rule of thumb is to see whether any of them got kicked or punched.. which they didnt.


Muslims students and clerics in staunchly Islamic Aceh on Wednesday came to the defense of the local authorities, saying that punks were trying to undermine Islamic law in the province, as officials claim.

Authorities in Aceh, especially the administration of the Banda Aceh municipality, have come under a barrage of criticism at home and abroad, with accusations of human rights violations being made following their move to arrest 65 punks in Aceh and send them for several days of “re-education” at a police camp.

“The existence of punks in Aceh is weakening the implementation of Islamic Shariah [law] in Aceh that is now being promoted, by damaging the moral of the youths in Aceh,” said Tengku Mukhtar Syafari, the head of the Rabithath Muta’allin Pidie association of clerics.

The Aceh chapter of Indonesian Muslim Student Action Unity (Kammi) aired its full support for the authorities’ actions, saying that the life they were living was not in line with the culture and customs of Aceh.

“In a number of Western countries, Muslims are not allowed to wear the veil. Is that not a human rights violation?” said Muhammad Muaz Munawar, who heads the chapter.

He said that everyone should respect the policies of other countries.

“Each country must have its own wisdom, so everyone else should respect it.”

Mukhtar said the accusations of human rights violations by rights activists were “unbalanced” and that activists were doing nothing.

“So far, these human rights defenders have come up with unbalanced statements on the way punks are provided with guidance although they themselves do not do anything,” Mukhtar said.

He said that instead of criticizing Aceh for dealing with its punks, human rights activists and groups should focus their attention on more serious violations, such as the killing of Palestinians by Israelis.

Meanwhile, Social Affairs Minister Salim Segaf al-Juffrie said he had reminded all social affairs workers and the police to act in a persuasive way when dealing with minors.

He also said that appearances could be deceiving.

“Their hair may look that way because it is the style, but their heart may not necessarily be bad. But if they have violated the law, for example by consuming drugs, that is different,” he added.

The deputy mayor of Banda Aceh, Illiza Sa’aduddin Djamal, who has been criticized for her staunch support for the move, said critics could come and see for themselves how the detainees had been treated. “Don’t just listen to negative issues regarding the guidance we are providing them. Please come and see for yourself that we really only want them to become better,” Illiza said.

Illiza said the 59 boys and six girls who had been given the “guidance” at a police camp outside of Banda Aceh, would soon be sent back to live with their families in the region.

No further details were given, but officials said they planned to return the young people to their parents on Friday.

Their “guidance” sessions included shaving their heads, cutting the hair of the girls short and intensive military-like discipline drills.




  • 4:26pm | More Muslim Groups Demand Canc...
    Wonder where the 1 mio radicals were today... they were supposed to show up in front of Police Headquarters...
  • 4:19pm | If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Wa...
    indeed, democratic system should be replaced by installing Chaliphate that rule us with sharia. Democracy leave us a big hole for decadency, allow
  • 4:18pm | More Muslim Groups Demand Canc...
    ... yes agoz... ban all and everything... incl. beer of course... hahahaha ... what a sad little life you live... you might really consider moving
  • 4:18pm | More Muslim Groups Demand Canc...
    But agoz - the Indonesian govt is pushing for dangdut to be recognised by UNESCO... I agree with minister - dont like it dont go. I dont l
  • 4:17pm | Indonesia Wants 10,000 Child W...
    cupid - theres a lot more, most are orphans or victims of divorce
  • 4:08pm | Indonesia Wants 10,000 Child W...
    A noble cuase. Education is every child’s basic right. But why are these kids not in school? Why have they already been allowed to slip thro
  • 3:56pm | Former Social Minister to Be R...
    Sarongs for disaster victims eh. An opertunistic vulture,who got of lightly ( don't they all!) because he was a member of the government pa
  • 3:50pm | HRWG Deplores Yudhoyono's 'Lac...
    I guess you would have to go back and look at her trial. Guilty until proven innocent. But without fingerprinting, contamination o