Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Fri, May 25, 2012
Archive Search

Arrests at Sea Raise Tensions With Malaysia
Nurfika Osman | August 16, 2010

In this file photo, Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore take part in a joint patrol.  Malaysia and Indonesia In this file photo, Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore take part in a joint patrol. Malaysia and Indonesia's relationship is simmering after the two countries had a maritime dispute on Sunday. (AP Photo/Ed Wray)
Share This Page
0
7
0
8
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

marcel
9:17am Aug 18, 2010

how about malaysian burn their flag(when during their independence day) and their media will surely cause apocalypse to both countries.

but i believe malaysian has more rational sense than their dissappointing nationalist politician.


Valkyrie
5:59am Aug 18, 2010

"the Indonesian media" - does that include JG too? Hmmmmm!


50-50
8:09pm Aug 17, 2010

Totally agree with Don123 and Roland. The Indonesian media, unfortunately tends to give only one side of the story - the Indonesian side. To fully justify their new found press freedom, they should give the two sides of the story. Or may be they don't have enough budget to station a full-time reporter in Kuala Lumpur and other Asean cities to ferret out the other side's version? Why even the allegedly not-so-free Malaysian media such as The New Straits Times and The Star have their full-time people in Jakarta for on the spot coverage?

Example: There was a big hu-ha in the Indonesian press about this time last year about Malaysia "stealing" Indonesian pendet dance. When later it surfaced that the "theft" had nothing to do with Malaysia but the inadvertent slip of Discovery Channel office in Singapore, the Indonesian media remained silent and did not highlight that as much as the initial controversy.


Don123
5:40pm Aug 17, 2010

It is sad that after so many instances, the Indonesian media still continue to cause hype to strain two countries' relationship built on goodwill by forefathers through decades. It is an easy way to sell news easily using sympathy. Finally, the Malaysian authorities have come out with facts proving Indonesian Fisheries officers entered into Malaysian territory in Middle Rocks (ruled by International Court of Arbitration in 2008 that it is Malaysian territoty). The Fisheries Ministry (KKP) officers entered into Malaysia to abduct Malaysian fishermen and demanded ransom of Rp10 million per head. The KKP officers already took away their catch and return to Batam. They probably have already sold them by now. Indonesian government ministers and legislators meanwhile wants to be fiery to try to be heroes for their political gain. They want to show they are the person who brought them back. Indonesia media should 1)stop using distorted language and show the GPS data to the Indonesian public, 2) ask where the catch are now, 3)cover news from Vietnam, Singapore, Thailand, and see how many cases of KKP abducting their fishermen and then demand unreasonable ransom (you will be shocked), so the Indonesian public can know and hopefully in the future generations, some young Indonesian can rise to fight these corruption and injustices. These are all news the Indonesian media will never report because they use sympathy and anger to sell news. Well, it is a successful way for them so far, but they are playing with fire.


Amiruddin Alauddin
3:43pm Aug 17, 2010

The aggressive and insulting demonstration at the Malaysian embassy in Jakarta recently is not an acceptable action. It was with a sense of disappointment once again I saw those Indonesian group of flag-waving & "bambu runcing" along with the posters of "Ganyang Malaysia". What does the Indonesia police do (as I was watching the video footage)? Nothing.

I just hope that there won't be another massive natural catastrophe over in Indonesia like what happened at Acheh, Tasik Malaya & Padang because this time most possibly Indonesia cannot count on the typical Malaysians for any charitable acts.

I


Jakarta. Tensions between Malaysia and Indonesia are heating up again following the arrest of three Indonesian maritime officers over an apparent border dispute.

The three officers were in Bintan waters off Riau Islands when they were arrested on Friday night by the Malaysian Marine Operations Force, according to Aji Sularso, the director general of supervision at the Indonesian Ministry of Maritime Affairs and Fisheries.

He said the officers were arrested shortly after detaining seven Malaysian fishermen who were part of a group aboard five boats illegally fishing in Indonesian waters. “Malaysia said that it was their territory, but they are our waters,” Aji insisted on Sunday.

The three had been part of a five-strong patrol team when they encountered the fishermen. Two officers took seven of the fishermen to Sekupang, Batam, while three boarded the fishing boats, where they were arrested.

Malaysian state news agency Bernama has reported that the incident took place in Kota Tinggi waters, off the southeastern coast of Johor state.

“The incident occurred about 9:30 p.m. when the 15 fishermen, between the ages of 23 and 63, were four nautical miles south-east of Tanjung Punggai [in Johor] before they were approached by an Indonesian fisheries enforcement boat and detained,” Kota Tinggi Police Supt. Osman Muhammad Sebot was quoted as saying.

Initial reports also said the Malaysians fired at the Indonesian patrol boat, but officials denied this.

“The Malaysian police only fired warning shots,” said Djoko Suyanto, Indonesia’s coordinating minister for political, legal and security affairs.

 Most reports said that after the warning shots were fired, the Indonesian patrol boat fled to Batam along with seven of the detained fishermen.

Widyarka Ryananta, social and cultural information counselor at the Indonesian Embassy in Kuala Lumpur, said Malaysia would give its official version of events today.

Aji also denied reports Malaysia had offered to trade the seven Malaysian fishermen for the three Indonesian officers.

In a news conference on Sunday evening, Maritime Affairs and Fisheries Minister Fadel Muhammad said Jakarta would send a diplomatic note to the Malaysian government over the incident.

“Three steps will be taken by our government to resolve this matter,” Fadel said.

Firstly, “the Foreign Ministry will issue a reprimand, or in diplomatic language a diplomatic note, to the Malaysian government as its police crossed into Indonesian territory.”

Second, the government would also secure the release of the three officers, and third, it would ask Malaysia to ensure this kind of incident did not happened again.

President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono said the matter must be resolved diplomatically to avoid straining relations.

Fadel said there had been at least 10 border violations involving Malaysian and Chinese fishing boats this year, and 14 such violations by Malaysian boats last year. “We will work with the Navy and water police to help us with border security,” he said.

Indonesia is highly sensitive about its territorial integrity since  losing the tiny islands of Sipadan and Ligitan off the northeastern coast of Borneo — disputed since 1969 — to Malaysia following a 2002 ruling by the International Court of Justice.

Lawmaker Tjahjo Kumolo, from House of Representatives Commission I for defense, information and foreign affairs, said the government must make a strong protest over the incident.

“Malaysia is Indonesia’s close friend. But the government must not turn a blind eye to this,” Tjahjo said. “The Malaysian police have humiliated our sovereignty.”