As China Cracks Down on Uighurs, Jakarta’s Muslims Stay Unusually Silent
Dwayne Carruthers | July 11, 2009
Related articles
Muslim Militant Group Claims Western China Attacks 3:19pm Sep 8, 2011
Malaysia Condemned for Deporting Uighurs to China 5:06pm Aug 23, 2011
Fresh Violence in Troubled NW China, 11 Dead 7:48pm Jul 31, 2011
Imprisonment, Exile or Worse Awaits Afghanistan’s Christian Community 10:37pm Jan 27, 2011
40,000 Pakistani Muslims Protest Against Blasphemy Law Reform 11:16pm Jan 9, 2011
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
317475This goes to prove that mass protests in Indonesia are not so much an expression of public outcry or solidarity, but rather an industry. Like all industries, it requires money, participants and consumers. Jews and Israel are already popular "brand names." Uighurs on the other hand, not so much. It wouldn't be "profitable" to stage mass protests to support our Chinese muslim friends.
Can't we let sleeping dogs lie? Why ask?
Don't be mistaken. A good majority of people in Indonesia are aware of what's going on but wisely have decided that the bottom line is always politics and therefore had refrained from initiating a reaction. Indonesians are now "politic savvy" and rather avoid being involved unnecessarily.
It's the foreign press and media who I believe have always tried to incite feelings.
Look at what happened in the aftermath of the Iranian polls. Did you observe any reaction here? We have matured.
- Previous
- 1
- Next
There were no protests on Jakarta’s streets after Friday prayers, which might strike some as strange, given the ongoing crackdown against Muslim Uighurs in China’s remote western province of Xinjiang.
In recent years, the Prosperous Justice Party (PKS) and aligned radical Islamic groups, such as the Islamic Defenders Front and Hizbut Tahrir Indonesia, have played active roles in staging protests against Israel’s military action in the Gaza Strip and Lebanon, and US operations in Iraq and Afghanistan.
“Organizing a protest costs money and sometimes it can be very expensive,” said Zulkieflimanysah, PKS deputy chairman for political affairs. “We don’t have enough money to participate in China’s affairs right now because we need to focus on what’s happening in our own country.”
The mosques in Urumqi, the capital of Xinjiang, were shut on the Muslim day of prayer as police patrolled the streets with high-powered machine guns. “Go home and pray,” the signs at the entrances to the mosques read. But hundreds of Muslim men who had gathered at the White Mosque in Urumqi’s Uighur neighborhood of Er Dao Qiao were allowed in after demanding entrance, The Associated Press reported on Friday.
The Uighurs, the majority of whom are Sunni Muslims, face constant persecution by the Chinese government. Students and government workers are controlled by strict regulations that infringe on two of Islam’s five pillars: During the holy month of Ramadan, students and government workers are forced to eat and their passports are confiscated so they cannot participate in the hajj to Mecca. Imams are forbidden to teach the Koran in private and the Arabic language is only taught in designated government schools.
Uighurs were once the largest ethnic group in Xinjiang, but an influx of ethnic Han has made them the minority. Han Chinese are the ethnic majority in China, representing more than 90 percent of the country’s population.
The recent riots in Urumqi began in response to the Chinese government’s handling of a brawl between Uighur and Han factory workers in southern China, but tensions between the two ethnic groups go further back.
On Nov. 19, 2006, one day before former US President George W. Bush visited Indonesia, the PKS staged a demonstration with thousands of supporters at a mosque in Jakarta to protest against US military actions in Iraq and Afghanistan.
“America presents itself as the champion of democracy, so when President Bush decided to invade Iraq, that move contradicted everything it claimed to stand for,” Zulkieflimanysah said on Friday. “We had to protest as a symbol of our dissent.”
However, he said, Indonesians were unlikely to act on the situation in China because its political system was not democratic.
On the other hand, when former Russian President Vladimir Putin visited Jakarta in 2007, the government and political circles welcomed him. The killing of tens of thousands of Muslims in Chechnya by the Russian Army seemed to have been forgiven and forgotten.
“Russia and Indonesia have been friends since the Cold War,” said Azyumardi Azra, an Islamic scholar.
“It is sad to say, but apparently Russia-Indonesia relations have a stronger political significance than religious concerns.”
He added, “I don’t think many Indonesian Muslims are aware that there are other Muslims living in Xinjiang because it is different from places like Afghanistan and Iraq, where the media is always on the story and therefore they get more global attention.”
Zulkieflimanysah said he did not know of any demonstrations being planned for the Uighurs.
- The Secret Catch of South Jakarta
- What US Stop Online Piracy Act Means for Indonesia
- Indonesian Judge Faces 20 Years for Graft
- Jakarta Police Bust Rp 128b Drug Ring
- For Many Indonesians, ‘Facebook’ Is the Only Internet
- Notorious Gang Boss Could Be Behind Sanex Steel Murder: Jakarta Police
- Luxury Property Prices Soar in Jakarta as Economy Fires Up Demand
- Indonesia to Create Giant Palm Oil, Rubber Firm
- More Backpedaling on Indonesia's Plan to Restrict Subsidized Fuel
- My Jakarta: Bagus, Child Busker
-
10:30am | Who Are the Atheists in Indone...
@nonredneck: How do we know whether God against or support atheism? Logically God is independent right? Does God need supporters to legitimate God’ -
10:13am | Angelina Sondakh Named a Suspe...
"Abraham said Angelina would not be immediately detained." Guess that gives her time to lose her memory, get sick and leave Indonesia with her mo -
9:09am | For Many Indonesians, ‘Faceboo...
FP i think you might be right NRN because fear is what the majority of religions use to scare or control the followers and fear means power -
9:05am | Who Are the Atheists in Indone...
bawel I am a devout and god fearing Christian. I think the point people are making is there is no evidence HE provides it, its just a matter -
8:48am | Angelina Sondakh Named a Suspe...
Another one lucky not to have stolen a sim card, sandals, bananas or 3 coconuts... Several month ago she swore in public that she didn't ge -
8:23am | Luxury Property Prices Soar in...
Luxury property prices in Jakarta are more a barometer of corruption than they are of economic growth. The vast majority of these properties are pu -
8:16am | Angelina Sondakh Named a Suspe...
I doubt she's the target. If I read the game play, KPK is doing just fine in their attempt to 'hook' the bigger fish. KPK....sque -
8:16am | Yohanes Sulaiman: Indonesia Ca...
Yohanes I would welcome a firm stance but adopting Reagan or Thatcherite policies requires a free market approach & we are heading in the op
