Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Fri, May 25, 2012
Archive Search

Buskers, Beggars and Street Kids Off Jakarta's Streets for Ramadan
Elisabeth Oktofani & Dofa Fasila | July 21, 2011

Share This Page
1
5
0
17
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

DrDez
7:16am Jul 22, 2011

Fanelli

YES !! That is the point !!!

If they are there all year they are not being shipped in as claimed..

Some come sure - but we ignore it for 11 months then lock them away for ramadan... Im sorry but that is just Islamic hypocrisy - at a time when as PB says they should be more benevolant - they simply sweep the dirt away and pretend it does not exist.. OR as an alternative view

Is it possible that those who profit from the begging actually want to ensure non mafia people (from outside the city) cannot beg at ramadan? IE they want to maximise the benevolance that ramadan brings.... If so (and that is possible) then one should be ask who is lobbying who


fanelli
3:11am Jul 22, 2011

eh, I'm with purebred on this one. I wish they'd get rid of them for the entire year. Look, beggars at red lights are mostly beggar mafias with quotas, ranks and different jobs + various commission payscales etc. Some beggars may be legitimate but as a whole, it's a bad thing. Add to that "seasonal" beggars who come here during Idul Fitri and, well... they shouldn't come to the city begging.


Valkyrie
6:36pm Jul 21, 2011

PBI

Perhaps you were born with a silver spoon in your mouth and I hope it stays there. Because, that mou** of yours appears to overlo** your re**.

(JG you editing it again?)

I really do not care if you're pribumi or even an alien. Your comments I observe quite often create an invitation to "controversies."

Whatever has happened to the words "compassion" and "mercies?" Are these words non existent in your vocabulary?

By the way....have you ever been hungry? Truly hungry because you can't afford a meal?

I suggest you put better use of your intelligence and energy in condemning the wrongdoers.


Valkyrie
6:16pm Jul 21, 2011

DD:

Have you forgotten that this is "opposite land?"

ps: Originator of this was Brahma Putera and I have not seen his contribution for a very long time. Also "KZ."

C'mon BP! C'mon KZ! Show up guys!


purebredindonesian
4:53pm Jul 21, 2011

I dont think common jakartan muslims will mind that there will be more buskers or beggars in ramadhan, as is expected of us to be more charitable during the month. But the local government will surely mind that plenty of beggars from out of city take the opportunity to come and beg in streets and mosques of Jakarta. Yes there are beggars and buskers during normal times, but there will be significantly more of them during ramadhan, due to influx from rural areas. The city goverment just want to discourage these influx.


Jakarta government officials are cracking down on beggars, buskers and street kids in what it says is an effort to rid the capital of “social welfare problems” during Ramadan.

On Wednesday, about 10 days ahead of the expected start of the holy month, Public Order Agency (Satpol PP) head Effendi Anas said his staff started an operation targeting the fringe groups, which it has labelled PMKS.

During the fasting month there is often an increase in their number on the capital’s streets as the generosity promoted by Ramadan attracts many from impoverish rural areas.

“This operation is aimed at providing comfort and safety to Muslims who are fasting during Ramadan,” Effendi said. “And also to keep PMKS from bothering people in public.”

The operation will involve 300 public order officers and will last until July 30, just before Ramadan starts. It will target the Gambir, Tanah Abang, Kebayoran Lama and Cilandak areas.

Another round of operations would be carried out from Aug. 16 to 28, toward the end of the fasting month and just before Idul Fitri. “During the first round, a persuasive approach will be used and they’ll be sent home,” Effendi said. “But the second time around, we will arrest them and send them to social welfare homes. They won’t be able to go home to celebrate Lebaran with their families.”

This, he said, has proven to be effective. “They really want to celebrate Lebaran with their families,” he said, adding that they would be released two days after the occasion.

Last year, the Jakarta administration arrested 2,500 PMKS during Ramadan, a 50 percent drop from the figure in 2009. “Hopefully, the number will fall even more this year,” he said.

So far, 123 PMKS were accosted after the first day of the operations, 26 of which did not have Jakarta residence cards.

Kian Kelana, the head of Jakarta’s Social Affairs Office, said the government has prepared three social welfare homes for PMKS in Kedoya, Ceger and Cengkareng.

Ahead of the holy month, expected to start on Aug. 1, police said there would be no raids by hard-line organizations, which have occurred in past years.

Officials have likewise assured the public that the government had enough essential goods to meet the high seasonal demand.

To accommodate an estimated 2.5 million passengers traveling to and from their hometowns at the end of the month, state railway operator Kereta Api Indonesia announced that an additional 26 trains will be operating during the peak travel period beginning Aug. 25 and run for 18 days.




  • 4:49pm | President's Son Nearly Attacke...
    How can on be 'nearly' attacked? All sounds a bit poofy to me. Like his father, he needs to grow some.
  • 4:47pm | If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Wa...
    @agoz are you serious? I still believe every individual is responsible for him/herself, political systems and/or religion have nothing to do
  • 4:39pm | Former Social Minister to Be R...
    By the time the Ministry of health had their cut in the mark up pricing of the vaccine, the mark up on the syringes and the cut off the top ...
  • 4:38pm | HRWG Deplores Yudhoyono's 'Lac...
    Perhaps HRWG should learn something about the case, rather than exposing itself as a sham, full of self serving people. Hey, HRWG, s
  • 4:26pm | More Muslim Groups Demand Canc...
    Wonder where the 1 mio radicals were today... they were supposed to show up in front of Police Headquarters...
  • 4:19pm | If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Wa...
    indeed, democratic system should be replaced by installing Chaliphate that rule us with sharia. Democracy leave us a big hole for decadency, allow
  • 4:18pm | More Muslim Groups Demand Canc...
    ... yes agoz... ban all and everything... incl. beer of course... hahahaha ... what a sad little life you live... you might really consider moving
  • 4:18pm | More Muslim Groups Demand Canc...
    But agoz - the Indonesian govt is pushing for dangdut to be recognised by UNESCO... I agree with minister - dont like it dont go. I dont l