Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Fri, May 25, 2012
Archive Search

Chaos and Delays Plague Indonesia Tsunami Relief Operation
Nivell Rayda | November 01, 2010


Share This Page
53
7
0
7
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

batikbooby
11:22am Nov 2, 2010

please excuse my ignorance, but who is this god thing that people keep rabbitting on about? please enlighten me


stevej6x7
9:37am Nov 2, 2010

The Lord giveth

and the tsunami washeth away.

Blessed be the name of the Lord.


peterR
7:17am Nov 2, 2010

Putrimawar - surely the officials in Indonesia only allow God to give help to Muslims?

Anyway, is not good Christians an oxymoron in Indonesia.


Putrimawar
1:30pm Nov 1, 2010

@peterR: I like your sarcasm, and may be rightly so. But, you're assuming that only Muslims have God, while lots of Mentawai people are Christians. Don't you think they have God too?


isahbiazhar
12:11pm Nov 1, 2010

Let us see the situation philosophically rather than the hard hitting way.These innocent people need help desperately.They were there and they will be there in the future.We cannot blame them for the natural calamity.The president had directed but the machinery is poor.The people suffer just because of the in between.For the sake of the future the government should stockpile food , clothing and medicene in all areas so that in times of emergency and calamity there is immediate aid.We can even build silos under the water to keep them safe.It is possible but we never think about them at all.We have to change and bring hope.It is not a grandiose plan but a feasible one.ther is no fuss here but reality.


Tuapejat and Sikakap. Despite being the capital of Mentawai district, tsunami relief efforts in Tuapejat are apparently in chaos, with food and medical supplies not only arriving late but also spoiling due to mishandling and negligence.

The first batch of government aid arrived in Tuapejat, on the island of Sipora, only on Friday afternoon, a full four days after the earthquake-triggered tsunami swept the group of islands off the western coast of Sumatra. The supplies were routed from Sikakap, on a small island to the south where relief efforts are being coordinated.

But about 20 percent of the ton of rice earmarked for the victims was drenched by seawater and heavy rains, while many cardboard boxes containing instant noodles and milk were also destroyed by water.

Some of the supplies have been going missing in less accidental ways. “Don’t tell anyone,” said one worker as he stuffed two tins of sardines in the pocket of his trousers. Other workers were spotted drinking bottled water meant for the victims.

Seeing the drenched rice, a senior police officer overseeing the shipment called over residents waiting for passenger boats in the harbor.

“These sacks of rice are soaked, it will rot before it even gets to the victims. Give it to these people here,” the officer told the workers.

At least 20 sacks, each containing at least 10 kilograms of rice, were handed out to the people of Tuapejat.

“Can we also keep the blankets that were drenched in water?” a local asked a worker.

At least 96 people are still missing in the wake of the 7.7-magnitude earthquake that drove a tsunami onto the Mentawai Islands on Oct. 25, and the death toll now stands at 449. Mentawai’s four main islands were devastated by the waves, displacing almost 13,000 people.

Sikakap on North Pagai Island, which along with South Pagai were the worst-hit, has become the hub for aid shipments.

But as supplies and volunteers began to flood in late last week with very little coordination from the central government, relief efforts quickly became chaotic. No one appeared to be recording which villages received aid, nor was there anyone in charge of directing new volunteers.

With no official in sight to coordinate the aid shipment, workers piled boxes of instant food on a wet ship floor, soaking the packets and leaving the contents to be scattered and stepped on by laborers unloading other cargo.

“We don’t know how much is being sent. We weren’t told the exact amount. All we know is that there is one ton of rice,” said Adek Simangunsong, a local volunteer.

“The aid was supposed to be here on Thursday, but strong currents and high waves delayed the shipment.” Bad weather had forced the relief ship to delay leaving Sikakap until Friday morning, four days after the quake.

The roughness and remoteness of the area, as well as the limited number of people affected, means that Sipora Island is virtually untouched by government aid.

“Everything is being sent to Sikakap. You can say that the aid sent to Sipora is not surplus,” Adek said. “There are many villages that still haven’t received anything. We are having trouble accessing them. Many of our ships and boats were forced to turn back to Tuapejat because of the rough seas.”

On Saturday, two boats carrying volunteers and aid capsized off the coast of Sikakap as locals reported waves up to four meters high.

The 15 volunteers aboard survived, but no one seemed to be in charge of their safety either.

Surung Matua Sinaga, chairman of the West Sumatra Disaster Relief Agency (BPBD), said his job was only to distribute aid to the victims and to coordinate volunteers, but said that when he heard the news of the capsized boats from two field officers in Mentawai, he told them: “It is not my responsibility.”

Surung said the agency responsible for coordinating volunteers was the Relief Operations Control Center (Pusdalop), in the West Sumatran capital of Padang.

But Depi, a Pusdalop official, thought otherwise. “We haven’t had any information about this [capsizing] incident. Our job is to register volunteers and journalists traveling to Mentawai. Once they get to the islands, it is the field coordinator’s job to direct them and monitor where they are going,” she said.

She didn’t know who was in charge on any of the islands.




  • 4:49pm | President's Son Nearly Attacke...
    How can on be 'nearly' attacked? All sounds a bit poofy to me. Like his father, he needs to grow some.
  • 4:47pm | If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Wa...
    @agoz are you serious? I still believe every individual is responsible for him/herself, political systems and/or religion have nothing to do
  • 4:39pm | Former Social Minister to Be R...
    By the time the Ministry of health had their cut in the mark up pricing of the vaccine, the mark up on the syringes and the cut off the top ...
  • 4:38pm | HRWG Deplores Yudhoyono's 'Lac...
    Perhaps HRWG should learn something about the case, rather than exposing itself as a sham, full of self serving people. Hey, HRWG, s
  • 4:26pm | More Muslim Groups Demand Canc...
    Wonder where the 1 mio radicals were today... they were supposed to show up in front of Police Headquarters...
  • 4:19pm | If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Wa...
    indeed, democratic system should be replaced by installing Chaliphate that rule us with sharia. Democracy leave us a big hole for decadency, allow
  • 4:18pm | More Muslim Groups Demand Canc...
    ... yes agoz... ban all and everything... incl. beer of course... hahahaha ... what a sad little life you live... you might really consider moving
  • 4:18pm | More Muslim Groups Demand Canc...
    But agoz - the Indonesian govt is pushing for dangdut to be recognised by UNESCO... I agree with minister - dont like it dont go. I dont l