Last updated at 1:31 PM. Monday 22 March 2010

Go to comments December 16, 2009

Anita Rachman

Teachers have said that schools in remote areas of Indonesia face a number of challenges. (Photo: JG)

Teachers have said that schools in remote areas of Indonesia face a number of challenges. (Photo: JG)

Child Drinking Just One of Many Challenges Facing Indonesia's Remote Schools

Tarakan, East Kalimantan. Encouraging students to come to school might be a common problem for teachers, but trying to stop their elementary school charges from drinking alcohol is another challenge entirely.

Cultural tensions as well as a lack of facilities, skill development and government support were just some of the issues identified by teachers from remote areas during a training event held in Tarakan by the Tanoto Foundation on Tuesday.

Yuluis Labo, 52, the principal of Sesayap Elementary School 08 in Tana Tidung district — around a three-hour speedboat ride from Tarakan — said that he and his fellow teachers at the school were trying to stop their students from drinking pengasih, a local alcohol made from mashed and fermented cassava that is sometimes also mixed with vodka.

“There are many problems in my school. Besides encouraging teachers to make daily teaching plans, we have many students that sometimes consume alcohol,” Yulius said. “They drink it because their parents say that it is one of the traditions of Dayak Brusu and almost all of my students come from the tribe.”

He said that there are 68 students at his school, aged between seven and 13 years old, under the supervision of six permanent teachers. He said that many of his students often skipped classes or were absent because they were drunk.

“Drinking pengasih is a tradition, and my students say that if they don’t drink it they are disrespecting the tradition,” he said.

Yulius said that pengasih was served on many occasions, such as during planting and harvest festivities and burial ceremonies. He said that parents asked their children to join the drinking sessions.

“Can you imagine? They are only elementary school students. After joining a party, they sometimes come to school in a bad condition: a bit drunk, sleepy and unable to concentrate,” he said.

Yulius, who has been the leader of the school since 2004, said that he has tried to talk to the students, but could not persuade them to give up drinking. He said that teachers needed approach the students calmly and talk to their parents in an appropriate manner.

The school has been trying to locate several members of the tribe who have relatively good educational backgrounds, such as those who have graduated high school, to explain that it is not good for people, especially children, to drink the traditional alcohol.

“But it’s not easy, we also need teachers who understand this. It’s not easy to be a teacher in my area,” he said.

Zulkifli, a teacher at Sekatak State Senior High School 01, located 290 kilometers from Tarakan, said he and his colleagues were facing a similar dilemma.

However, Zulkifli said that the problem had been worse in the past.

“In 1998 it was even worse. Students got drunk and we could hardly even warn them,” he said.

Zulkifli said that he and the teachers at both his current school and previous school, Sekatak State Junior High School 01, had tried several ways to combat the problem. He said that approaching parents was crucial.

Inviting parents to come to the school to receive their child’s semester reports provided a good opportunity for discussion, he said.

“But things still happen, it’s hard."

Anita Lie, a professor from Widya Mandala Catholic University in Surabaya, East Java, and a supervisor at the training session, said that being a teacher in a remote area was not the same as working in the city.

She said that teachers often not only face educational challenges, but also cultural ones.

“That is why giving pre-training to teachers before they are sent to remote areas is very important. The government must pay more attention to teachers in remote areas,” Anita said.

However, Anita stated that culture was not static and it could change. She said that teachers should firstly understand the local culture before agreeing with or opposing it.

“There should be empathy. Don’t ask students to go against their parents or tradition, use the right approach,” she said.



Post a comment

Login or register to post comments!

Comments

tsuroyya

8:15 AM December 17, 2009

I think at this point communication for development (ComDev) issues offers a possible alternatives.

Teacher's dilemma in resolving student's drinking case is a complex issues. It involves different stakeholders such as teachers, students, parents and local cultures.

The possible alternative that ComDev offers is that using a participatory approach to mediate between education institutions, health institutions, and ethnic group leaders. The parents may not well persuaded if teachers convince them that drinking may hinder their child's ability at schools. Health officials involvement would enable teachers to promote a new behavior among their students.

Anita Lie has said that teachers could take advantage from the meeting with parents every semester to have discussions on the drinking habit. This meeting would be more fruitful if teachers could also invite ethnic group leaders and health officials to be panels.

I believe that anything relates to cultures will be difficult to handle. However, it is not impossible. It takes time, but possible. Other meeting such as graduation festivals, or local ceremonies will allow teachers to approach the community especially the parents and ethnic group leaders for persuading them on the child drinking problem.

Roland

5:35 PM December 16, 2009

Enchanté Jeanne! Who of us wouldn't like sometimes a glass of good wine here but all you get is heavily overpriced stuff of sometimes very dubious quality (the good ones are still "ripening" in Jakarta port!) or (at least in Bali) gallons of Aussie Chardonnay as a quick fix before the next pub crawl!

Jeanne Hachette

4:28 PM December 16, 2009

As we say in France, water is polluted , drink wine!

Simon P

3:25 PM December 16, 2009

May as well drink. What sort of education do you think's available in Tarakan, East Kalimantan? It's bound to be appalling.

Roland

3:19 PM December 16, 2009

Let's hope at least the parents are sober when they are receiving the semester reports so they can comprehend that they are gradually making little cretins out of their children (the younger the worse) with alcohol. Another issue for sure is cigarette smoking, it's many times that small kids are seen having a smoke!

it is definitely the responsibility of the parents but also of their teachers.

Simon P

1:10 PM December 16, 2009

“Drinking pengasih is a tradition, and my students say that if they don’t drink it they are disrespecting the tradition,” he said.

This is also my excuse. So I implore the boys and girls up at the docks to release that booze. It's my culture maaan.