Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Fri, May 25, 2012
Archive Search

Cinemas Face Threat of US Movie Boycott
Elisabeth Oktofani | February 21, 2011

Share This Page
1680
1126
0
33
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

Roland
10:31pm Feb 20, 2011

Now, I was quite curious how much the tax would be for an average 2 hour movie:

1 meter of film contains approx. 2.18 seconds worth of movie with a frame rate of 24 per second. That means that a 2 hour movie consists of 3,300 meters of film. Ergo the tax would be around $1,400.

@mawarangu - I like your thought - and indeed indie film makers showed in the past that they can be with a very small budget quite creative if the script is fine and actors as well as the director and producer are dedicated to the cause. However I need to agree to didkarjadi that no effort is shown by the government to support these young artists. In general there is a lack of support (and unfortunately also interest) in art in general in Indonesia. This interest would need to be aroused in schools, may it be music, painting, photo shooting or, as in this particular case, movie making. I don't know of any school having any of these in their curriculum, and maybe just a few private schools in their extracurricular offerings. There are also no incentives for young film makers, so of course the local market is dominated with terrible and cheap productions.

Competition is important and cannot be underestimated as a driving force to do better with local products, meaning bringing higher local products on the market.


didikarjadi
6:04pm Feb 20, 2011

mawarunggu - How on earth can you believe such twaddle. Your logic is seriously flawed.

You think that by doing away with all competition, the Indonesian film industry is going to find wings and take off. And you also believe that sponsors will step forward with sufficient cash to produce films on par with those made abroad. Get real on all counts.

Maybe the Indonesian film industry can grow, but it first must be through creative effort. I have no doubt that there is some amazing talent out there, but it needs government support and backing to grow. It does not need the elimination of its competitors. The biggest problem will be finding investors that understand the industry. Indonesian investors in the arts and culture are few and far between.

If you want shining examples of how industries perform in the absence of competition, just look at all of the state run companies.


mawarunggu
5:16pm Feb 20, 2011

This could be the best thing that ever happened to the Indonesian film industry. This is a great time for investors interested in the film industry to jump in and fund the making of the any number of fine scripts out there just waiting for executive producers. There are many gifted film industry people, especially among the independents, just waiting for the chance to make quality local films to fill in the gap. Cinema 21 and the other theaters will no have to close and people will not have to do without jobs if funds are pumped into making local films.


didikarjadi
9:36am Feb 20, 2011

Uchen - I understand that this high levy is unique to Indonesia. I do-not think you will find that the American film produces are threatening any other country for this reason.

Bali is trying to foster relations with Foreign movie producers, and was having some success, but the government departments involved here do-not give a shit about that or peoples jobs, nor what is best for Indonesia. The officials who are involved in the "ongoing negotiations" are interested in one thing and one thing only, themselves.

Thousands of people stand to loose their jobs, businesses that pay huge taxes will close down, the public will suffer yet another recreational loss, all because of some corrupt officials trying to line their own pockets.

To read this any other way is pure naivety.


Valkyrie
6:53am Feb 20, 2011

BilboBaggins: And I, can't remember when was the last time I went to the movies. A very very long time ago.


Cinema screens across the country may soon have little to show except local movies if a new threat by American film producers to boycott exports to Indonesia is carried out.

The warning has come from the Motion Picture Association, the international counterpart of the Motion Picture Association of America, which has apparently been angered by a proposed levy slapped on imported films.

Freelance film reviewer Bobby Batara told the Jakarta Globe that Frank Rittman, MPA’s vice president for the Asia Pacific, aired the warning after a preview screening for journalists on Thursday of the Oscar-nominated US film “Black Swan.”

Bobby, who attended the event, said Rittman had complained about a new tax that would soon be applied by Indonesia’s customs office.

Rittman was quoted by a number of journalists at the screening as saying that the new government regulation on film importation could force big American studios to stop sending movies to Indonesian cinemas.

MPA representatives could not be reached for confirmation.

Titis Sapto Raharjo, editor in chief of Flick Online Magazine, a film review site, was also at the screening and said the rumor was that the government planned to impose a levy of 43 cents per meter of film imported.

Government officials involved in the matter declined to confirm the figure, saying only that talks were still ongoing.

Syamsul Lussa, a representative from the Ministry of Culture and Tourism, said he did not want to comment because the levy had not been finalized yet. “We will discuss it with the tax and customs directorate as there is a high demand for imported films in Indonesia,” he told the Globe.

Bambang Permadi Brodjonegoro, head of fiscal policy at the Ministry of Finance, said the details had not been finalized because negotiations with the MPA were still ongoing.

“I can’t provide any details until it has been discussed at the fiscal policy body. Please wait until next week,” he said in a message to the Globe. “It’s better to wait until after we have met with [officials from] customs and duties.”

Titis criticized the MPA for bringing up the issue before talks had been completed. “This is an internal discussion between the government and the MPA,” he said. “Therefore, it is very important that Frank not bring this case up to the public.”

Nauval Yazid, manager of the annual Jakarta International Film Festival (JiFFest), said if the threat were carried out, it would deal a significant blow to cinemas and filmgoers across the country.

“Stopping film exports to Indonesia would affect many people,” he said. “Besides, the Indonesian film industry is grappling with piracy, which cannot be stopped. It’s very important that the MPA discuss and resolve this problem with customs.”

Members of the MPA include some of the biggest studios in the United States, including Walt Disney Pictures, Paramount Pictures, Sony Pictures Entertainment, Twentieth Century Fox Film, Universal Pictures and Warner Bros. Entertainment.

Indonesia’s film industry has suffered a downturn in recent years. In 2009, six local films sold more than a million tickets each at the box office. In 2010, only one movie broke the million mark.

Last year, 81 Indonesian films had cinema releases, slightly down from 83 films in 2009, although a significant decline from 91 big-screen releases in 2008.




  • 5:17pm | Lady Gaga Refuses to Tone Down...
    can we just get over her, i effin LOATHE FPI, but i don't care about this basic talent girl (well i do appreciate her "help" in lgbt issues).
  • 5:14pm | President's Son Nearly Attacke...
    step24... "I hope this will make them realize to wake up from their stupidity and blindness and start doing their job right"... unfortunately tha
  • 5:13pm | Former Social Minister to Be R...
    Quite jg. As my Mum used to say "it's enough to make you vote communist". But of course that's not allowed in this wonderful tolerant de
  • 5:10pm | If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Wa...
    JPB gone... agoz resurrected... never ends...
  • 5:02pm | HRWG Deplores Yudhoyono's 'Lac...
    PasserBy - perhaps YOU should actually read the article. Guilt or innocence or the mental health of Schapelle Corby is NOT the issue discussed - it
  • 5:00pm | If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Wa...
    I'm starting to like this agoz guy ... he/she/it suspiciously sounds like a more hardcore 22/JPB/bowel though :). Keep on coming lad, alway
  • 4:58pm | President's Son Nearly Attacke...
    Indeed blightyboy - yesterday I was nearly 'murdered' - luckily the murderer was 1000 kilometers away.
  • 4:55pm | Tomy Winata to Build Jakarta's...
    Please get real with this idea, may be good for business , but how about people in general and the rest of the populations who are poor . May be yo