Collapse of Road Blamed on Erosion
Arientha Primanita & Zaky Pawas | September 17, 2010
Police and curious onlookers gathering near the collapsed section of Jalan RE Martadinata near Tanjung Priok port in North Jakarta on Thursday. Traffic at the site has been closed for safety reasons. (JG Photo/Safir Makki) Related articles
Dutch Unveil Latest Plan in War Against the Sea: a Massive Sandbar 9:39pm Dec 26, 2011
Sumatra-Bound Trucks Stuck Again at Merak Port 3:16pm Mar 19, 2011
Wanted: Long-Term Road Program for Jakarta 11:55pm Dec 14, 2010
Repaired Jakarta Port Road Open to Cars; Trucks to Follow 11:47pm Dec 5, 2010
Indonesian Shorelines May Wash Away If Government Does Not Act: Experts 12:01am Oct 1, 2010
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
396593“The road has been fine for more than 20 years, so we didn’t really monitor the structure” - that's one way to look at the problem!
I wonder how many structurally unsound bridges are in Jakarta alone, and nobody seems to be really in charge to perform a scheduled periodic PROFESSIONAL check on their structure, just because "they look good and they are fine since 20 years..."
Also taken in consideration that Indonesia is earthquake prone, suffers under flooding, and ESPECIALLY because contractors are generally well known to use inferior building material than stated in their final bill!
So when one feels next time the slight motions of the street on elevated city toll roads, while standing in a traffic jam...hopefully just a collapse will never happen!
Just very lucky that nobody got injured or died yesterday!
- Previous
- 1
- Next
Jakarta. Experts have criticized the government over a 103-meter span of road that collapsed suddenly near Jakarta’s Tanjung Priok port early on Thursday, disrupting traffic in and out of the port but causing no casualties.
While the authorities have blamed erosion for the collapse, which saw a section of two entire lanes of Jalan RE Martadinata disappear underwater, an urban planner and city councilor believe weak monitoring contributed to the incident, which may cost the state up to Rp 6 billion ($666,000).
Comr. Susatyo Purnomo Condro, chief of detectives at the North Jakarta Police said the surface of the eight kilometer road had been undergoing repairs since April 1, but the contractor, Indra Prima, was yet to complete the project.
He said the 20-year-old road, which falls under the responsibility of the central government, ran alongside a canal and was often flooded by tidal surges.
Comr. Irvan Prawiraputra, chief of North Jakarta’s traffic unit, said police had initially closed all lanes at the collapsed part of the road, but reopened the unaffected lanes for about an hour before closing it altogether again because of safety concerns.
The deputy minister of public works, Hermanto Dardak, told the Jakarta Globe that erosion was to blame and that natural water abrasion had weakened the road’s foundations.
He said the ministry would today start installing concrete piles to support the remaining portion of road where the collapse took place. He estimated the repair bill would be about Rp 6 billion.
Djoko Murjanto, director general of Bina Marga, which oversees roads at the ministry, said a study would be undertaken to find the most appropriate technology and measures to repair the damaged section and strengthen the entire length of the road.
“The road has been fine for more than 20 years, so we didn’t really monitor the structure,” he said, adding that the ongoing repairs had only been surface work to fix problems such as potholes.
Meanwhile, Insp. Gen. Timur Pradopo, chief of the Jakarta Police, said during a visit to the site that a joint team with the Public Works Ministry would investigate the cause of the collapse.
Susatyo said the police had so far questioned four people — two project supervisors from the Public Works Ministry, an employee of Indra Prima and the motorcycle rider who discovered the collapse.
He said police were focusing on the ongoing repairs as well as technical information about the road’s construction. Yayat Supriyatna, an urban planning expert from Trisakti University, blamed weak monitoring for the incident.
“RE Martadinata is a strategic road used by many people. Why did the government only repair the surface without checking the foundations as well?” he said.
Yayat said that while the erosion had been natural, proper monitoring would have prevented the collapse.
Ellen Tangkudung, from the Indonesian Transportation Society (MTI), said the heavy traffic that used the road, including of container trucks, should be considered in the planning.
City councilor Muhammad Sanusi urged the central government to repair the road immediately because it provided primary access to and from the port.
He said the ministry should have known that North Jakarta was exposed to regular tidal floods and better monitored the road’s foundations.
Traffic to and from Tanjung Priok is being diverted to avoid the collapsed section of the road, with a detour available through Sunter and Jalan Baru Pengadilan.
- We Love Jakarta: This Traffic is Making Me Gila
- John Kei Just a Puppet in Sanex Steel Hit: Jakarta Police
- Afriani’s Drug Seller Arrested, Police Claim
- Knife-Wielding Jakarta Child to Meet Psychiatrist
- Food Stall Owners Slam Jakarta Over New Restaurant Tax
- Thrill Builds in Jakarta for Architecture in Helsinki
- Pint-Sized Mariachis Learn Music of Mexico in New York
- Jakarta Bus Operator Could Lose Routes if Found Liable for Two Accidents
- Indonesia's Mining Sector Royalties Too Low: Hatta Rajasa
- Update5: Indonesian Police Storm Bali Prison to End Riot
-
11:10pm | Letter to the Editor: Study In...
It has nothing to do with conspiracy. It's not a conspiracy if people explicitly tell you they are running your lives and they are doing it for yo -
10:55pm | Lawyer: Nunun Has Heart Condit...
"....almost went to Ethiopia...second class of course!" -
10:38pm | Lawyer: Nunun Has Heart Condit...
Hey, it worked for Pak Harto. -
10:14pm | Malaysia Bans British Author's...
Is that a case of the one-eyed leading the blind Dr Dez? -
10:02pm | W. Java Police Say 20 Suspects...
That came straight from mafia playbook. We won't cause any harm, just obey us. -
9:54pm | Regaining Control in a Decentr...
Elizabeth, only the naive and pseudo-intellectuals believe that anyone out there is responsible to the voter first. Like you anyone that has travel -
9:51pm | Lawyer: Nunun Has Heart Condit...
the tactic at play here seems to be a massive stalling for time and constant delays due to health issues in the vain hope that the judge will get b -
9:02pm | Letter to the Editor: Study In...
@nonredneck: I love you, in a good way. @Looho: Again, fundamental rights to strike does not give workers and trade unions the licen
