Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Fri, May 25, 2012
Archive Search

Did This Politician Plagiarize a Student’s Qaddafi Op-Ed?
Anita Rachman | January 14, 2012

PKB lawmaker Marwan Jafar has been accused of plagiarism. PKB lawmaker Marwan Jafar has been accused of plagiarism.
Share This Page
13
6
0
7
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

pakGuru
4:06pm Jan 17, 2012

"Koran Tempo will...they would wait for Jusman to write a letter to the editor. "

oh wow: tempo - nice to see proactive action there

you'd think a magazine company would have a factchecker on staff, to avoid situations like this?


apaajaboleh
2:06pm Jan 16, 2012

They steal money, so what is there from to stop them from stealing other peoples ideas and creative work? Leopards never change their spots.

“....The allegations aren’t true,” he said. “It’s a technical error on the part of my aides. Apart from blaming someone else, is Marwan now saying that he has the balls to pass off an article written by someone else and then saying it is his opinion that is reflected? Aparrently he does not know what an op-ed is. And this guy is a lawmaker? What a joke!!


jchay
9:56pm Jan 15, 2012

With legislators like Marwan Jafar and Marzuki Alie, it's no wonder that Indonesia's present is so dark and shabby.. but from student like Jusman Dalle, the future of Indonesia might actually be not too bad after all. Keep the good fight, Jusman!


BilboBaggins
10:41am Jan 15, 2012

Denial and excuses, the same old story.


shytallnight
7:46pm Jan 14, 2012

mcculdr - I couldn't agree more.


Indonesian lawmaker Marwan Jafar is in the hot seat after being accused of passing off a Makassar student’s work as his own in an opinion article published in a leading national newspaper on Friday.

Jusman Dalle, the Makassar student, took to Twitter on Friday morning to accuse the House chairman of the National Awakening Party (PKB) of plagiarism.

He later told the Jakarta Globe that he was reading Koran Tempo and was surprised to come across Marwan’s piece, because it looked so much like an opinion piece he had written for the Internet news portal Okezone.com.

“Twitter is effective, it spreads news very quickly. I intentionally mentioned some House members, such as deputy House speakers Anis Matta and Pramono Anung, because they have a lot of followers,” said Jusman, who is an active member of Indonesian Muslim Student Action Unity (Kammi), a national group.

Marwan wrote an opinion piece on Libya’s energy management after the death of the country’s leader, Muammar el-Qaddafi, for the paper’s Friday edition. His piece was titled “Libyan Energy Management Post-Gaddafi.”

Jusman touches on the same issue in his piece, which appeared on Oct. 25, 2011, under the title, “Quo Vadis Libya?”

At least 10 of the 13 paragraphs in Marwan’s piece bear a striking resemblance to Jusman’s, the only difference being the arrangement of the paragraphs and the use of a few different words.

Speaking to the Jakarta Globe, Marwan denied plagiarizing Jusman’s work, but conceded errors may have been made.

“The allegations aren’t true,” he said. “It’s a technical error on the part of my aides. They may have forgotten to cite a source.”

Imam Nahrawi, secretary general of the PKB, said it was unlikely that Marwan would have plagiarized his article in Koran Tempo.

“Pak Marwan is very creative. He is a diligent writer. I am not sure that he would do such thing,” he said, adding that the party would summon Marwan to clarify the matter.

Koran Tempo’s managing editor, Yos Rizal, said the newspaper would compare the two articles before making a statement.

If the allegation is proven to be true, Koran Tempo will blacklist Marwan, Yos said. But he added that they would wait for Jusman to write a letter to the editor.

Jusman said he and Kammi would submit a complaint to the House Ethics Council next week. “As for Koran Tempo, I will send them a letter tomorrow,” the student said.




  • 6:02pm | Indonesia Wants 10,000 Child W...
    They should have prevented it in the first place, instead of realizing the problem when it is too late and then tried to fix it. They should provid
  • 6:02pm | 'Freedom!': Scotland Considers...
    Will never happen. Many Scots live in England anyway and there are even more people in England with at least some Scottish blood in them. Would the
  • 5:56pm | If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Wa...
    There must not be any threats in a democratic country. If you don’t like [a performer] then don’t watch [the concert],” said Djoko Suyanto
  • 5:50pm | Former Social Minister to Be R...
    March 2011 - May2012 = 20 month. Only in Indonesia...
  • 5:48pm | 'Freedom!': Scotland Considers...
    I take exception to the headline "Freedom!" The Scots are free - in a voluntary political union with the rest of Great Britain. If they choose in
  • 5:31pm | If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Wa...
    agoz: Indonesia will never be ruled by Sharia law. Educated people in Indonesia will not allow that. If you think Sharia is so wo
  • 5:17pm | Lady Gaga Refuses to Tone Down...
    can we just get over her, i effin LOATHE FPI, but i don't care about this basic talent girl (well i do appreciate her "help" in lgbt issues).
  • 5:14pm | President's Son Nearly Attacke...
    step24... "I hope this will make them realize to wake up from their stupidity and blindness and start doing their job right"... unfortunately tha