Govt Claims Only 3 Indonesians Facing Execution in Malaysia
Camelia Pasandaran, Nurfika Osman, & Anita Rachman | August 24, 2010
An Indonesian protester is arrested after throwing feces at the Malaysian embassy in Jakarta on Monday. Tensions between Indonesia and Malaysia have risen. (JG Photo/Afriadi Hikmal) Related articles
E. Java Teacher Caught Smuggling Drugs May Face Execution 6:24pm Feb 7, 2012
Malaysia’s DRB-Hicom to Snare Carmaker Proton 9:09pm Jan 16, 2012
Malaysia Gay Festival Organizers Challenge Ban 6:14pm Jan 10, 2012
Malaysia Doesn’t Take Human Capital Problems Seriously 8:55am Dec 29, 2011
Malaysia's Movie Maverick 1:25pm Nov 30, 2011
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
392531Since when did the Indonesian government give a toss about people, apart from its corrupt elites? Crocodile tears about 'our brothers', who happen to be migrant workers, and thus unimportant. Indonesian politicians exist for themselves, their families, cronies, friends, hangers-on, those funding them as future powers to be, those with damning information, but most with no intent, ever, of being a servant for the great unwashed, at the last count about 237 million souls in Indonesia. That is why they are and will always be utter failures in the real world. The rhetoric is there but there is no action.
Unless and until this changes, and there is respect from politicians, industrialists, army, police and others, for Indonesians as citizens with rights, then a shameful, corrupt, backward, 3rd-world underperforming country is Indonesia's fate.
We could solve the problem by abolishing death sentences.It is time to look into this by both countries.
Malaysians should respect the Indonesian laws and in the same manner, Indonesians living in or coming to Malaysia should do the same. No exceptions.
i think everyone should responsible with what they did. if they found guilty, we should not seek pardon for them, even if the our people, because they had done something that harsh to the others. and also we should hand over the crimes to other country if they did crime there and ran away to our country. don't do shame thing just like US did upon their war crime, US will all out in defending their war thugs or other crimes
We have put many people, especially foreigners, on death penalties because of their involvement in smuggling drugs to Indonesia, we have no right to request for a pardon for these 177 Indonesians. What goes around comes around. Unless there are people wrongly convicted, I say leave them and may God have mercy on their souls.
- Previous
- 1
- Next
Jakarta. The President on Monday instructed the Ministry of Foreign Affairs to report accurate data on the number of Indonesians facing the death penalty in Malaysia, before it drafts plans on providing legal aid to the detainees.
President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono said the ministry must clarify conflicting figures from human rights watchdogs and other concerned groups that “have appeared everywhere, even in online media.”
“The Foreign Ministry, which is currently working to quickly resolve these issues, must report the actual figure [of Indonesians sentenced in Malaysia],” the Indonesian president said.
“[The ministry must report on] what steps we have taken to protect our brothers who have been sentenced according to Malaysia’s regulations, particularly those sentenced to death,” the president added.
Yudhoyono said many government leaders have requested the state to give lighter punishments to foreigners sentenced to death in Indonesia.
“Because of this, it is our duty to do the same for our own citizens. However, we need to respect the existing regulations in their respective countries, just as other countries respect the legal system of our country,” he said.
Mahfud Siddiq, chairman of House Commission I that oversees foreign affairs, said they will request Minister of Foreign Affairs Mary Natalagewa on Tuesday to provide updates on the number of Indonesian detainees in Malaysia, as well as the arrests of Indonesian maritime officers.
Last week, Migrant Care, the Commission for Missing Persons and Victims of Violence (Kontras) and Imparsial said there are 345 Indonesians imprisoned in Malaysia and sentenced to death over drug and homicide charges.
The groups called for immediate government action.
But Manpower and Transmigration Minister Muhaimin Iskandar said on Monday that the number of prisoners on death row has not reached 345.
He said that according to government figures, a total of 177 Indonesian citizens are facing the death penalty charges in Malaysia.
“The majority of them are migrant workers. Some of them only went to Malaysia for a short visit, but then they got involved in drug cases,” Muhaimin said.
“We will try hard. The president has instructed us to work hard. However, we cannot intervene in the legal process of Malaysia,” the minister added.
Widyarka Ryananta, social and cultural information counselor at the Indonesian embassy in Malaysia, confirmed the government’s tally.
“There are 177 Indonesians in Malaysia who are facing the death penalty charges, with 142 linked to drug cases and 35 were [implicated] in murder cases,” Widyarka told The Jakarta Globe.
The embassy official added that not a single Indonesian has been executed in Malaysia so far.
“We have never had a single Indonesian executed here,” Widyarka said. “We have always provided legal assistance to the best of our ability for every Indonesian citizen caught up in legal cases in Malaysia.”
Of the 142 people implicated in drug cases, Muhaimin said, 70 had been sentenced to death and “only three of them are facing execution, while the remainder of the cases are on appeal.”
The issue was brought to light after two Acehnese men, who were sentenced to death by hanging in Malaysia for drug trafficking, sought help from the state.
The Malaysian Supreme Court had rejected the appeals of Indonesians Bustaman bin Bukhari, 37, and Tarmizi bin Yakub, 38, who had no recourse left.
Both detainees, who have spent 15 years behind bars, also wrote to Kontras to ask for help with their situation.
Widyarka said there are 6,845 Indonesians holed up in Malaysian jails, the majority of whom were accused of crimes ranging from immigration violations, murder and drug trafficking.
Widyarka said that, as of 2007, 19 Indonesians sentenced to death had been granted clemency, 13 of whom had been involved in drug smuggling cases.
Following Monday’s cabinet meeting, Marty said he could not immediately provide data on the Indonesian detainees because he still has to coordinate with the Justice Ministry.
“The President has instructed us to establish a joint team from the Foreign Ministry, the Justice Ministry and other institutions to consolidate the information that we have and to push for maximum effort,” Marty said.
“In several cases, we successfully reduced the sentence from the death penalty to a lighter sanction,” he added.
Separately, House Deputy Speaker Priyo Budi Santoso of the Golkar Party said several ministries — including the Ministry of Manpower and Transmigration, Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Ministry of Defense — should be evaluated as soon as possible in order to make sure that they could provide adequate assistance to the prisoners.
“The [ministries] should be evaluated,” Priyo said. “There are 345 Indonesians sentenced to death. We must do something.”
Priyo said the Indonesian government should guarantee the safety of its citizens, no matter where they are in the world.
“Look at the United States. They will do anything for their people,” he said. “Even the highest official will go directly and talk to the concerned countries .”
Priyo said the government should respond quickly to the matter and give it “special attention,” since hundreds of Indonesian lives are at stake.
- Malaysian Girl Speaks Indonesian After Freak Accident: Report
- Indonesians Buying Up Most Expensive Homes in Singapore
- Indonesia Woman Kills Teenage Brother Over Sock Insult
- Funeral on Friday for Student Killed in Rafting Accident
- Concerned for Orangutans in Indonesia, US Girl Scouts Lobby for Sustainable Palm Oil
- Will Lady Gaga Finally Set Foot in Jakarta?
- Opening Eyes to Tolerance Via Film
- 5 More Prisoners Found After Jakarta Jail Break
- Indonesian Operators Ban Access to LGBT Advocacy Web Site
- Ariel Could Be Released From Jail in July
-
11:03pm | Notorious Gang Boss Could Be B...
But Indonesia Today is a very lucky country...I know poverty and deprivation is still a problem But if you look at USA, Eropa, Australia for exampl -
10:44pm | Concerned for Orangutans in In...
When people have decent job they will be able to think about their environment. Unfortunately, being greedy often drive us not to care about preser -
10:34pm | Breaking News: Dozens Feared D...
Probably the accident investigation will uncover: 1) bus driver was speeding, 2) bus driver was tired, and 3) bus was not maintained properly. -
9:55pm | Breaking News: Dozens Feared D...
Agreed SBD...and many other routes. I am always scared going with a rental car with "the family", cruising along the mountain stretches, -
8:48pm | Breaking News: Dozens Feared D...
It's amazing there are not a lot more accidents of this severity, given the crazed manner in which many bus drivers 'pilot' their vehicles on th -
7:40pm | Shocking Images Show Animal Cr...
I can definitely tell you that in Islam we do not discriminate animals based on their habit or size. All animals should be loved and not unnecessar -
7:18pm | Malaysian Police Detain Saudi ...
Is that something that interpol do ? Do they have to follow certain guideline on what can be classified as a crime ? -
7:13pm | Shocking Images Show Animal Cr...
Sorry Bawel, my brother... What do you do with Eid Al Adha? Slice (or watch the slicing of) the throat of the goat and let i
