Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Thu, February 9, 2012
Archive Search

Green Whistle-Blowing: Now by Text
Fidelis E Satriastanti | January 26, 2010

Workers sweeping up trash from Menteng River in Jakarta. Poor sanitation habits, including dumping garbage into waterways, have led to massive contamination of the country’s drinking water. (Photo: Safir Makki, JG) Workers sweeping up trash from Menteng River in Jakarta. Poor sanitation habits, including dumping garbage into waterways, have led to massive contamination of the country’s drinking water. (Photo: Safir Makki, JG)
Share This Page
39
0
0
2
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

Roland
10:45am Jan 27, 2010

The positive: Finally there is a way to report environmental compliance issues in a simple manner!

The negative: Is the ministry going to be ready? Judging from the article and opinions of the ministry there it is a big "NO". Quoting: "We received so many complaints"...on average the Ministry received 190 complaints a year - which is around one complaint every second day - to call this "so many" is a bit of an exaggeration! Also what is ineffective in receiving complains via letters, fax or e-mail? Also as admitted the operational fund and resources are insufficient and as a most challenging task in my humble opinion is to get the right mindset into all citizens of this country, especially the children. Not only the big corporations, because I believe they know, however they try to skip that part for cost reasons. Another huge challenge will be the mentioned communication and implementation between central and local administrations. And...finally...it is not about monitoring only, it is about action taken to prevent further breaches of the compliance plan. Because, don't we all (unfortunately!) know how an envelope filled with money (probably for the next mega-wedding of a local official!) with close both eyes and ears! What a pity and disgrace for this beautiful country!


Valkyrie
6:07am Jan 27, 2010

Loking at the photo above, I am imagining if it would be possible that this task be performed by "convicts" instead?

My idea is to have the corruptors, paedophilles, murderers etc., feel some humiliation and, by getting them involved may act as a deterrent towards prospective wannabes.

"Shame" punishment is an effective system. Anyone see a degradation of an individual with this?

They stole from us, took the lives of our loved ones, hurt our children and yet, we are housing and feeding them. I therefore feel strongly that "they" should repay to society in some form for their misdeeds.


  • Previous
  • 1
  • Next

Did you catch someone in the act of dumping buckets full of trash or toxic material into a river near you? Do you have a burning desire to tell off the government for doing little to halt the destruction of forests? If you want these matters heard and addressed directly by the government, just pick up your mobile phone.

The State Ministry of the Environment on Tuesday invited members of the public to text their environment-related complaints to a new hotline – 0811-932-932. The launch of the number coincides with a new Ministry Web site, penegakanhukum.menlh.go.id, dedicated to news, views, and existing regulations on the environment.

“We received so many complaints, mostly through letters, fax or e-mail, but the methods were ineffective and took a long time. It is simpler for villagers or anybody else to text, rather than find access to the Internet and type out their complaints,” said Ilyas Asaad, deputy minister for environmental compliance. He added that on average the Ministry received 190 complaints a year.

“With the new system, the Ministry is hoping that we can also monitor environmental conditions in Papua. One of the difficulties for monitoring environmental conditions is the relationship between locals and the district or subdistrict administrations,” Ilyas said.

He said administrators across the nation were still finding it a challenge to incorporate environmental issues in their local regulations.

“Ideally, all complaints should be taken into account. But because we still lack resources and the necessary funding, we need to set priorities and will, for example, go after larger companies instead of smaller ones,” Ilyas said.

Berry Nahdian Furqon, executive director of the Indonesian Forum for the Environment (Walhi), said the biggest challenge for the ministry was the steps the government would take once it received the complaints.

“The operational action counts. The relationship between the central government and regional administrations has been quite loose. The Ministry needs all the help they can receive from local administrations,” Berry said.

Furthermore, he said that green groups could use the system to address their complaints but they would still maintain their own independent methods to express their opinions.




  • 4:02pm | Axis of Hostility: Iran, Israe...
    Good article indeed. Let the Palestinian build their country in peace and the Iranian have their own way of living. The Iranian has indeed proven t
  • 3:44pm | Indonesians Buying Up Most Exp...
    I heard from someone corruption accounts for 30 % of Indonesia's economy. Actually people like Nazaruddin, Gayus are the priority buyers for housi
  • 3:39pm | The Thinker: Let's Talk About ...
    The government and health institutions need to get their heads out of the sand and begin providing birth control to unmarried women who want it. He
  • 3:35pm | Piece of Mind: Beggars vs. Wor...
    Nice article Natha... Keep up
  • 3:29pm | Indonesia Property Demand to R...
    part 2 Secondly a growth in property prices puts an ever greater wealth gap between those with and those without. The impact of cours
  • 3:15pm | New Indonesian TV Mini-Series ...
    If we have people who see stoning as inhuman, or yelling at God through mosque's speaker is disturbing... I doubt we could find a common ground.
  • 2:30pm | Indonesian Art Sales Among Fa...
    Good afternnon, you wrote :"Last year, Indonesia led the art world in auction revenue growth with 39 percent, followed by China’s 38 percent growt
  • 2:26pm | Malaysian Girl Speaks Indonesi...
    I'm a linguist and I know of studies which investigated similar cases (people who appeared to suddenly speak a language they don't know, sometime