Indonesian Gas Explosion Victims Fall Through Government Cracks
Stephanie Riady | July 22, 2010
Badly disfigured and injured Muhammad Sofyan in Gatot Subroto Hospital in Central Jakarta. Sofyan's four surviving daughters can not raise enough money to pay for his care after a Pertamina LPG cylinder exploded in his Tangerang home and killed his wife. (JG Photo/Stephanie Riady) Related articles
Strong US Data Drives Big Day for Southeast Asian Markets 8:03pm May 2, 2012
Indonesian Delegation Hopes to Have Prominent Voice at G-20 Trade Talks 12:25am Apr 18, 2012
Podomoro Reveals Industrial Park Plans 12:29am Apr 18, 2012
Indonesia Stands Out in Clean Energy Rise 5:09pm Apr 15, 2012
Pertamina Leads the Way as Companies Look to South Africa 8:45pm Apr 13, 2012
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
387220If something like this was to occur in a developed country, a proper investigation would have taken place and if necessary the cylinders recalled. I'm very concerned about this and I am going to make arrangements for the cylinder to be placed outside.
Wow this is pretty bad - it would be interesting to know how frequent accidents happen..
Pertamina should either switch over to the 3kg or insure both. Just because the 12kg tanks may be more cost effective or has been around since the 70s should not mean that it is the right choice.
The insurance sums which Pertamina pays out (for the 3 kg containers of course only!!!) are an insult by itself.
“Pertamina is only responsible for filling and distributing the tanks. Most incidents are caused by defects in the tanks and hoses — and WE source these from outside.”...so at least he (kind of) admits that they have been the ones who sources all these substandard hoses and regulators. Someone in this company must have put a signature under the deal to purchase them!
Who is it?
Did anyone before distribution made tests that they are applicable and safe?
Was there a minimum safety standard set?
Have they been on certified ISN standard? That's the least which is expected what a government affiliated company should do before distributing this equipment - it's their very own set safety standard!
Did somebody within Pertamina made the big buck by accepting and authorizing substandard equipment?
Someone must have had the authority to buy them - who is it?
What were the numbers - around 40 Million of them distributed - I cannot believe that there was not a Dollar or two rolling on the side!
Indeed shame on Pertamina to excuse itself now on faulty or substandard equipment - it was and still is their sole responsibility to face the consequences!
I do understand that many companies are outsourcing for a final product under their brand name, eg. car manufacturers but it is still the responsibility of the brand holder if this equipment malfunctions, therefore are usually quality checks in place to ensure that that the outsourced equipment stands the standards of the brand name! Is it now, that Pertamina didn't care at all, was it all just a hasty implementation without any planning ("let's take the first and cheapest available hoses and regulators...") or is it simply that quality requirements by Pertamina are simply on such a low level that there basically "nothing unusual" with this business deal!
And people are still blowing up, getting disfigured, their properties in shambles, families destroyed.....and Pertamina spokeswoman Wianda Pusponegoro still issues "Big Girl" corporation wisecracks and weak excuses for this disaster!
This situation is terrible. Basically every home has a potential bomb in it. Of course Pertamina has a responsibility here, and in turn the government. It is the usual story of no management, no control, and no desire to be responsible for anything.
This would almost make me want to switch to 3Kg cylinders. At least my wife will get something if I get blown up.
- Previous
- 1
- Next
Jakarta. On the fateful Tuesday morning last week, an LPG gas cylinder explosion claimed the life of Muhammad Sofyan’s beloved wife and left him fighting for his life with horrific burns to 35 percent of his body.
Such tragic cases, however, are not unusual. The Center of Public Interest Studies (Puskepi) has stated that there have been 78 recorded explosions so far this year, up from a total of 50 cases for all of 2009.
What is unusual is that Sofyan and his four surviving daughters that he must now care for alone have been given no financial assistance by state oil and gas company Pertamina.
The reason: The explosion in their Tangerang home was caused by a 12 kilogram, not a state-subsidized three kilogram, LPG cylinder.
“We have been told that we are not eligible for reimbursements because the insurance only covers explosions caused by three kilogram LPG cylinders,” Sofyan’s second eldest daughter, Yeni Yuniarti, told the Jakarta Globe.
Not only has the explosion torn the family apart, but the hospital bills that Sofyan, a small-scale entrepreneur, must pay are also proving crippling — the cost of the operations at state-owned Gatot Subroto Hospital in Jakarta will cost at least Rp 100 million ($11,000).
Yeni, 25, also a small entrepreneur, said the family home had been left in a shambles — the explosion that claimed the life of her mother had knocked over one of the house’s brick walls, blown the roof off and left much of the furniture badly charred.
With the breadwinner of the family debilitated, Yeni has been forced to rely on the kindness of neighbors to help pay for the education of two of her younger sisters, Sisilahwati and Cindy, who are 12th and 7th graders respectively.
Pertamina has coughed up Rp 7.5 million to compensate for the death of Nursiah, Sofyan’s wife, a fraction of the required amount.
Yeni said that after she appealed to Pertamina, they promised to supply an additional Rp 12.5 million compensation for the death, and additional support on a case-by-case basis.
“I went to Pertamina and asked [for the money], because my father’s treatment requires a down payment of Rp 15 million, and we simply don’t have it right now.”
The sisters have vowed to make sure their father gets the medical care he so badly needs.
“We will do whatever it takes to get that money needed for my father’s treatment,” Yeni says. “I never ask money for small little things, not even for my father’s medicine, but I pray that officials will at least help me finance his operations.”
What is a life worth?
Pertamina spokeswoman Wianda Pusponegoro confirmed that Pertamina’s government-mandated insurance policy only applied to those who used three kilogram LPG cylinders, which was part of the government’s move in 2007 to shift from the use of petroleum to LPG in the household.
For three kilogram gas cylinder explosions, Pertamina pay a maximum of Rp 25 million for a death or permanent injury, Rp 25 million for hospital care, Rp 2 million for a funeral and Rp 100 million for material damage.
The company has previously stated that is has so far paid out Rp 3 billion to victims.
Wianda said the compensation package was also dependent on the cause of the blast.
“Our insurance program does not include 12 kilogram tanks because these tanks have been around and fine since the 1970s,” Wianda said.
Furthermore, the program targeted those who were less financially well off, she says.
Wianda said that while Pertamina will continue to provide assistance on a case-by-case basis and “any help beyond this is voluntary and out of Pertamina’s etiquette of good will.”
“If something happens, let us know, and we will discuss it with the leaders in charge.”
Wianda, however, said that Pertamina had unfairly been blamed for the explosions.
“Pertamina is only responsible for filling and distributing the tanks. Most incidents are caused by defects in the tanks and hoses — and we source these from outside.”
Pertamina Policy Criticized
Pertamina’s stance has been criticized as being inadequate.
On Wednesday, members of the Indonesian National Committee of Youth (KNPI) peacefully demonstrated outside Pertamina headquarters in Central Jakarta, holding banners demanding that Pertamina take greater responsibility.
Another victim, Iswarni, said that though his son had lost his wife and home and suffered terrible burns after a three kilogram cylinder exploded in his Jakarta home in April, the family had been forced to sell a property in East Java to cover the medical expenses and cost of repairing the house.
Pertamina has since reimbursed the family for their expenses.
Iswarni, whose hands are badly burned and stiff, said he had two wishes.
“First, I would like to fully recover. Secondly, I would like to be given some money to buy a drinks stand.”
The list of grieving victims continues.
Mulyati, whose five-year-old son Zidan Gilbran was badly disfigured as he passed Iswarni’s home when the cylinder exploded, said she prayed Pertamina would pay for the plastic surgery for his face.
- Tomy Winata to Build Jakarta's Tallest Building
- Lady Gaga Angers Thai Fans With Fake Rolex Comment
- Lady Gaga Refuses to Tone Down Her Shows: Manager
- Indonesia Set to Cap Bank Owners’ Stakes: Sources
- President's Son Nearly Attacked by Angry Mob
- Singapore Cabby Jailed for Molesting Indonesian Maid
- If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Watch, Djoko Says of Gaga
- Indonesia's Chief Justice Demands SBY Explain Corby Clemency
- National Exams' ‘Fantastic’ Passing Rate Suspicious: ICW
- Djoko Says ‘I Don’t Care’ About FPI Demonstration
-
10:41pm | Djoko Says ‘I Don’t Care’ Abou...
Meanwhile, in complete contrast from what the S.O.B is at liberty to say under the freedom of his beloved Indonesian constitution.... -
10:34pm | Tomy Winata to Build Jakarta's...
As sound as interesting it is, and how people would picture this monumental skyscraper will glorify the skyline of Jakarta. I see no objectives. -
10:34pm | Indonesian Police Consider Ton...
A small but extremely loud group of mentally retarded inbreds. And you know what we do with retarded inbreds: we ignore them. -
10:30pm | If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Wa...
The picture showed People with deepest and darkest hatred for other human beings and showing their true color by calling them KAFIR? You can only s -
10:04pm | Djoko Says ‘I Don’t Care’ Abou...
more on Sobri (lets call him S.O.B. from now on) Jakarta Post 15/4/08 – A videotape screened on Monday showed Islamic Defenders Front (FPI) -
9:42pm | Lady Gaga Concert Promoter Has...
the whole country went gaga over lady gaga -
9:41pm | Two IPB Security Guards Shot D...
Ah Bogor - such a center of peace and piety. -
9:39pm | Lady Gaga Concert Promoter Has...
"a permit from the venue, a recommendation from the Jakarta police, a recommendation from the Tourism and Creative Economy Ministry, a permit for
