Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Sat, May 26, 2012
Archive Search

Indonesian Government Slams Beheading in Saudi Arabia
Ismira Lutfia & Markus Junianto Sihaloho | June 20, 2011

Indonesian migrant workers wait to disembark on their arrival from Saudi Arabia at Tanjung Priok Port, North Jakarta, last month. The government has said it will protest the execution of an Indonesian in Saudi Arabia after she was convicted of murder. JG Photo/Yudhi Sukma Wijaya Indonesian migrant workers wait to disembark on their arrival from Saudi Arabia at Tanjung Priok Port, North Jakarta, last month. The government has said it will protest the execution of an Indonesian in Saudi Arabia after she was convicted of murder. JG Photo/Yudhi Sukma Wijaya
Share This Page
85
24
0
14
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

Roland
8:02pm Jun 21, 2011

@devine - indeed! After I placed the question a related article mentioned the number. I was actually quite surprised about the high number of Indonesian "criminals" which "deserve" the death sentence! My suspect about the initial reason to commit a crime is as you mentioned. It would be actually really interesting what the gender, the occupation during their stay in SA as well as their crime was to "deserve" to have the head chopped off!

devine
6:48pm Jun 21, 2011

Roland, in a seperate news item on JG yesterday it was reported that currently 22 !!! Indonesians are on death row in Saudi Arabia. My guess is that most of them are maids and that will be put to death after being mistreated to the point where the could not take it anymore...

gharadiran
4:41pm Jun 21, 2011

It's a barbaric civilization. A remnant of an antiquated civilization so far removed from the modern world. This is what is supposed to be the "master race" of all muslims?

DrDez
6:20am Jun 21, 2011

TGIF

That is what our people claim ... As yet it is not certain what they did or did not not know (and I doubt if we will ever know) If it goes very quiet soon you can assume that we did actually know..

Things we do know - She was sentenced to death several months ago.

Things we dont know - in that time what have the Indonesian Consulate done? They were denied proper assistance... what does that mean?

Things we also know is that public executions are announced several days in advance (to ensure a crowd I guess) so again.. what did our people know and what did they do?


TGIF
9:16pm Jun 20, 2011

@subrotto...I don't believe in capital punishment either but the difference here that the Saudis did not inform Indonesia of this poor woman to be slaughtered for their enjoyment under their Sharia law. That's the brouhaha!!!

The government says it will issue a formal protest over the execution in Saudi Arabia of an Indonesian migrant worker convicted of murder, arguing that it had been in the middle of seeking clemency for her when she was executed.

Ruyati Binti Sapubi, a migrant worker from Bekasi, was beheaded by sword in the western province of Mecca on Saturday for murdering her female employer, stabbing her repeatedly in the head and neck with a kitchen knife in January 2010.

Didi Wahjudi, a representative from the Indonesian consulate in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, said neither the consulate nor the embassy in Riyadh had been informed about the execution.

He said the consulate only learned of it through media reports as well as from members of the Indonesian community in the country.

“We were actually in the middle of seeking clemency on behalf of the victim’s family and were conducting other non-litigation efforts,” he said.

“We are not happy that the execution happened without us being notified.”

Despite two diplomatic notes asking for consular access to Ruyati, Didi said Saudi authorities kept the embassy out of the loop during her trial.

He said Indonesian officials had also tried to meet with her when she appeared in court.

However, he said Ruyati had pleaded guilty to the murder and such crimes were punishable by death in Saudi Arabia.

Meanwhile, the government on Sunday said it condemned the execution and would formally censure Saudi Arabia’s ambassador to Indonesia, saying the Saudi authorities had not allowed it to provide Ruyati with proper consular assistance.

“Without disregard to the governing laws in Saudi Arabia, the Indonesian government condemns the execution that was carried out without upholding the international practice in relation to providing consular protection,” Foreign Ministry spokesman Michael Tene said.

A ministry press release said the Saudi Arabian ambassador would be officially summoned so the government could present its case, while the Indonesian ambassador in Riyadh would be recalled to Jakarta “for consultation.”

Ruyati’s daughter, identified only as Evi, told radio station El Shinta that her mother’s placement agency had falsified her age, cutting it from 54 to 35, so she could qualify to work abroad.

Separately, Hikmahanto Juwana, an international law expert at University of Indonesia, called for a halt to migrant workers being sent to Saudi Arabia.

“The withdrawal is necessary to voice the Indonesian government’s objection to the beheading, and the government is entitled to demand an explanation from the Saudi authorities about why they failed to inform the embassy there,” he told the Jakarta Globe.

He said more pressure should also be exerted on Riyadh to take firm legal action against abusive Saudi employers. “Migrant workers do not go abroad to commit crimes,” he said. “If they do commit a crime, it must be because of the violent treatment they get from their employers.”

Tjahjo Kumolo, from the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI-P), called for the ambassador to Saudi Arabia, Gatot Abdullah Mansyur, to be fired over the mishandling of the case.

“The Foreign Ministry said they did not know about Ruyati’s case,” he said. “So what is the ambassador doing there? The ambassador must be dismissed.”