Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Sat, February 11, 2012
Archive Search

Indonesian’s Death Sentence Calls Into Question Fairness of Malaysian Courts
Fitri & Putri Prameshwari | September 05, 2010

Mohamed Saleh, 60, showing a picture of his son, Edy Saputra, who is on death row in Malaysia. Saleh says Edy is innocent.  Mohamed Saleh, 60, showing a picture of his son, Edy Saputra, who is on death row in Malaysia. Saleh says Edy is innocent.
Share This Page
19
12
0
6
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

Ivanovich
6:08pm Sep 7, 2010

To rob and had the victim killed with a group of people is wrong. The best scenario for him would be life imprisonment. From the photo, he look like a good schoolboy, and he together with others might had resorted to rob due to frustration and feeling of been cheated. However, think about the victim who was innocent and not a party for his

predicament. Edy have to serve his rightful punishment. As for his employer, the Malaysian authorities should investigate and if the allegation found truth, shall be prosecuted (jailed & wealth confiscated) to the full extend of the law. Let this lesson be known to others (Indonesian & Malaysian) that

this tragedy should be avoided (not to happen) in the first place.


layman
9:24am Sep 6, 2010

"However, on their way they ended up robbing what they believed was an empty house in Serian, 65 kilometers from Kuching. The owner surprised them in the act, and in the ensuing tussle they killed him,"

Many may wonder, was it FAIR for the house owner to die protecting HIS property. If Edy and Erwan were so desperate for food or transportation back to the border, they could seek help from villagers rather than robbing and killing someone. The perception one gets reading Indonesian news is that Indonesians should always get the right of way when dealing with others, especially Malaysians, even on foreign soil. That is one nauseating nationalism.


sirlance
8:30am Sep 6, 2010

I dont know how to react with this kind of reporting.. laugh or cry..

But something to bear in mind... a good person will never (even when thing are very very hard..) do ..err btw, on our way home we rob a house and my friend kill the owner..

Serve him right.. the house owner have family kids that are now orphan and wife that is now a widow. Let him hang.


danielnoor
1:07am Sep 6, 2010

Those in death row, 99.9 percent will deny that they commit the crime. This is normal. Nobody wants to die. But the law wil exhaust itself before sentencing as they too does not wish to take an innocent life for nothing.Whether you in Malaysia or Indonesia or USA ,etc once you commit a crime and there are evidences that you committed it, then you face the music.


foto4mike
12:17am Sep 6, 2010

I'd rather be tried 100 times before a Court in Malaysia than one time here in Indonesia. However I still see a chance to move onwards: Indonesia can make the first move and abolish death penalty immediately and forever! Having done that, maybe then there is a chance to convince Malaysia to move along the same road. Otherwise: why should Malaysia safe a convicted murderer from the death row, when Indonesia happily kills foreigners here?


Mataram. Amid the recent revelations about the high number of Indonesians currently facing the death sentence in Malaysia, one family is speaking up about their efforts to get their loved one’s sentence commuted.

Mohamad Saleh, 60, said on Sunday in Mataram that he believed his son, Edy Saputra, was innocent of the murder charge for which he had been convicted.

“I miss my son,” Saleh said. “I want him freed from his death sentence.”

In 2006, Edy was arrested in the Malaysian state of Sarawak for robbing a house there and killing its owner.

Endang Susilowati, an activist from the Panca Karsa Foundation, an advocacy group involved in the case, said that throughout his trial at a court in the state capital of Kuching, Edy always denied he had murdered the man.

“Edy always said Erwan [a fellow migrant worker from West Nusa Tenggara] was the one who killed the man, not him,” Endang said.

“During the trial, there was no evidence to show that Edy had murdered the victim.”

Edy departed for Entikong, Malaysia, in April 2006 through an illegal placement agency. Without any official work or immigration documents, Edy and a group of seven other workers from Indonesia moved from one job to another before finally ending up at a plantation in Miri, Endang said.

She added that after six months there, Edy had still not received a salary or the fake passport he was promised by his employer, so he decided to escape from the plantation with Erwan and return home to Indonesia.

However, on their way they ended up robbing what they believed was an empty house in Serian, 65 kilometers from Kuching. The owner surprised them in the act, and in the ensuing tussle they killed him, Endang said.

They split up immediately afterward, and Edy was later arrested. Erwan, meanwhile, remains at large.

Since 2007, Edy’s family has sought to appeal the death sentence handed down to him, even going to Kuching in March 2008 to file an appeal, but to no avail.

Zaenuddin, a relative of Edy’s, said that with no knowledge of his current condition, the family could only hope that he had not been executed yet.

“Maybe he’s still alive because what he said about not killing the victim is true,” he said. “That’s what we believe in as well.”

He added that he hoped the Indonesian government would help get Edy’s sentence commuted from death.

Agus Triyanto, the labor attache at the Indonesian Embassy in Kuala Lumpur, said his office was “trying its best” to help Indonesians there with legal troubles.

“Every case is tightly monitored,” he said.

As many as 177 Indonesians in Malaysia are currently either on death row or face charges that could see them receive the death sentence, according to the Indonesian government.

Of that figure, 35 are implicated in murder cases.




  • 11:03pm | Notorious Gang Boss Could Be B...
    But Indonesia Today is a very lucky country...I know poverty and deprivation is still a problem But if you look at USA, Eropa, Australia for exampl
  • 10:44pm | Concerned for Orangutans in In...
    When people have decent job they will be able to think about their environment. Unfortunately, being greedy often drive us not to care about preser
  • 10:34pm | Breaking News: Dozens Feared D...
    Probably the accident investigation will uncover: 1) bus driver was speeding, 2) bus driver was tired, and 3) bus was not maintained properly.
  • 9:55pm | Breaking News: Dozens Feared D...
    Agreed SBD...and many other routes. I am always scared going with a rental car with "the family", cruising along the mountain stretches,
  • 8:48pm | Breaking News: Dozens Feared D...
    It's amazing there are not a lot more accidents of this severity, given the crazed manner in which many bus drivers 'pilot' their vehicles on th
  • 7:40pm | Shocking Images Show Animal Cr...
    I can definitely tell you that in Islam we do not discriminate animals based on their habit or size. All animals should be loved and not unnecessar
  • 7:18pm | Malaysian Police Detain Saudi ...
    Is that something that interpol do ? Do they have to follow certain guideline on what can be classified as a crime ?
  • 7:13pm | Shocking Images Show Animal Cr...
    Sorry Bawel, my brother... What do you do with Eid Al Adha? Slice (or watch the slicing of) the throat of the goat and let i