Jakarta Police Forced Into U-Turn Over Raids And Abuse Tests for Street Children
Arientha Primanita & Zaky Pawas | January 22, 2010
A child busker getting a donation at Jakarta's Hotel Indonesia traffic circle. (SP Photo) Related articles
In the War on Beggars, Who’s Right and Who’s Wrong? 11:29pm Sep 4, 2011
Buskers, Beggars and Street Kids Off Jakarta's Streets for Ramadan 10:56am Jul 21, 2011
8,000 Street Kids to Get Rp 1.4m Each 3:30pm Apr 9, 2011
For Children of Migrant Workers, Malnutrition Threat 11:48pm Jan 9, 2011
Indonesian Minister Confident Street Children Problem Solved by 2014 4:25pm Nov 17, 2010
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
354011and people can raid senayan to examine the parliament members for corruption, political (and sexual) abuses too . . .
padt - there you go.....we still have Boediono and Sri Mulyani who risked their bums being scewed for making those decisions.
The idiots are still trying very hard to find the right orifice whilst screwing around like blue arse flies.
That room in Senayan for the last two months are filled with wannabes and demigods. Target -2014.
Some years ago I worked briefly in a very mediocre business that was going no where fast, where everything was decided at meetings by people bringing up 'good ideas'. There would be a problem and someone would say, "I've a good idea! Why don't we do this...." And people would sit around the table and say, "Yes, that's a good idea. Why don't we try that." And they would....and in a few months we were back to stage one with the same problem or worse. It was always a case of one step forward and two steps back. If, as I usually did, you questioned the 'good idea' or disagreed with it outright, the pressure on you to conform was noticeable. You were singled out as excessively critical, not a caring person and not a team worker. In short, bullied into submission.
The trouble was that no one was prepared in the first place to look at the problem, acknowledge it for what it was, find out why we had it in the first place and then think about the best way to solve it. So instead of engaging in the situation, everyone reacted to it. Hence, every decison was usually a knee-jerk reaction. Not thought through beyond the next square.
I suspect the initial decision to get out on the street and look up little (and not so little) kid's bums was a knee-jerk reaction and I am pleased to hear that, because of sober, wise and informed pressure, it has been scrapped. A good decision, indicating that wiser people have pointed out consequences that the original decision makers had not considered.
Nevertheless, it raises the question why people make these kind of knee-jerk decisions in the first place.
As far as I could work out in the place I worked in - it was because the people running the show weren't very intelligent. And as a result, their main concern was to safe guard their jobs, titles, influence and position. They were afraid that somehow if they thought too much (even if they were capable of doing so) about the situation, it might show that they were in fact partially responsible for the problem. So they used diversionary tactics to avoid any responsibility or idea that somehow they might be part of, if not the cause of the problem and ran the show on 'good ideas'.
Good Ideas? Quid pro bono? Good for whom?
You don't run an institution, or a country on good ideas. You get things done and get things changed by facing the facts in the cold, hard light of daytime.
You have homeless kids on the street and people sexually abusing them and killing them because you have an unjust structures within a society which has its core values shoved up its bum. It's the national bum you need to look up. Not these kids' bums.
The right move.
Why on earth do the police always jump in with knee jerk ideas and reactions and always end up looking so bloody stupid? It is just another in the long line of examples that lead pretty much everybody, apart from the powers that be, to the inevitable conclusion that the police need a thorough overhaul.
- Previous
- 1
- Next
The Jakarta city administration has been forced to drop a controversial plan to stage raids to catch street children and subject them to physical examinations for evidence of sexual abuse, saying on Thursday that it will adopt a softer, more persuasive approach.
Budi Hardjo, head of the city’s Social Affairs Agency, backtracked on comments to the Jakarta Globe on Wednesday in which he said that children caught in a citywide dragnet in cooperation with the police, the Jakarta Health Agency and the Ministry of Social Affairs would be given “rectal examinations for indications of sodomy.”
“People misunderstood the program and the intentions of the joint team, degrading the program even though it had good intentions. Bekasi conducted the raids first, and people assumed that we would use the same methods,” he said on Thursday, referring to Jakarta’s satellite city in West Java.
The U-turn is an embarrassment to authorities, who stand accused of hatching an ill-conceived strategy to assure the public they weren’t neglecting the city’s street children — estimated at well over 4,000 — in the wake of the recent confession by alleged serial killer Bayquni, aka Babe, that he had raped and killed at least 10 young boys.
Following an outcry from the public and activists, Harry Hikmat, director of child social services at the Ministry of Social Affairs, said the plan to have the capital free of street children by next year would no longer include police raids on their known hangouts.
He also said the ministry was cooperating with local authorities, including in Jakarta, on the street children issue.
“The method was never meant to be a raid, we know that it’s a term used for crime,” Harry told a news conference. “We will first do assessments to learn who they are, their backgrounds and their experiences during their lives on the streets.”
The Jakarta Social Affairs Agency will collect data on street children and beggars until Feb. ary 19, he said, which will be followed by visits from social workers.
“The social workers will go to the streets and [homeless] shelters to have persuasive conversations with the children to get to know them personally,” Harry said, adding that the program will run continually.
The results of the assessments will be used to help form national and regional policies on child protection, as well as new programs to get children off the streets. The interviews will also find out whether the children have been molested or abused while working or living on the streets, he said.
- Tomy Winata to Build Jakarta's Tallest Building
- Lady Gaga Angers Thai Fans With Fake Rolex Comment
- Lady Gaga Refuses to Tone Down Her Shows: Manager
- Indonesia Set to Cap Bank Owners’ Stakes: Sources
- President's Son Nearly Attacked by Angry Mob
- Singapore Cabby Jailed for Molesting Indonesian Maid
- Indonesia's Chief Justice Demands SBY Explain Corby Clemency
- National Exams' ‘Fantastic’ Passing Rate Suspicious: ICW
- If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Watch, Djoko Says of Gaga
- Malaysian Authorities Seize Copies of Irshad Manji’s Book
-
7:28pm | Police Arrest Suspect Who Trie...
Quick but not for bekasi church when they were attacked... -
7:26pm | Police Arrest Suspect Who Trie...
So the POLRI can actually move quickly...(in some instances). Their motto ‘Rastra Sewakottama’ (People's Main Servant). -
7:10pm | Two IPB Security Guards Shot D...
Appalling, and at prayer time too. -
7:06pm | Djoko Says ‘I Don’t Care’ Abou...
“remember that Indonesia has a constitution” Should be the new national motto emblazoned on the Sang Saka Merah-Putih flag. -
7:02pm | Indonesia Wants 10,000 Child W...
A good start would be to issue every one of them (who don't already have one) a birth certificate so that they can be truly called Indonesians wit -
6:56pm | Former Social Minister to Be R...
He’s PPP (Peci Packing Parasite). -
6:53pm | Indonesia Wants 10,000 Child W...
"... child workers, between 6 and 18 years of age..." - the first number, can this be true? 6 year young child workers...that is worse than I tho -
6:29pm | Djoko Says ‘I Don’t Care’ Abou...
I don't get how a concert is against the constitution. Where does it say concerts deemed "immoral" cannot run? Our politicians need to understan
