Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Fri, May 25, 2012
Archive Search

KAI Believes It Has Concrete Solution for Rooftop Riders
Dessy Sagita & Vento Saudale | January 12, 2012

Passengers riding atop the roof of a commuter train at Gambir station in Central Jakarta on Wednesday. State railway operator Kereta Api Indonesia is planning a series of new hanging concrete barriers that would prevent passengers from sitting on the roofs of train cars. (JG Photo/Jurnasyntao Sukarno) Passengers riding atop the roof of a commuter train at Gambir station in Central Jakarta on Wednesday. State railway operator Kereta Api Indonesia is planning a series of new hanging concrete barriers that would prevent passengers from sitting on the roofs of train cars. (JG Photo/Jurnasyntao Sukarno)
Share This Page
10
1
0
9
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

Roland
1:40pm Jan 12, 2012

maybe the REAL solution would be a better and decent scheduling of trains on all lines. I mean these trains are already crowded as they are and people need to go and come from work in a decent way. The lethal idea with the concrete balls is outrageous and will have the same end as the sprinklers which sprayed paint on roof riders.

I do understand though that certain people are defiant on any rules set up - not only for trains - just look at the streets - 5 minutes out on the road one can see at least ten violations to any acceptable traffic rules.


BilboBaggins
10:02am Jan 12, 2012

I think I would try a less lethal barrier.

How about a simple high volume sprinkler bar placed over the tracks at the exit from each station.

Should be cheap to build and fairly effective. Only needs to be turned on as a train passes by.


DrDez
9:27am Jan 12, 2012

Human... 2 new sports in one go... my we are creative, it must be those vocational schools... except most these kids don't go to school and are probably part of the 50 million kids without birth certs...THATS A CLUE MR P.

No doubt another new sport in the SEA Games for 2015 in which we will excel by virtue of being the only entrant (again)

Rules... well try not to die Mo, if you do then you get extra points for blood splat style. But it won't matter because you will be dead.

Funny really that the first kid to be wiped out will have his picture splattered all over the media - not a word will be said about the damage to kids or morality... unless his/her armpits are on show of course...


human2
7:54am Jan 12, 2012

DrDez u need to clarify the rules of dodging. Is it dodging the concrete balls or the body parts flying off and hitting pedestrians? I can imagine a morning commute would be really ruined by being hit by a headless torso or perhaps an eyeball landing in your bubur?


DrDez
7:37am Jan 12, 2012

how long before dodging them becomes a sport?


After numerous failed attempts to persuade people to stop riding on the roofs of train cars, state railway company Kereta Api Indonesia is hoping the threat of injury, or even death, will put a stop to the already dangerous practice.

The company announced on Wednesday that it planned to install hanging deterrents in the form of rows of concrete balls that will stop anything — living or dead — in its tracks.

Mateta Rizalulhaq, a spokesman for KAI, said the concrete balls would be hung at rooftop height at several stations, such as Bekasi, Tambun and Cikarang, and at train crossings.

“With this method, we hope the passengers will no longer sit on the train roof, as it is dangerous,” Mateta told the Jakarta Globe on Wednesday.

He declined to give a specific start date for the new scheme but said that it would be implemented soon.

KAI has experimented with several tactics to stop rail riders from seeking seats on train car rooftops, but the practice has persisted. Recently, the company sought the help of religious leaders, asking them to speak to their followers about the dangers of riding atop trains.

Last year, KAI installed paint guns at various points that would spray those riding on rooftops. That plan merely resulted in angry, paint-spattered riders.

“We really hope those who have authority, such as the Transportation Ministry and the police, help us in enforcing the law because we have limited authority,” Mateta said.

Wednesday was supposed to be the start of yet another crackdown on roof riders, but tactics employed by stations are typically limited to announcements and verbal scoldings.

West Java’s Bojong Gede station chief, Dharmawan, said his 15-strong staff was powerless to deal with the roof riders.

“During rush hour, trains from Bogor are packed while passengers waiting [at the Bojong Gede station] often can’t get onboard,” he said.

“We have tried warning people not to ride on the roof using banners and loudspeaker announcements. We even tried getting help from clerics, but they don’t usually last long. Our officers even had stones thrown at them by people refusing to get down from the roof.”

The Depok Lama and Depok Baru stations plan on building a series of bars to close the gaps between the stations’ roofs and train rooftops.

“At the Depok stations, there is no gap where passengers can get onto the roof or for them to climb down,” Depok Lama station chief Gatot said.

But the official admitted that eventually roof riders would find a way to get on top of the train by climbing up once the train cleared the station’s roof.

Gatot said that to effectively reduce the number of roof riders, more trains were needed.

“Each train car has a capacity of 160 people, but during rush hour more than 200 can cram into every little space,” he said.

Joko Setijowarno of the Indonesian Transportation Society criticized the varying approaches used by different stations, adding that preventing roof riding required a uniform and continuous policy.

“You can’t do one thing at Station A and do another at Station B, or do one thing today and do another thing the next day. Everything has to be done simultaneously for the program to work,” he said.

Seventeen-year-old Adit said he liked roof riding with friends just for the fun of it. “There’s a rush when you get on top of the train, plus the view is great and you don’t have to pay,” he said.