Miss Indonesia Shames Us All, Cry Aceh’s Clerics
Nurdin Hassan | October 12, 2009
Newly crowned Putri Indonesia Qory Sandioriva from Aceh celebrating with other finalists after being crowned during the grand final in Jakarta on Friday. (Photo: AFP) Related articles
Miss Dominican Republic Is a Mrs: Organizers 12:18pm Apr 26, 2012
Sex Change Might Not Bar Wannabe Beauty Queen 11:45am Apr 3, 2012
Asia’s Coffee Bean Queen 7:40pm Sep 26, 2011
Islam’s Answer to Miss Universe 7:01pm Sep 18, 2011
Jakarta, Meet Your Abang None 7:04pm Jul 26, 2011
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
334970Funny that the 'Western values' are being claimed to be at fault. Which language are we all debating in? To say that one viewpoint is of less value than another is simply xenophobic. Shall we continue this discussion in a more Eastern language?
Islamophobia is an interesting coinage that we've been hearing over the past few years and one that I totally reject. A phobia is an irrational fear of something however, religions, as belief systems, posit themselves well within the ambit of philosophy and human discourse. In fact Islam itself has traditions based on the long debate and deep discussions of the Greeks etc. My objection to Islam and all monotheisms are equally rational and thus -phobia is a deeply erroneous coinage.
The current Islamist mindset is an almost treasonous assault on the values of debate that lie at the religion's origins. Perhaps all religions become like this eventually though, hugely distorted through time, based , as they all most surely are, in supernatural fluff, insubstantial as opposed to transubstantial. Faiths just become a set of rules to follow for the dependent mind. Alas however you don't get at truths by pointing at things and saying"Do this" , Religious texts 'work' through discussion and debate, they are works of metaphor, allegory and simile. It is in this interpretative realm that their value, if any, lies. It would seem though, that our morality has evolved and far outstripped 2000 year old bronze age modes of thought. Enjoy your stonings and lashings. It's the women I feel sorry for.
Kiai Carita:
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!
Nice!
Sufehmi says:
I disagree with French gov't, by banning jilbab they are taking away people's right to belief.
---AND---
I have no problem with people sporting symbols that they like/belief - crosses, goth accessories, jilbab, etc. In any day, I WILL support my fellow humans right to belief in Jesus / Buddha / gods / etc; and to express it.
Again, the rule is only applicable at schools, and such, and applies to ALL students, so also to Muslims...
And they are definitely NOT taking away your right to believe
It is backwardness of people who tend to feel higher than this rule, because they feel a headscarf makes you a better believer.
I have yet to discover the Surah in which Allah tells women to wear headscarves.
wak atan:
Just keep out of this discussion with your "peabrain" outburts.
Banda Aceh. In the latest religious dispute out of Aceh, a prominent group of Islamic clerics has denounced newly crowned Putri Indonesia Qori Sandioriva for “bringing shame” to the province by abandoning its conservative Muslim values on her way to winning the title.
Sandioriva, 18, who was born in Jakarta but has an Acehnese mother, beat out 37 other contestants from 33 provinces to win the pageant on Friday. She will represent Indonesia in the 2010 Miss Universe Pageant.
Aceh’s Daya Ulema Association criticized Sandioriva for not wearing a jilbab during the competition or observing other norms of Shariah law. Granted special autonomy, the province strictly adheres to Shariah law.
“We are not bothered by the Putri Indonesia contest. What bothers [us] is why she represented Aceh, but did not reflect the values and culture of the Acehnese people who are well-known for their Islamic faith,” said Teungku Faisal Ali, the association’s secretary general.
“Dayah [and all ulema regret that a contestant representing Aceh did so without representing Aceh’s values.”
The province has imposed partial Shariah law since 2001, and expanded it further under a 2006 autonomy law. However, the province’s laws must not violate existing national laws or the Constitution, a situation that has created legal tussles.
Last month, Aceh’s provincial legislature passed a bylaw mandating that adulterers be stoned to death, which drew protests from human rights groups and brought embarrassing international media attention. Aceh Governor Irwandi Yusuf has refused to sign the new bylaw.
Regardless, the uproar over Putri Indonesia has shown that some groups in Aceh continue to flex their muscles in support of its autonomy, even though the pageant doesn’t have a swimsuit competition.
Faisal said Sandioriva shouldn’t have represented Aceh because her father is Sundanese and she studies at the University of Indonesia near Jakarta.
Sandioriva, who finished in the top five in both the gown competition and the interview segment, said she received permission from the Aceh government to compete, given that the province doesn’t have a selection process for Putri Indonesia.
“If it is true the Aceh government gave her permission, then their commitment to enacting Shariah is questionable,” Faisal said, adding that Acehnese contestants should only show their face, palms and feet.
In reply to a question, Sandioriva told the pageant’s host, Charles Bonar Sirait, that she didn’t feel the need to wear a jilbab or veil.
“Hair is beauty, and I am proud of beauty,” she said.
The controversy may return next year when Sandioriva competes in Miss Universe, which has a swimsuit competition.
“Promoting Aceh should not be done by showing genitalia, especially when she competes for the Miss Universe title, which surely will disgrace Aceh even more,” Faisal said.
Sandioriva’s win was a hot topic among local Facebook browsers over the weekend, with many supporting the new beauty queen but most reprimanding her for not wearing a jilbab.
- Indonesian Fans Stage Flash Mob for Gaga
- Five Jakarta Governor Candidates Guarantee Religious Freedom
- Dangdut Music Gets Its Groove Back
- Police Chief to Be Summoned Over Lady Gaga and Church Dispute Controversies
- Sukhoi Victim Identification Process Completed
- Jakarta Poaches on Farmland Waters
- Red Shirts Send Warning to Thai Elite
- Lady Gaga to Go on in Philippines Despite Rallies
- 21 Kalimantan Sex Workers Test Positive for HIV
- Rise of Australia’s ‘Feral Billionaires’
-
3:10pm | The Thinker: May 1998 Revisite...
simsin: I totally agree with you. The Indonesians that committed the atrocities in 1998 are the same breed that are murdering ethnic and religious -
3:07pm | China to Speed Up Approvals fo...
@maharaja aka 22 - I am living here since more than 17 years and are married here. You are absolutely NOT in the position to tell me off, you littl -
3:06pm | Breaking: Prosecutors Seek Lif...
To be fair, death penalty will only add to the already long list of martyrs of radicalism (see Imam Samudra & co.), becoming the idols of Mujahiddi -
3:03pm | The Thinker: May 1998 Revisite...
@maharaja - your attitude of denial and shifting guilt to others is...well, actually I am speechless (in a very negative sense) about your comment! -
2:58pm | Jakarta Drug Bust Nets 4 Suspe...
Wiggum and his pals are lighting the pipes tonight ladies and gentlemen... -
2:57pm | Lady Gaga Is the Least of Indo...
Lady Gaga is too sexy for Indonesia? It's BS. Just watch Dangdut Koplo concert. If dangdut concert such as that is allowed, I don't see why LG is -
2:56pm | Lady Gaga Is the Least of Indo...
But it's still pushing through in the Philippines, right? At least the voice of the conservative Christians were drowned by democra -
2:54pm | Indonesian Fans Stage Flash Mo...
I think the sentence "putting house in order" has different meaning for maharaja. "Putting house in order" probably means banning mini skirt or
