Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Wed, February 8, 2012
Archive Search

Most Support Caning of Women, Says Malaysian Official
February 24, 2010

Malaysian Muslim women buy groceries at a wet market in Kota Bharu. (Reuters Photo/Zainal Abd Halim) Malaysian Muslim women buy groceries at a wet market in Kota Bharu. (Reuters Photo/Zainal Abd Halim)
Share This Page
46
0
0
10
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

Valkyrie
7:53am Feb 26, 2010

Are you all aware that judicial caning, is also a form of corporal punishment in Singapore? If I'm not mistaken this punishment only applies to male criminals between the ages of 18-50.

In 1993, Michael P. Fay, an American, briefly shot to fame when he was jailed for 4 months, fined S$3,500 and received four strokes of the rotan, for theft and vandalism.

To date, this has worked well for Singapore.

Note: criminals undergo medical examinations to identify if they are medically fit to be caned. Medical officers are present whenever canings are performed.


Kiai Carita
4:25pm Feb 25, 2010

Al Qaeda and Malaysia should work together to humiliate Muslims everywhere with their bigotry. Shame on you Malaysia! Shame on you!


Roland
4:23pm Feb 25, 2010

Let us just hope that this kind of Sharia law never makes its way into Indonesian law - because here the general population consists of around 90 % Muslims and, same as LAYMAN mentioned in Malaysia, modern Islamic scholars are many times over-shouted by fundamentalist ones.

Ans Simon, YES, this assaults are an affront to humanity.


Simon
1:34pm Feb 25, 2010

The word seems appropriate here: what a pig of a man.

Assaulting anyone, but most especially women, is an affront to humanity.

But, then, I guess this guy also thinks that horses flew once, no?


layman
11:46am Feb 25, 2010

The report title and the Jakim DG's statement are misleading. The DG cannot say most Malaysians accept the caning of women under the country’s Shariah courts, because there are only 60% Malaysians who are Muslims. The other 40% don't care since they are not affected by this law. Even among Muslims, they may only 'accept' because it has already become law but to say 'support' the caning of women, some one better do a real survey. I can confidently say that only a small group supports this law. Furthermore, Malaysians have no way to vote out Syariah law makers as opposed to voting our parliamentarians. Syariah law makers are in a class and fraternity of their own. What Malaysia needs when it comes to so-called Islamic law is a total shake-up or shake-down of the system and its agencies. Malaysia actually has a number of progressive Islamic scholars but they are out-maneuvered by the dogmatic fundamentalists. So, to say most Malaysians 'support' the caning of women is misleading.


Most Malaysians accept the caning of women under the country’s Shariah courts, Islamic Development Department (Jakim) director general Datuk Wan Mohamad Sheikh Abdul Aziz said on Wednesday.

“Jakim held a seminar to discuss caning long before it became an issue among Malaysians. The outcome was encouraging because the participants understood the whys and hows of it,” he said as quoted by newspaper Web site thestar.com.

“We are aware that some parties are still unable to accept the punishment but given time and more explanation, I believe they will come around.”

He added that Jakim was “willing to explain the issue all over again, to whoever needs an explanation.”

Malaysia’s Women’s Minister, Shahrizat Abdul Jalil, said on Tuesday that she hoped to organize a conference with representatives of other Muslim-majority countries to discuss the punishment.

She told the Malaysia Insider website she respected the caning sentence recently doled out to three women, but she believed physical punishment was not the only option.

“Wrong is wrong, but there are many ways to handle the issue, including rehabilitation and counselling,” Shahrizat said.

The women were caned for having sex outside marriage. They have since publicly defended the punishment, saying it gave them a chance to repent.

Authorities used a light rattan stick to hit the women on their backs while they were fully clothed. The caning of men in Malaysia, by contrast, is done on bare skin and can cause bleeding and scarring.

JG