North Sumatra Home to Country’s Most Corrupt Officials: Watchdog
Nivell Rayda | February 23, 2011
Medan, the capital of North Sumatra. The province is the most corrupt in Indonesia, according to figures compiled by Indonesia Corruption Watch. (Antara Photo/File) Related articles
Ex-Minister Fadel Named Suspect in Graft Case, Implicated in Another 3:51pm May 23, 2012
Suharto's Grandson to Appear for Graft Questioning 5:41pm May 18, 2012
House Speaker Weighs Suit Against Indonesian News Website 3:50pm May 14, 2012
Critics Doubt Democratic Party’s Intent To Recruit Candidates From the Outside 9:35pm May 11, 2012
Former Lampung District Head Gets 12 Years for Graft 5:18pm May 9, 2012
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
424626@Ronen - thank you kindly for your comment! An interesting and informative read! Cheers
Yes, Roland. Corruption culture may be attributed partly to the "noveau riche" culture, but I would see them as 2 separated phenomena, as corruption is widespread here among all income classes of society, quite equally...
The "noveau riche" culture, which is not limited to the 3rd world, is a result of the adaptation of superficial American + colonialist values. European culture is undergoing 100 years or so of decadence. American vulgar values are 'in', while the Old European delicate values are 'out'.
Unlike American wealthy class who live in a society which did not abandon totally the old European values, the 3rd world wealthy class has no shame at all, as they do not have any delicate cultural background.
I am living in Medan. You can find here hundreds of extravagant houses and mansions, but not even one opera house, theater, famous intellectual, famous film director, international-grade scientific research lab, innovation house, hi-tech company... It's an absolute intellectual desert.
Respected people here are those who have money, even if everyone knows they are corrupted. Most people who fight here against corruption are not better than the corrupted people themselves. They just feel jealousy. I bet that most of them will behave the same when they have the power.
People, poor and rich alike, are not interested here in high delicate culture. All they need is food and low-grade entertainment.
Many people here prefer to work 16 hours a day in exhausting physical work as an employee with permanent job, for almost no money, - than to open their own small business, and have a change to earn much more with less physical work. Why? - They prefer peace of mind: permanent job with little brain-work, is the dream-job of most Indonesians, poor or rich.
Most Indonesian I met, - do not want their brain to work hard. This is what I call a Tropics Zone Mentality. For hundreds of thousands of years the Jungle-dwellers of the Tropics never have to think for the sake of survival… This legacy is dominating their culture till nowadays. It’s the mother of many society-illnesses, like corruption, lack of innovation, lack of long-term-planning and poor efficiency and capabilities, while it’s also contribute a lot to the lack of sharp and cold criticism, which caused the Tropics dwellers to be also very friendly…
By the way, this is another insight I got here. Friendly societies everywhere are usually more corrupted than cold individualist society. This two pairs of values are almost never mixed.
@BrahmaPutra, you got a point there. Yes, if just having a pocket knife in your pocket could cost you long years in jail, one wonders what could befall the pickpocket...
@Ronen - I am sure that your observations are right, also because I can see a similar mindset in Indonesia. Maybe it is because in Europe's society the social middle class is dominant to which of course also government officials and employees belong and wealth is quite evenly spread, in addition to a decent social services (healthcare, education, employment...), which on the other hand means that taxes are at times quite high to finance the social scheme. However here is unfortunately still the middle class a very small crust, maybe accounting for 10% of all Indonesians and the majority is poor, whatever government supplied statistics are trying telling otherwise. I know here tons of folks hardly surviving on a daily base, in addition to a poor healthcare, a very selective education system and unfortunately also a very religiously dominated environment.
I am actually not surprised that corruption is so rampant, because everybody wants everything NOW, no matter the consequences and the means to obtain it. Just look on to the new middle class in Indonesia - it seems, for me at least, that exactly this middle calss wants to show everybody "We made it", and this at times in a very exaggerated manner. One car is not enough, it must be 3 or 4 (of course, if possible the newest and biggest models), on mobile is not enough, it must be 3 or 4 and so on and on! you know how many times my wife and me are getting approached by "well meaning" and comparably well off Indonesians asking, why we are only driving one car, and that one is 7 years old. why we are not using the most advanced mobiles available, why my wife is not having lots of jewellery, why we are not having nannies, more maids, a driver and so on (I think you get the point). It is this completely brainwashed generation of "noveau riche", misguided by advertisements, images and symbols of the wealth. Their only god is money, because this generation believes that happiness is found in having more and more on materialistic goods surrounding them and lost their view that happiness lies in living in peace within, having a good family, a good wife, good children, a humble life! Maybe the whole thing is a bit of a cultural shock for many people here, never having anything before and now having "everything at last", no matter the price and the ways to obtain it!
I actually do hope very much that my grandchildren will see a better world than we have to observe daily!
Hi Roland, Of-course, nobody can argue with you, how this country was looked if there was no corruption here. However, I think you extremely underestimate the corruption dimensions in Indonesia. It's not just the politicians, and bureaucracies. The INDONESIAN SOCIETY itself is problematic. The Indonesian electorate is voting once after another to parties and individuals who collaborated shamelessly with corrupted politicians, officials and human rights offenders. I do not know a single Indonesian who never exploit his family/friends-ties to get a job/benefit he/she is not entitled to. Indonesian society like all the indigenous tropical societies in the world, have mental difficulties to adapt themselves to the rules and hectic life of global economy demands. Hence, most of them, are looking for comfortable and easy shortcuts to gain money. Tropical indigenous societies who live in Paradises on Earth, were never felt the need to adapt the culture of long-term planning, with the associated values of accuracy, efficiency, loyalty, honesty, etc.
The harsh experience of recent dozens of years of globalization, has a potential to change something in the indigenous cultures of the tropics. However, cultural changes take generations to evolve. One can not expect to have them installed instantly. Roland, - your grandchildren will see, maybe, the beginning of a change. Do not expect North-European mentality in the Tropics for the next 200 years, at least...
The country’s leading antigraft watchdog has released new figures on corruption in the regions for 2010, and the news is not good for North Sumatra and East Kalimantan.
Agus Sunaryanto, head of the investigation unit at Indonesia Corruption Watch, said on Wednesday that based on the number of graft cases involving government officials, North Sumatra was the most corrupt province in the country.
The organization recorded 64 corruption scandals involving North Sumatra government officials at the provincial and district levels last year.
“North Sumatra’s provincial administration has to pay serious attention to corruption practices [involving government officials] plaguing the province,” Agus said. “The government must establish greater transparency and impose strict monitoring in regard to the use of its coffers.”
He added that losses incurred from graft in the province amounted to Rp 288 billion ($32.5 million) over the year.
One of the more prominent examples of corruption in the province was the case of North Sumatra Governor Syamsul Arifin, who was arrested in October in connection with alleged graft committed while he was head of Lankat district.
And in 2008, the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) arrested Abdillah, the mayor of the provincial capital, Medan, and his deputy, Ramli Lubis, for two cases of graft.
North Sumatra administration spokesman Edi Sofyan denied the government had failed to carry out reform in the province.
“Just the opposite, actually,” Edi said. “The high number of cases [in North Sumatra] shows that we are serious about tackling corruption.”
Data recorded by the ICW showed there were 448 corruption scandals involving local officials nationwide last year, with 176 cases recorded during the first six months.
“In the first half of 2010, state losses caused by corruption nationwide amounted to Rp 2.1 trillion,” Agus said.
“In the second half of the year, losses amounted to Rp 1.5 trillion. The trend is worrying. These figures suggest that law enforcers tend to touch on only petty corruption cases.”
According to ICW records, East Kalimantan suffered the greatest losses of the nation’s provinces to corruption in the second half of 2010 at Rp 601 billion. This figure came from just two cases that were handled by local law-enforcement agencies during the period.
East Kalimantan was followed by Jakarta, which recorded Rp 200 billion in state losses from six separate corruption scandals.
Gamawan Fauzi, the minister of home affairs, has painted a bleak picture of the country’s regional heads, saying too many have been implicated in graft scandals.
“Among the 155 regional heads who have been named graft suspects, at least 17 of them are [current and former] governors,” Gamawan said during a meeting with Committee I of the Regional Representatives Council (DPD).
In November, Transparency International Indonesia named Cirebon in West Java and Pekanbaru in Riau as the most corrupt cities in Indonesia. The results were based on the organization’s most comprehensive survey yet, which polled 9,237 members of the business community in 50 cities.
The two cities tied in last year’s Corruption Perception Index with a score of just 3.61, with 10 being the cleanest.
“Reports from local and national media on both cities are filled with cases of corruption,” researcher Frenky Simanjuntak said. “This has affected the perception of businesses operating there.”
Medan scored 4.65 in the Transparency International survey, ranking 22 out of 50 cities.
- Tomy Winata to Build Jakarta's Tallest Building
- Lady Gaga Angers Thai Fans With Fake Rolex Comment
- Lady Gaga Refuses to Tone Down Her Shows: Manager
- Indonesia Set to Cap Bank Owners’ Stakes: Sources
- President's Son Nearly Attacked by Angry Mob
- Singapore Cabby Jailed for Molesting Indonesian Maid
- If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Watch, Djoko Says of Gaga
- Indonesia's Chief Justice Demands SBY Explain Corby Clemency
- Djoko Says ‘I Don’t Care’ About FPI Demonstration
- National Exams' ‘Fantastic’ Passing Rate Suspicious: ICW
-
10:41pm | Djoko Says ‘I Don’t Care’ Abou...
Meanwhile, in complete contrast from what the S.O.B is at liberty to say under the freedom of his beloved Indonesian constitution.... -
10:34pm | Tomy Winata to Build Jakarta's...
As sound as interesting it is, and how people would picture this monumental skyscraper will glorify the skyline of Jakarta. I see no objectives. -
10:34pm | Indonesian Police Consider Ton...
A small but extremely loud group of mentally retarded inbreds. And you know what we do with retarded inbreds: we ignore them. -
10:30pm | If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Wa...
The picture showed People with deepest and darkest hatred for other human beings and showing their true color by calling them KAFIR? You can only s -
10:04pm | Djoko Says ‘I Don’t Care’ Abou...
more on Sobri (lets call him S.O.B. from now on) Jakarta Post 15/4/08 – A videotape screened on Monday showed Islamic Defenders Front (FPI) -
9:42pm | Lady Gaga Concert Promoter Has...
the whole country went gaga over lady gaga -
9:41pm | Two IPB Security Guards Shot D...
Ah Bogor - such a center of peace and piety. -
9:39pm | Lady Gaga Concert Promoter Has...
"a permit from the venue, a recommendation from the Jakarta police, a recommendation from the Tourism and Creative Economy Ministry, a permit for
