Last updated at 12:36 AM. Monday 15 March 2010

Go to comments November 03, 2009

Liz Sinclair

Both Indonesian and foreign extras were needed to play shoppers and fellow tourists alongside Julia Roberts and Javier Bardem during filming in Bali for the movie “Eat, Pray, Love.” (Photo courtesy of Neal Hornaffer)

Both Indonesian and foreign extras were needed to play shoppers and fellow tourists alongside Julia Roberts and Javier Bardem during filming in Bali for the movie “Eat, Pray, Love.” (Photo courtesy of Neal Hornaffer)

On Set With Julia Roberts in Bali

Being an extra in a movie sounds glamorous, but in reality consists of long hours and a lot of waiting and standing around.

Columbia Pictures is currently filming the best-selling book “Eat, Pray, Love” at locations around Bali. The movie stars Julia Roberts as the writer, Elizabeth Gilbert, and Javier Bardem as her love interest, Felipe.

I went to a casting call in Ubud a month ago, had my photo taken and a few weeks later received a phone call. The production was shooting in the Ubud Market and needed foreigners to play tourists. “Bring three changes of clothes and a market bag, You can’t take cameras or phones,” said the woman on the phone. “Oh, and bring sunglasses, too.” She told me to arrive at Pura Dalem, in Peliatan, by 6 a.m.

On the day, I arrived by taxi with some friends, Andy and Sylvie Hamilton and their daughters, who were also extras. The parking lot next to the Pura Dalem was crammed with huge trailers. Dozens of people, American and Javanese, with earpieces and walkie-talkies clipped to their belts, scurried around like ants. One of the trailers contained the film’s wardrobe. I saw floral dresses for Wayan (the herbal healer) and khaki pants and a panama hat for Felipe.

A woman at the registration desk across the road gave us green plastic passes, with the words “Eat Pray Love Extras” printed on them. “Wear these at all times,” she said.

A food tent was set up next to the desk, with chairs full of Balinese extras, and warmers and plates with Indonesian food on tables. The woman saw me wave at an Indonesian friend. “Breakfast for foreigners is across the street, with the cast and crew,” she said.

Inside Pura Dalem, Bali Good Food Catering was serving Western food. Cast and crew were already in line, getting breakfast. The Hamiltons and I filled our plates with fruit, eggs, French toast, bacon and sausages.

As we ate, Haggarty (“We go by last names on the set”) gave us a brief preview of the day. Extras had to sign consent forms and weren’t allowed to talk to actors or take photos.

Haggarty asked people wearing visible logos to change. He explained the studio wasn’t allowed to show corporate logos unless they’d signed a contract to display the brand. He was also checking clothing colors, to make sure no one clashed with the principal actors.

We were then bused to a small guesthouse (the “holding area”) across the street from Ubud Market. We waited, sitting in small groups, talking or reading. A tent was set up with tea, coffee and food. A man distributed nasi bunkus (take-away rice) to the Balinese extras. At 10 a.m., a man named Emil came and counted us off into groups. He took one group across to the set, then a second. The Hamiltons and I were left to wait.

After an hour, Andy and I decided to watch the filming. We crossed the road and snuck onto the set. We wound up next to a video feed monitor inside a shuttered shop. We peered out through sarongs, T-shirts and baskets hanging on the walls. I could see Javier Bardem and Julia Roberts walking through the market, practicing their lines.

Crew members positioned extras around the set, singly and in pairs, according to height and build. I noticed that the crew often paired Japanese and Chinese or Korean and Chinese extras together. A man walked around, taking digital photos. When I asked, he told me he was in charge of ensuring background “continuity.” Dozens of crew members were moving cameras and huge baskets of fruit around in a seemingly random ballet, speaking constantly into their earpieces.

A Balinese shop owner told me she had received no fees for her lost business. “There was some money paid,” she said, “but it went to the market temple.”

At midday, the foreign extras were bused back to Pura Dalem for lunch. The Balinese extras remained in the holding area. Lunch was a healthy spread of fresh salads, grilled vegetables, fish and foccacia sandwiches, with freshly-baked biscotti for desert. “Gee, are we in California or Ubud?” Andy asked.

After lunch, we returned by bus to the set. The bus got stuck in a traffic jam on Ubud’s main road. Haggarty asked the driver to open the door and let him out. The driver refused and Haggarty asked again, raising his voice. “We’re at a cultural impasse,” said an Indonesian-speaking extra who was talking to the driver. “If he lets you out, he’s afraid he’ll be in trouble with the police.” Finally, the bus reached the set and we all disembarked, and returned to wait in the holding area.

At 1 p.m., my group was finally called. As I got to the set, I heard my name called. I looked around and saw a local journalist I knew. “Are you an extra?” I asked. “No,” he said, “I’ve crashed the set to get pictures of Julia Roberts. Worth a lot of money.” But security overheard him. “Are you an extra? Where’s your badge?” someone asked him. He turned and tried to walk quickly back into the market, but two heavy-set men followed and chased him out.

Haggarty placed me in front of a woodcarving stall, and told me to pretend to shop. Which I did, over and over, as the director called for multiple rehearsals.

Haggarty reappeared, “You,” he said to me. He looked at Mary, the extra next to me, “And you. Come with me.” He led us by the shoulders to the far side of the set. I looked up and saw Julia Roberts and Javier Bardem standing, chatting, nearby in the shadows. “Stand on the ‘mark,’ ” Haggarty said. He pointed to a piece of duct tape on the ground. Cameras are focused on the mark, so if an extra isn’t in the right place, they won’t be in focus. “Walk over to me. Pretend you’re looking at these shirts,” he said. “But don’t talk, just pantomime. They’re recording dialogue in this scene.” Haggarty went to stand over in the shadows, under a boom that held a huge camera.

I heard “Action!” Mary and I started walking. “No, No!” I heard Haggarty yelling. I looked up to see him waving his arms at us, “Wait until they say, ‘Background,’ ” he said. (No one had actually told us this.) Mary and I both froze. Then I heard someone yell, “Background!” We started walking again, but we were off the mark. I looked ahead and realized that I was about to collide with Javier Bardem. I heard Mary gasp. “I almost tripped Julia Roberts,” she whispered.

Somehow, we managed to navigate around the two stars, who walked on, speaking their lines, ignoring us. The director yelled, “Cut!”

The stars walked back to their marks. Mary disappeared. I couldn’t see Haggarty. I had no idea what to do, so returned to the woodcarving stall, where I found Mary. She told me the director had seen her in a previous scene, in a different part of the market, and for reasons of continuity, she couldn’t appear in another scene.

For the next few hours, the extras walked back and forth, pretending to be tourists shopping. I wanted to buy some durian, which filled several nearby baskets, but had to keep looking at carvings. My feet started to hurt. The occasional real tourist wandered onto the set, unaware of the movie, only to be removed by security. Finally, filming ended. The crew started to dismantle the set. Emil called out, ”All extras return to the holding area.” Julia Roberts and Javier Bardem were whisked into cars by bodyguards wielding open umbrellas to protect them from photographers, and driven away. I went to buy some durian, and found that the crew had given all the fruit, which were pre-purchased props, to the Balinese shop owners.

I went back to the holding area. A few extras who hadn’t been used yet were driven off to a coffee shop for the next scene. An accountant paid the rest of us. It was five o’clock: we’d been waiting, eating and walking for 11 hours. The foreigners received $100, foreign kids $50 and the Balinese $20. In the end, the Hamiltons hadn’t been in a single scene. “At least we got paid,” Sylvie said. “But it would have been fun to have been in the movie.”



Post a comment

Login or register to post comments!

Comments

Jeanne Hachette

3:51 PM November 5, 2009

@gezellig:

So let's screw the foreign tourists to convince them not to come back. Visit Indonesia ...but only once.

Great marketing tactics!!

gezellig

3:35 PM November 5, 2009

@Dr Biz:

foreigner with kitas pays local price=Rp.9000

blowie

12:14 PM November 5, 2009

< If in fact the film company deliberately took advantage of Indonesian residents because of their lower expectations against the expectations of foreign residents, I believe it is exploitation. >

I doubt if any of those foreign residents were doing it for the money. If they had I'm sure none of them would have agreed to work for so little. $100 is just a nice round figure and acceptable as an honorarium amount.

I thought perhaps that the non-Indonesian extras were paid more because compatible language and cultural familiarity with the film crew would make direction easier but, the fact that the children were paid more than the local extras, is obviously discriminatory and completely destroys my theory.

blowie

12:06 PM November 5, 2009

< If in fact the film company deliberately took advantage of Indonesian residents because of their lower expectations against the expectations of foreign residents, I believe it is exploitation. >

I doubt if any of those foreign residents were doing it for the money. If they had I'm sure none of them would have agreed to work for so little. $100 is just a nice round figure and acceptable as an honorarium amount.

I thought perhaps that the non-Indonesian extras were paid more because compatible language and cultural familiarity with the film crew would make direction easier but, the fact that the children were paid more than the local extras, is obviously discriminatory and completely destroys my theory.

billjayman

11:29 AM November 5, 2009

Best post ever... Dr. Biz

Short and to the point.

Dr.Biz

8:16 AM November 5, 2009

Entrance fee to Borobudur

Locals: 9000 rupiah

Foreigners: 11 usd (105 000 rupiah)

any comments?

Valkyrie

6:04 AM November 5, 2009

I admire people who adhere and posess a good attitude towards morals and ethical principles. You responded much better than I anticipated, and it truly humbled me. Thank you!

Just like to share something from Lewis Carroll with you:

"If you don 't know where you are going....any road will take you there."

peterR

12:34 AM November 5, 2009

Valkyrie

I have no problem in answering the question.

I firmly believe that every person, regardless of their status, should be paid according to their worth and what they contribute, nationality or colour, nor status, should not be part of that factor. Additionally, and far more importantly, I believe that every person deserves the support that enables them to achieve their potential and progress to live a decent, healthy life.

Regarding me specifically, I believe that I should also be paid according to my ability, no more or less than any other person who has similar abilities, regardless of who they are, their status, colour, and in what country we are residing in. However, I am a photographer, an occupation where colour, nationality and social status is irrelevant. Whether or not my images continue to sell relates directly to my personal creativity. Being white, holds no advantage for me what-so-ever.

In this specific case, I believe that the Indonesian and foreign crowd extras should have been paid pretty much the same. If the figures quoted are accurate, the difference is obscene. Incidentally, I have a vested interest in equality, I am man married 32 years to an Indonesian, with two daughters who are half Indonesian, and an extended Indonesian family that is just too large for me to count.

There is not one cell in my body that recognises any difference between human beings in terms of race or status. I have no barriers in my mind and no prejudice racially: None!... Not to say that there aren’t quite a few individuals that piss me off enormously.

I understand from this article that the foreign extras were each paid directly. When I said it would be interesting to know what other payments have been made for the use of Ubuds facilities and to whom, in part I was wondering how the Indonesian extras were paid, directly or through an agent of some description? If in fact the film company deliberately took advantage of Indonesian residents because of their lower expectations against the expectations of foreign residents, I believe it is exploitation.

I hope that this is honest and straightforward enough.

Valkyrie

10:56 AM November 4, 2009

peterR:

The disparity is too great. This time around you can't mask the facts before you.

Is it so difficult for you to mention the color of a spade? C'mon, cut that crap about promotions! Yes we need the publicity but when pigmentation is being valued than bigotry steps in.

Allow me to ask you a straight forward question. What's your worth compared to an Indonesian? I meant an Indonesian with similar academic qualities or perhaps a wee bit better than you? This is personal I realize, and naturally you can refuse to answer it.....your prerogative.

The film being tripe? Well, your meat may be poison to another you know.

peterR

9:40 AM November 4, 2009

indotoonster

You are of course right about the vast difference in the payments. It would be interesting though to know what other payments have been made for the use of Ubuds facilities and to whom.

Bit presumptuous to label the film tripe. The book was very popular, which I assume you read and did-not like.

Bottom line, its good for the promotion of Bali and hopefully that feeds through to the locals.

Anto.is

9:21 AM November 4, 2009

Nice article...., but how come balinese get paid less than foreigner? I just don't think it is fair...

indotoonster

7:39 AM November 4, 2009

Whoo, how glamorous! Lovely article, gives us fantastic insight into how these Hollywood productions manage to spend hundreds of millions of dollars on producing such tripe.

Nice to see that foreign extras get paid at least 500% what the Balinese get. Those freshly-baked focaccia sandwiches don't pay for themselves...