Residents Giving Up on Public Transport
Dofa Fasila & Zaky Pawas | January 28, 2011
About 750,000 vehicles are expected to be added this year to Jakarta's already-choked streets. (Antara Photo) Related articles
Jakarta Bus Operator Could Lose Routes if Found Liable for Two Accidents 11:45pm Feb 21, 2012
Path Paved for Jakarta’s Transport Superbody 2:17pm Feb 22, 2012
Will Jakarta Traffic Problems Be the End of Governor Fauzi? 11:30am Feb 16, 2012
Joining the Dots: Connectivity, Safety and Energy Are Jakarta’s Transport Challenges 11:08am Feb 16, 2012
Toll Gate to Be Closed in Traffic-Heavy Semanggi 11:59am Feb 11, 2012
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
419490Heh heh. In fact you know me Les. Back to the subject in hand though...I remember the push for the clean, green gas powered Bajaj a couple of years back. Another total failure and the reason given? They were expensive for the drivers of the normal orange bajajs to buy or rent. Unbelievable! Bajaj drivers barely have a pot to piss in and yet city transportation policy failure is their fault? Politicians in this country are just the absolute penultimate.
@ Sir Anthony...You're sounding like me now. Maybe I should hand my "busway/transportation hat" over to you lol. You are 110% correct in all you say. Someday - sometime - someone MUST bight the bullet and eradicate the rustbuckets from the public transport fleet. As I have also said on many occasions, whilst there is no problem with funding of plant and equipment (e.g. shelters/buses), managements generally in Indonesia have no idea that preventative and ongoing maintenance is both important and cost-effective.
Here are some suggestion and tips to improve traffic related problems, asf.:
1).Build more flyover and underpass.
2).Increase parking fee, and used the fee to improve & subsidize public transportation.
3).Stop fuel subsidy for private vehicles in big cities, and use the subsidy to improve public road, transportation & build access pathway to bikers & pedestrians.
4).Widen surrounding intersection roads.
5).Provide more elevated parking space, to avoid overflow of parking vehicle congesting the road.
6).Provide professional tow trucks services to tow violated vehicle blocking the road.
7).Increase all related vehicle & fuel taxes in big cities to subsidize for public transportation improvement.
8). And many more.
I had lived in overseas for many years, the above suggestions are commonly practiced in developed countries.
“By the end of 2010, there were eight million motorcycles alone in Jakarta.”
God almighty.
“They’re scared of scrapping the older buses because of opposition from the owners,” Royke said.
And why is there opposition? Do you think they enjoy having their crates break down every two days? No, it's because these dollar a day drivers and conductors would be expected to stump up for a new shiny bus and charged higher rental fees than before. It's central governments responsibility to maintain and upgrade bus fleets and public transportation systems and to pay drivers salaries to boot. Any solution that would involve the investment of cold, hard money that could otherwise be stolen by those in charge is out of the question though. Thus we get the busway, the cheapest option and one not suited to a city this crowded...and they can't even maintain and run that properly. The state of the Metro Minis and Kopajas plying the streets is simply dreadful and in terms of emissions, they are just filthy and make the city more closely resemble Calcutta than KL.
I have read so many similar articles, again and again and again, in various newspaper magazines etc, and I think we all know enough what causes the congestion in Jakarta. Too bad, all is just talk and talk, well until Jakartans themselves start putting the right people who would fight 100% for their rights for better quality of public services and (finally) bring all these cheap talks into reality.
Commuters in Greater Jakarta are abandoning public transportation in droves in favor of private vehicles, an official said on Thursday, while the city’s administration said it would take steps to ease traffic on congested Jalan Casablanca.
Jakarta Traffic Police Chief Sr. Comr. Royke Lumowa said the shift threatened to exacerbate traffic congestion and render the city’s widely panned bus and train services obsolete.
“Commuters are increasingly choosing to use private vehicles rather than take public transport. If this keeps up, public transportation will soon cease to exist.”
He cited a study done for the Jabodetabek Urban Transportation Policy Integration Project that showed the number of public transit users dropping by a quarter from 2002 through 2010.
In 2002, 38.3 percent of commuters used public transport, but by 2010, it had dropped to 19.3 percent.
At the start of the study period, 21.2 percent of commuters used a motorcycle, while 11.6 percent used a car. By the end of that period, those percentages had jumped to 48.7 for motorcyclists and 13.5 for drivers.
These statistics, Royke said, could be seen by the sheer volume of vehicles clogging the city’s streets today.
“Every year an extra 600,000 to 900,000 new vehicles are registered in the city, 80 percent of them motorcycles,” he said.
“By the end of 2010, there were eight million motorcycles alone in Jakarta.”
The number of those traveling by foot or bicycle dropped from 23.7 percent in 2002 to 22.6 percent in 2010, despite the advent of community initiatives such as the Bike to Work movement and monthly car-free days on certain thoroughfares.
Royke blamed the exodus from public transport, which happened despite the introduction of the busway, on the declining standard of buses and trains.
“The high incidence of crime and discomfort inherent in public transportation, coupled with the worsening congestion, is what’s making people turn to private transportation,” he said.
To resolve this situation he called on the Jakarta Transportation Office to take measures to improve the quality of their services, including scrapping aging buses.
He said, however, that the office had not considered any of the police’s recommendations on the matter.
“They’re scared of scrapping the older buses because of opposition from the owners,” Royke said.
He also called for other modes of public transport to be introduced, such as a monorail, and for the three-in-one policy, under which only high-occupancy vehicles can enter certain streets during rush hours, be scrapped because it was ineffective.
“People who are fed up of taking public transport would rather drive and hire a three-in-one ‘jockeys’ to play the system,” he said.
Among the problems afflicting Jakarta’s public transport system is the generally poor condition of shelters along the busway lines that crisscross the city.
In particularly bad shape are the shelters along Corridor III, which runs from Harmoni in Central Jakarta to Kalideres in West Jakarta, several of which are missing their roofs. Some of them have been taken over by street-side vendors, tire repairmen and homeless people.
On Thursday, the West Jakarta administration said it would fix these shelters, many of which have been without a roof for the past three years.
Saleh Tahir, the administration’s head of transportation, said he was aware of the damage to the shelters but denied his office had failed to act on the problem quickly enough.
“We routinely maintain these shelters,” he said.
“The roofs were torn off by strong winds and not because the screws holding them were loose.”
He also said his office was studying the possible relocation of a series of five shelters along Corridor III, none of which is located near a side street.
“Once the study is done, we hope to move those shelters to more strategic locations.”
“We want them at points where they’ll be able to serve the needs of the most people possible. We won’t leave them to languish in their current locations,” Saleh said.
In a separate development, the Jakarta administration announced measures to ease traffic jams along Casablanca in Kuningan, South Jakarta, where construction is underway on an elevated road linking Kampung Melayu in East Jakarta to Tanah Abang in Central Jakarta.
The administration previously suggested alternative routes that motorists could use instead of Casablanca, including Jalan Gatot Subroto, Jalan Karet Pedurenan, Jalan Bendungan Hilir, Jalan Dukuh Atas, Jalan Rasuna Said and Jalan Saharjo.
On Thursday, it announced it would also open Jalan Denpasar in the Mega Kuningan business district to the public.
Access to the district, which hosts the JW Marriott and Ritz-Carlton hotels that were targets of terrorism, is normally restricted for security reasons.
Governor Fauzi Bowo denied that the congestion along Casablanca was caused by the construction, instead blaming motorists for wanting to take the road.
“Of course the construction contributes a bit to the traffic, but should that stop us from building it? Then we’ll have no recourse when the number of vehicles increases and there’s gridlock.”
- We Love Jakarta: This Traffic is Making Me Gila
- John Kei Just a Puppet in Sanex Steel Hit: Jakarta Police
- Afriani’s Drug Seller Arrested, Police Claim
- Knife-Wielding Jakarta Child to Meet Psychiatrist
- Food Stall Owners Slam Jakarta Over New Restaurant Tax
- Thrill Builds in Jakarta for Architecture in Helsinki
- Pint-Sized Mariachis Learn Music of Mexico in New York
- Jakarta Bus Operator Could Lose Routes if Found Liable for Two Accidents
- Indonesia's Mining Sector Royalties Too Low: Hatta Rajasa
- Update5: Indonesian Police Storm Bali Prison to End Riot
-
11:10pm | Letter to the Editor: Study In...
It has nothing to do with conspiracy. It's not a conspiracy if people explicitly tell you they are running your lives and they are doing it for yo -
10:55pm | Lawyer: Nunun Has Heart Condit...
"....almost went to Ethiopia...second class of course!" -
10:38pm | Lawyer: Nunun Has Heart Condit...
Hey, it worked for Pak Harto. -
10:14pm | Malaysia Bans British Author's...
Is that a case of the one-eyed leading the blind Dr Dez? -
10:02pm | W. Java Police Say 20 Suspects...
That came straight from mafia playbook. We won't cause any harm, just obey us. -
9:54pm | Regaining Control in a Decentr...
Elizabeth, only the naive and pseudo-intellectuals believe that anyone out there is responsible to the voter first. Like you anyone that has travel -
9:51pm | Lawyer: Nunun Has Heart Condit...
the tactic at play here seems to be a massive stalling for time and constant delays due to health issues in the vain hope that the judge will get b -
9:02pm | Letter to the Editor: Study In...
@nonredneck: I love you, in a good way. @Looho: Again, fundamental rights to strike does not give workers and trade unions the licen
