Semanggi Exit Closure To Ease Jakarta Gridlock Leads to Massive Jam
September 04, 2010
Related articles
Traffic Congestion Predicted Over Holiday Weekend 7:09pm Jan 20, 2012
Running From Bali to Jakarta — for Charity 7:51pm Jan 11, 2012
1 Dead as Windstorm Wreaks Havoc Across a Soggy Jakarta 9:37am Jan 6, 2012
Jakarta's Security Policy Off The Mark 9:18am Jan 4, 2012
A New Year for Indonesia: Wishes for 2012 in Jakarta 5:13pm Dec 30, 2011
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
394522If they could only design a road system that worked there would not be so many cars needing to make U turns at nearly every intersection or break in the center strip.
I have seen many changes like this made over the last 10 years or so and in nearly every case it has only made the problems worse.
One way through Blok A on Jl Fatmawati/Panglima Polim is a great example. Every evening there is a major macet for hours on the detour route while the main road is virtually empty.
Christ, that's why. I thought a riot or a demonstration or something happened along the way. It just has to be the government that disappointed me rather than the rioters.
Basically what happens is that traffic is just moved from one area to the next.
The u-turn closure is a mysterious one - now instead of standing in a traffic jam for 30 minutes, just to reach the other side of the street, it will be 1 hour - even more gasoline useless burned and time wasted. Of course it resulted in a 'reduced vehicle build-up" at the specific, observed spots, because it moved a few kilometers ahead to another spot! One suggestion true - adding more manned toll booths would help to minimize kilometers of traffic jam when entering or leaving jalan tol and an electronic payment system (GTO) as already introduced but not all too heavy used would speed up the exchange at the booths.
"...and blocking some U-turn slots that create bottlenecks."
Yeah right, that always works.
- Previous
- 1
- Next
Jakarta. The closure of Plaza Semanggi’s vehicle entrance along Jalan Gatot Subroto was meant to ease traffic congestion, but it ironically resulted in a massive traffic jam.
Hundreds of vehicles coming from Slipi in West Jakarta at around 10 a.m. on Friday moved at a slow crawl toward Semanggi.
Jakarta Police Traffic chief Sr. Comr. Condro Kirono said vehicles trying to enter Semanggi from the main road got stuck, while others were forced to take alternative routes.
He said many motorists may not have been aware that the Semanggi entrance was blocked.
“Those who did not know and wanted to enter [Plaza Semanggi from Jalan Gatot Subroto] were stuck,” Condro told the Jakarta Globe on Friday.
“Vehicles from Slipi heading toward Cawang [in East Jakarta] had to [drive past]. The old way is no longer acceptable,” he said.
However, Condro said traffic jams like this would not happen again once the public got used to the new traffic scheme.
“We are still trying to perfect the system in the area. Please do not worry about this. This traffic is temporary, I assure you,” he said. “I am confident that in the near future traffic in the Semanggi cloverleaf and [overpass] will diminish.”
In previous trial runs, the Semanggi 1 toll entrance on Jalan Gatot Subroto was closed from 3 p.m. to 6 p.m. — the peak of the rush hour. Udar Pristono, head of the Jakarta Transportation Office, said the scheme resulted in “reduced vehicle build-up.”
The transportation office and Jakarta Police’s traffic directorate suggested the permanent closure of three gates along Jalan Gatot Subroto — the Semanggi 1 entrance heading east, the Semanggi 2 exit from the Bekasi area and the Tebet 2 entrance — because these fed congestion in the roads around Semanggi.
Jakarta Deputy Governor Prijanto said the city administration expected state-owned toll operator Jasa Marga to agree to the scheme, because it would help reduce traffic around toll exits and entrances.
Officials also asked the company to consider adding toll booths and expanding the use of electronic payment schemes.
Jasa Marga president director Frans Sunito said the company would comply if the Public Works Ministry ordered it to do so.
He said shutting down toll gates would not affect the company’s income.
“People who use the toll road will keep using it, even though their usual entrance may be closed,” Frans said.
The plan is one of a few that the Jakarta administration is considering to ease the capital’s horrendous traffic problems.
Other proposals include limiting the use of motorcycles in congested areas and blocking some U-turn slots that create bottlenecks.
The closure of the Semanggi vehicle entrance on Friday came a day after city officials met to discuss ways to solve the traffic crisis, which is costing the capital an estimated Rp 12.8 trillion ($1.42 billion) a year.
The meeting was chaired by Vice President Boediono and was attended by ministers, governors, senior officials and Jakarta’s traffic police.
They came up with 17 ways to improve traffic flow in Jakarta, such as cracking down on illegal buses, clearing TransJakarta bus lanes, reviewing parking bylaws, providing access to cheaper fuel for select public transportation, offering incentives to phase out minivans in favor of large buses and pushing through with the Mass Rapid Transit project. Zaky Pawas
- Will Elevated Roads Ease Jakarta’s Traffic Jams?
- Bakries Want Rothschild to Leave the Board of Bumi Plc
- Activists Question Indonesia President’s Silence Over Religious Violence
- A Year After the Murders in Cikeusik, Why Is the Govt Going Soft on Hard-Liners?
- Indonesia's Aviation Industry Urges Govt to Halt Spread of Drugs
- Democratic Party Slide, Golkar Now on Top
- ‘Rude’, ‘Anonymous’ Tweeters Beware: Tifatul to Target Twitter
- Second Chance Fashion at Pasar Senen
- Papua to Require Male Circumcision in AIDS Fight
- Angelina Leaves but Anas Stays, for Now
-
2:00pm | ‘Rude’, ‘Anonymous’ Tweeters B...
It is not so useful to mock Mr Tify statements. It is clear now that he need something useful to do in his spare time, can't anyone suggest someth -
1:52pm | Young Girl Dies, Hopes for Fut...
Sad, very sad. As you say, perhaps something good can continue out of this unfortunate end. I say, continue, because the good has already b -
1:40pm | Papua to Require Male Circumci...
In terms of logic, its difficult to imagine that this idea could have resulted from anything other than a bad idea of the year competition. -
1:23pm | Indonesia's Ruling Democratic ...
It's ironic that the Party that was given a mandate to govern by promising to clean up corruption is now ripping itself apart and being daily expo -
12:41pm | ‘Rude’, ‘Anonymous’ Tweeters B...
Correction to my previous post: that should be 'aspiring totalitarian' governments such as RI. -
12:40pm | ‘Rude’, ‘Anonymous’ Tweeters B...
Twitter sold out and took the easy route by empowering totalitarian governments such as RI to censor the platform. So what comes next? Facebook wil -
12:33pm | Papua to Require Male Circumci...
Great news! Some places already have almost universal circumcision like USA, Phillipines, and South Korea but with the World Health Organisation pu -
12:13pm | Indonesian President’s New Pla...
Val Actually there are many justifications for having one - its just the lies and BS that sickens me.. Another thing why do we need to borro
