Singapore Coroners’ Court Concludes Indonesian Student’s Death Was Suicide
Kinanti Pinta Karana & Ismira Lutfia | July 30, 2009
The family of deceased Indonesian student David Hartanto Wijaya walking out of court in Singapore on Wednesday. (Photo: Wong Maye-E, AP) Related articles
Student’s Singapore Death In Legal Limbo 12:16am Aug 1, 2009
Your View: The KPU, Megawati, and David 9:38am Jul 31, 2009
Doubts Surface Before Verdict on Indonesian Student Death in Singapore 11:40pm Jul 24, 2009
Family of Singapore Suicide Student Calls on Government for Assistance 10:50pm Jun 9, 2009
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
320817Oh tweet.me.not -
In Singapore they play to the rule of law, unbending. Whilst you spend your fortune there, please don't expect to tell the fiddler to play your tune. It might work here....and so it does.
It is within the framework of their legal system to disallow foreign professionals get involved, especially in cases of this nature. Can I assume that you are referring to forensic experts from Indonesia?
Suicide is a criminal act, you know? So keeping David's laptop and cell phones are evidences for their keeping.
Media all over the world profess a bias attitude. You appear to be an intelligent person so let's not elaborate on this.
Of course I feel upset and can only sympathize with David's family. But what can you do when confronted with a situation like this?
Here, I would ask our local media not to stir up feelings. We have more vital issues at hand to handle.
But why won't the Singaporean government not let the deceased parents see the face and body of David after he died. They immediately cremated him.
David's lawyer also said that there were defensive wounds on David's body.
When David's body also wanted proof and forensic experts to check it, the court did not allow it
They also won't return David's laptop and cellphones.
Odd.. That said. I love Singapore and it's food and shopping but Singapore is known for highly repressing their own media and controlling it to their own purposes.
The Indonesian media is of course biased, but more so the Singaporean media.
I didn't follow the case closely, so I have no comment on the outcome. However what's interesting is what the media from the two countries report on. The Singapore media, (e.g. Today Online and Straits Times) points out evidences -- stab wounds at the back of the professor's body, suicide note, etc. -- that logically proof the death as not a murder. The Indonesian media (in general) on the other hand, plays to the angle that the Singapore courts may be unfair.
Why can't people understand that the legal system of a soveriegn state cannot be influenced by an external source?
I can understand the anger and pain that David's family are going through, but the rule of law must be maintained.
The law allows David's family to pursue the issue with an appeal to the Supreme Court of Singapore. Seeking justice in countries like Singapore can be very costly, but at least you can be assured that the rule of law will reign.
I am sorry, but I honestly cannot believe comments that judgement from the Coroner's court was bias. Singapore cannot afford to have a "blackmark" on their legal system.
On the lighter side........Singapore is a "fine" city.
If you commit a crime in Singapore, you're done for. No external authority has ever succeeded to influence a court decision. They will uphold Law to the letter.
- Previous
- 1
- Next
The Singapore Coroners’ Court on Wednesday ruled the death of David Hartanto Wijaya, an Indonesian student who had been studying at Nanyang Technological University, to have been a suicide.
David was found dead at the university campus on March 2, and his family and supporters believe he may have been murdered. Wednesday’s ruling means that the family’s case will not be heard by a criminal court.
Hartono Wijaya, David’s father, told the Jakarta Globe he was “very sad and disappointed” by the court’s decision.
“When the judge was about to read the verdict, we walked out of the court because we knew what the verdict was going to be,” Hartono said. “I’m so deeply sad, my tears have gone dry. I cried for help until my voice was gone.”
David’s mentor, Prof. Chan Kap Luk, had accused the student of attempting to stab him with a kitchen knife shortly before the student allegedly jumped to his death from the fourth floor of the university building.
David’s family has always maintained that the circumstances surrounding his death were suspicious. The family cannot appeal the court’s decision and criticized the Indonesian government for not doing enough to ensure a fair trial.
“Why did the government close their ears and eyes to us?” Hartono said. “My son was an Indonesian citizen, he fought for Indonesia in a world competition, but his beloved country did not help him.
“For four months we have been asking and begging the government to help us. We needed their help to speak to the Singaporean government to ask them to give us a fair trial.”
Vice President-elect Boediono met with the family in Singapore on Tuesday, and while Hartanto said he was supportive, “he is not in the government yet.”
“He only met us one day before the verdict,” Hartono said. “What could we have expected from him?”
He took the opportunity to thank David’s friends and individuals who were sympathetic to the family’s plight.
“Without their generous help, we wouldn’t have been able to hire a lawyer and pay our expenses in Singapore,” Hartono said.
Foreign Minister Hassan Wirajuda said on Wednesday that the government was committed to ensuring that Indonesian citizens received fair trials overseas.
“However, we have to be aware that there are limitations for us not to interfere [with trials] as we would not also want that to happen with our court,” he said.
Hassan said the Indonesian Embassy in Singapore acted mostly as an observer to the case, but said more could have been done to help the family if they had been more cooperative.
“How the embassy helped the family depended mainly on them, including in the legal process,” he said.
For example, the Hassan said that family could have used the Singaporean legal advisor that the embassy keeps on its payroll.
“They preferred to hire an Indonesian lawyer who surely will not have access to the Singaporean court and does not have a license to practice there,” he said.
The minister said the government remained “committed to supporting and protecting Indonesian citizens” but said that any assistance given to the family would extend only as far as Singaporean laws permitted.
- Indonesian Fans Stage Flash Mob for Gaga
- Five Jakarta Governor Candidates Guarantee Religious Freedom
- Dangdut Music Gets Its Groove Back
- Police Chief to Be Summoned Over Lady Gaga and Church Dispute Controversies
- Sukhoi Victim Identification Process Completed
- Jakarta Poaches on Farmland Waters
- Red Shirts Send Warning to Thai Elite
- Rise of Australia’s ‘Feral Billionaires’
- 21 Kalimantan Sex Workers Test Positive for HIV
- Lady Gaga to Go on in Philippines Despite Rallies
-
3:20pm | Breaking: Prosecutors Seek Lif...
hans - but he will be out in 10 yaers max and he will have full access to media and others to twist their mionds Death is what he shuld be -
3:18pm | The Thinker: May 1998 Revisite...
agreed roland and simsim -
3:10pm | The Thinker: May 1998 Revisite...
simsin: I totally agree with you. The Indonesians that committed the atrocities in 1998 are the same breed that are murdering ethnic and religious -
3:07pm | China to Speed Up Approvals fo...
@maharaja aka 22 - I am living here since more than 17 years and are married here. You are absolutely NOT in the position to tell me off, you littl -
3:06pm | Breaking: Prosecutors Seek Lif...
To be fair, death penalty will only add to the already long list of martyrs of radicalism (see Imam Samudra & co.), becoming the idols of Mujahiddi -
3:03pm | The Thinker: May 1998 Revisite...
@maharaja - your attitude of denial and shifting guilt to others is...well, actually I am speechless (in a very negative sense) about your comment! -
2:58pm | Jakarta Drug Bust Nets 4 Suspe...
Wiggum and his pals are lighting the pipes tonight ladies and gentlemen... -
2:57pm | Lady Gaga Is the Least of Indo...
Lady Gaga is too sexy for Indonesia? It's BS. Just watch Dangdut Koplo concert. If dangdut concert such as that is allowed, I don't see why LG is
