Last updated at 12:59 AM. Saturday 20 March 2010

Go to comments October 06, 2009

Jakarta Globe

Residents perform Friday prayers outside a damaged mosque in Padang, West Sumatra, last week. (Photo: Herlambang, EPA)

Residents perform Friday prayers outside a damaged mosque in Padang, West Sumatra, last week. (Photo: Herlambang, EPA)

SMS Messages Link Quakes With Koran; Some Leaders Call Quake 'Warning' From God

Text messages have been circulating since last week linking the timing of Wednesday and Thursday's earthquakes in Sumatra with verses about immorality and punishment in the Koran, prompting some Islamic leaders to call the disaster a “warning” from God.

Two days after the earthquake shook West Sumatra, the Jakarta Globe received an anonymous text message.

“Padang’s earthquake happened at 17:16 and the aftershock happened at 17:58. The next day, there was an earthquake in Jambi at 8:52. Look at the Koran!” the text message stated.

The verses corresponding with the earthquake times reference “annihilating” towns where residents and leaders have acted immorally. (Full translations of the passages are below)

Poet Taufiq Ismail told Republika newspaper that the link between the Padang earthquake and chapter 17, verse 16, in the Koran was found by a young ulema.

“It is awesome. I am stunned,” Taufiq said.

“I think the SMS has spread widely with the purpose that the nation stops doing the things that have angered God,” he said.

Abdullah Syah, chairman of North Sumatra’s Indonesian Council of Ulema (MUI), said that the earthquake was “a test and a warning for people in West Sumatra as well as in other areas.”

“Every one must open their heart and their eyes to the disaster,” he said.

The earthquake was a signal for the Indonesian government to eradicate immorality, Abdullah added.

Meanwhile, geology experts have said the powerful quake that shook Padang came from a spot near — but not inside — the Sunda Trench, a long undersea crescent of seismic energy stretching from north of Aceh to the east of East Timor.

Tectonic plates from India and Australia are grinding slowly under plates that support Indonesia and Burma at a rate of up to six centimeters per year, causing explosive releases of force.

Quake expert Sri Widiyantoro, from the Bandung Institute of Technology, said the precise cause of the jolt in Padang did not come from the seam between plates, but was triggered by a break in the middle, a type known as an intraplate quake.

Translation of Koran verses referenced in SMS message

Chapter 17, Verse 16 (Al Isra)

“And when We desire to destroy a town, We command its affluent ones, those [inhabitants] of it who enjoy the graces [of God], meaning its leaders, [We command them] to obedience, by the tongue of Our messengers; but they fall into immorality therein, rebelling against Our command, and so the Word is justified concerning it, that it should be chastised, and We destroy it utterly, We annihilate it by annihilating its inhabitants and leaving it in ruins.”

Chapter 17, Verse 58 (Al Isra)

“There is not a town — its inhabitants are the ones meant — but We shall destroy it before the Day of Resurrection, through death, or chastise it with terrible chastisement, by killing [its inhabitants] or otherwise. That has been inscribed in the Book, the Preserved Tablet.”

Chapter 8, Verse 52 (Al Anfal)

“The way of these people is like the way of Pharaoh’s folk and those before them: they disbelieved in God’s signs and so God seized them, with chastisement, because of their sins. Truly, God is strong, in what He wills, severe in retribution.”



Post a comment

Login or register to post comments!

Comments

John Ralph

2:10 PM October 8, 2009

To Simon you are 100% correct. I have also worked in Catholic countries where corruption is everywhere. I suppose I am tired of the pretenders, those who consider themselves superior to others because they think they are closer to God. Does not matter to me who they are. Religion is proving itself to be the cause not the answer. In Indonesia, well, who really cares.

Valkyrie

10:42 AM October 8, 2009

I am going to state a few controversial issues here.

In the beginning the universe was created. This has made a lot of people angry and have been widely regarded as a wrong move.

Corruption started right there when Adam tempted Eve. Judas sold his Master for 30 pieces of silver, and so on.

Humanity is an ocean; if a few drops of the ocean is dirty, the ocean does not become dirty.

Having said the above, it is regrettable that moral values of many religions have failed to uphold this virtue and Simon is right.

We are all going through a very dangerous moment in time.

Simon

9:16 AM October 8, 2009

John Ralph, corruption is also a way of life in many non-Islamic nations. Think of Italy or South America. In fact there is a fairly good argument to be made that more devout a nation is, the more likely it is to be plagued by corruption, which rather undermines religion's claim to any moral superiority.

Valkyrie

7:20 AM October 8, 2009

Thanks John! Let me assure you that my question had no malice attached to it.

John Ralph

5:59 PM October 7, 2009

To Valkyrie

I have 7 different English versions of the Koran. Given English is more precise than Bahasa, it is interesting to note the different so called interpretations of the Koran by translators. I also have the strict Saudi Arabian translation (official) which is different in many ways to the other 6 I have. Frankly I am disappointed with the Koran. But it does explain to some extent why corruption is a way of life in so called Muslim countries. That is what I was trying to understand.

Valkyrie

9:53 AM October 7, 2009

John Ralph: I am curious to know from you, why you needed to read the Quran three times over?

John Ralph

7:09 AM October 7, 2009

Indonesia is one of the most corrupt, immoral and unethical countries in the world. Islam has failed in Indonesia and religious leaders have failed to lead. Instead they have done nothing to stem the tide of endemic corruption. I have read the Koran 3 times from cover to cover, and I am disappointed in the lack of real substance in the Koran. Now I know why people question whether Islam is real or pretend. How do you stop the Indonesian culture of lying, cheating and robbing. I was in West Sumatra last week. When I asked why they would not help they said why should we spend our own money when we can just wait for foreign assistance. That is why Islam has failed. You dont care. You dont understand what it means. Your politicians, Bureaucrats and dare I say it, religious leaders, are all on the take to make money now. But dont worry, God will take you by the left hand when the angel comes for you. So stop pretending you know anything about being close to God.

BillyRocks

12:35 AM October 7, 2009

If we read carefully, no one punish God or blame Him, we, human, only reflect what is happening as a sign of human's wrong doing in their lives and that doesn't mean that Padangnese people are doing so much wrong in their lives. It is just a refelction, so we, people, would have better lives in many aspects, religions, social life, earth caring, ... Read moreand many more, and people have right to reflect anything through any reference, so are my friends down there in this JG's comment, I respect their comments. I am not attacking any of your comments friends since men seek the truth in their own characteristics

jetset24

10:35 PM October 6, 2009

Coincidental events cannot usually be relayed with religious epithets. If disasters occur because of bad behavior then how come a few handful of corruptors regardless of ethnicity, religious upbringing are still living comfortably in many corners of Indonesia. What sins could the locals in Padang be so sinful of?? How come there isn't god's wrath over Las Vegas or Macao for example?? Over the edge religious people are clouded with none sense that the balance of reality, science and common sense do not longer exist. This is another way for religious people to be heard, to be known, to influence vulnerable people yet again with their own agenda.

Believe it or not, Indonesia is sitting on the ring of fire...simple as that.

jakman

6:49 PM October 6, 2009

that's smart ghifi. ulemas lie to keep their foothold in the secularizing indonesian society. imagine, how m.tops's followers would respond to this? their own made disaters are justified then! this freaks me out.

in west sumatra the local sharia bylaw prevent women going out unaccompanied, thus make women the majority of the quake victims!

morality should be establised from human values and rationality. only this can help indonesia.

ghifi

5:03 PM October 6, 2009

those times are not entirely accurate for example tasikmalaya earthquake took place @ 14:55 not 15:04

the 2nd earthquake @ padang took place @ 17:38 not 17:58

source: www.bmg.go.id

Valkyrie

4:40 PM October 6, 2009

Simon - A true blooded "existentialist" indeed!

PeterR - Words (prayers) WITHOUT ACTION ARE THE ASSASINS OF IDEALISM.

peterR

4:05 PM October 6, 2009

I agree with Simon. What happened to the compassion in religion, which so many so-called religious leaders seen to process very little of. Instead of sitting around trying to align such disasters to God's hand, they should be doing something to help out.

You can bet your life that when they come to sorting out which sins are actually causing disasters, they will start to cherry pick the immoral acts that suit them best.

Simon

3:11 PM October 6, 2009

Do these idiots ever sit back and reflect that the most devout Islamic nations in the world seem to be the ones most regularly hit by these sorts of terrible natural disasters.

Either they are thoroughly wrong about what their god is thinking or there is no god. Either way, to throw things like this into the mix when so many people are suffering so much is just pure evil, regardless of your beliefs.