Tifatul Says BlackBerry Fight More Than Just About Porn
Markus Junianto Sihaloho & Ismira Lutfia | January 12, 2011
The Communication and Information Ministry wants Research In Motion, the Canadian manufacturer of BlackBerry, to indicate their willingness to comply with the requirements they set in a formal letter. (JG Photo) Related articles
Megawati and Taufiq Share Their Domestic Lives With the Nation 10:39pm Feb 22, 2012
Indonesia’s Graft Taking Toll on Democratic Party’s Popularity 4:54pm Feb 20, 2012
Indonesian Lawmakers Look to Get Foreign NGOs ‘In Line’ 9:56am Feb 20, 2012
New Round of Funding Accusations Against Anas Campaign Emerge 9:17pm Feb 19, 2012
Regaining Control in a Decentralized Indonesia 4:45pm Feb 18, 2012
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
416428There's PKS for you. Partai Kambing Sejati. All they can do is ramming anywhere they deemed necessary. They don't even care if it will destroy Indonesia, as long as their Islam agenda applied here. As far as I concerned, that's terrorism for you.
They, TS’s party, say that the main point of their demands on Blackberry are not to do with just porn. They say that there main concern is that Blackberry does not sell phones itself on the Indonesian market, but rather operates through retailers/agents who import and sell their product, and therefore they do not pay taxes in Indonesia. But is that not pretty much the same deal as most other phone and high end electronic and digital product manufacturers on the market? Most, like Nokia, Motorola, and for cameras and other stuff, Nikon, Canon, etc., surely have agency arrangements here, they don’t import and sell directly themselves. There must be thousands of products who have similar arrangements as BB. As for the tax angle: Well, hardly any company in Indonesia pays tax anyway; they all have a Gayus on their books. So why has Tifatul got a bee in his bonnet about RIM. Could it be that some in his party can smell cash.
Tifatul Sembiring is a horrible little man, an embarrassing little toad, that absolutely nobody likes. He is incompetent and a fraud. For Gods sake, please someone, get rid of him.
"Is it arrogant to remind foreigners to respect our laws and regulations? "
Big Talk. So please, T.S., also enlighten us by showing the one public servant , yet minister, of our deteriorating nation who lives up to that demand!
So embarrassing to see what leadership our nation has. Malu.
Tifatul is beyond belief, he appears to have no understanding of business practice at all.
Local business's are making a fortune selling and providing blackberry and services and paying the due taxes.
Go ahead ban blackberry, it will be Indonesia's loss and the world will just laugh again at another stupid decision
“The company brings no economic benefits to Indonesia, yet they take so much money from here"-tifatul sembiring said
their product will bring benefits to the economy when the govt learn to use BB as more than phone, it can be use for business, to sen reports and so many more, i myself uses a blackberry, i pay RP99.000/month, using XL and it seems unfair if banning blackberry in indonesia,
Mr tifatul, what will you do if u ban blackberry in indonesia and 2 million people protest to you? the citizens pay for the blackberry they use, for the phone, for the phone plan and other things. if 2 mil ppl use bb, the avg pric of 1 bb is around 4 juta, 2 million multiply by 4 juta hpw much is dat, does the govt want to give the citizens their money back ?
In a new twist to the communication minister’s campaign to block BlackBerry users from accessing porn sites, his party is now saying the move is ultimately to protest against the maker of the smartphones and its business practices in Indonesia.
Communication Minister Tifatul Sembiring has given Research in Motion, the Canadian company behind the wildly popular BlackBerry device, until Jan. 27 to filter its BlackBerry Web services for pornography, or risk losing its license to operate in the country.
On Tuesday, Machfud Siddiq, a legislator from Tifatul’s Prosperous Justice Party (PKS), said the campaign was more than just about blocking porn.
He said the main purpose of the ultimatum was to highlight how RIM was “taking too much money from Indonesians without even paying any taxes here.”
“The company brings no economic benefits to Indonesia, yet they take so much money from here,” he said.
“And because the company is based in Canada, it pays taxes there, not here.”
“So this isn’t just about Web filtering,” Machfud added. “It’s about justice in doing business. Indonesia shouldn’t be treated like a cash cow.”
RIM is not required to pay taxes in Indonesia because it is not involved in the retail sale of its phones in the country.
Instead, BlackBerrys are imported by authorized local agents, who pay the requisite customs and excise fees and government sales taxes for the phones, as well as their own corporate taxes.
There are an estimated two million BlackBerry users in Indonesia, out of the total 11.9 million worldwide, making it one of RIM’s biggest markets.
Machfud said Indonesian consumers should support the government’s efforts to push large corporations to invest and create jobs in the country.
Tifatul on Tuesday again took to Twitter to explain his campaign against RIM and try to get Indonesians on his side.
In his messages, the minister claimed there were three million registered BlackBerry users in the country and another one million using black-market phones.
“With an average monthly subscription fee of $7 per customer, RIM makes a net income of Rp 189 billion [$21 million] a month or Rp 2.268 trillion a year,” he wrote.
“That’s the Indonesian people’s money going to RIM,” the minister tweeted.
However, the subscription fee is paid to the local carriers offering BlackBerry Messenger and push-mail services.
Tifatul claimed RIM was making all this money without paying taxes to the Indonesian government or building network infrastructure here.
“Is it wrong to ask for a slice of the pie for Indonesia, such as the hiring of local people, the inclusion of more local content and compliance with local laws and regulations?” Tifatul tweeted.
The minister added, “Do we have to give RIM privileges and exceptions? Do we always have to bow to foreign [entities]? Is it arrogant to remind foreigners to respect our laws and regulations? [Let’s] demand greater rights for our respected nation.”
- John Kei Just a Puppet in Sanex Steel Hit: Jakarta Police
- Afriani’s Drug Seller Arrested, Police Claim
- Food Stall Owners Slam Jakarta Over New Restaurant Tax
- Knife-Wielding Jakarta Child to Meet Psychiatrist
- Thrill Builds in Jakarta for Architecture in Helsinki
- We Have Evidence to Link John Kei to Murder: Jakarta Police
- Pint-Sized Mariachis Learn Music of Mexico in New York
- My Jakarta: Bernadette Maria, Agnostic
- Indonesia Twitter Fight Turns Violent
- Jakarta Bus Operator Could Lose Routes if Found Liable for Two Accidents
-
2:11pm | Indonesia Twitter Fight Turns ...
much about this place is as my oldest puts it 'Beyond Sinetron' :) Last month I started reading my diaries - kept on and off sinc -
2:05pm | Letter to the Editor: Study In...
Yes Yohannes, me too... I resisted entering it for a while but I can see this is like rugby and football... nobody is going to change their stance -
2:01pm | Letter to the Editor: Study In...
DD, as I am sure you are aware, you were one of those I was referring to. You can be successful but it is very hard work and all about ... -
1:59pm | Malaysia Bans British Author's...
@marko1 : quoted you: “Its sad you try to be more Arab than Arab” -> so you think arab is Islam and Islam is arab ?? You are tiring me . -
1:57pm | Letter to the Editor: Study In...
@SirAnthony: It is funny that now you are crying about censorship, while you are the first one trying to undermine my argument by saying that I am -
1:57pm | Indonesia Twitter Fight Turns ...
@Dez: That's nothing pal, a friend of a friend used to know an editor type in Jakarta who assaulted a check in operator for being tardy at Soekar -
1:53pm | Letter to the Editor: Study In...
Have no fear TB, Ay-dolf is still some distance away from make an ill-advised entrance into the proceedings. -
1:50pm | Sneaky Police Janitor Tries To...
"Jakarta Police traffic division chief Dwi Sigit Nurmantyas on Wednesday denied allegations that the force’s tow truck drivers were engaged in su
