Tolerance in Theory, but Not in Action
Markus Junianto Sihaloho | February 13, 2012
Youths from inter religious community in a rally to campaign for pluralism at Malioboro street, Yogyakarta. A new survey released on Saturday found that 95.4 percent of 2,500 people questioned across Indonesia believed that religious freedom should be respected. (JG Photo/Boy T. Harjanto) Related articles
Indonesia ‘Most Tolerant Country in the World’: Religious Minister 5:17pm May 23, 2012
Religious Groups Criticize Government for Weak Support of Religious Freedom 10:49am May 21, 2012
Top Muslim Groups Decry Attacks on Religious Liberty 9:29pm May 22, 2012
With Indonesia Now Stable, EU Ends Aid for Displaced 10:29pm May 15, 2012
Church Row a ‘Dark Time’ for Aceh 8:48pm May 11, 2012
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
497627I mean alwa
I would prefer my kids to root for my football team let alone my faith or religion ! Off course you would want your kids have the same faith as you are and it is natural that you try to convince them the right path you take and pray that they follow. But in the end they have the right to say no. That's basic human rights.
Well unless the faith they sign up for encourages them to kill or blow up other faith. Then I may need Densus88 number.
JPB... If it wasnt for the Americans displacing the Japanese there wouildnt be any Indonesia.
@marko.
I wasn't addressing putri specifically.
I merely disagreed that all this "peace and diversity" will ultimately achieve anything in the end, as it merely serves to silent any honest intellectual discussion on this issue.
The fact is that there is a good reason for not practicing tolerance, if you believe that believing the wrong religion can cause suffering in the afterlife.
The issue then shifts to this: is there a rational reason for having any religious beliefs in the first place? You have to deal with this in an honest debate/discussion, you can't silence these.
The Islamic Qur'an (Feast 5:5) is more tolerant of inter-marriage than either the Jewish Torat (Deuteronomy 7:3) or Christian Injil (1 Corinthians 7:39). Permitting inter-marriage is simply saying religion doesn't matter much. That's easy. Permitting conversion between religions is religious tolerance and pluralism. That's much harder. Wouldn't the correct application of Pancasila be to start with One Almighty God, who different groups believe has revealed slightly different codes of conduct, and ensure national laws are not made that would try to force people to go against God, whichever Book they believe. Get it? Don't try to force people to go against God, just for the sake of trying to make everyone the same, or letting some do what they want. If Indonesia succeeds in putting Pancasila into practise, it will be her glory, lan satunggal hadiah saking Gusti Allah. Berkah dalem, Bung Bule.
While the majority of Indonesians agree in principle that other people’s religions and faiths should be respected, this does not consistently translate to everyday life, according to a new survey.
The survey, which was released on Saturday, found that 95.4 percent of 2,500 people questioned across the country believed that religious freedom should be respected. It was conducted jointly by the People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR) and Syarif Hidayatullah University in Jakarta.
The results were unveiled on Saturday by lawmaker Eva Kusuma Sundari, who said the reality of events playing out across Indonesia did not reflect this broad consensus.
“This means that people’s tolerance for religious differences is just intellectual discourse or a moral commitment,” she said. “It’s not yet at the level of action or political commitment.”
Forty-six percent of respondents said they would not accept an interreligious marriage among their immediate family members, underlining the disconnect between honoring religious difference in theory and in practice.
Eva said the survey also showed there was a very low level of implementation of the state’s founding ideology, Pancasila, which stipulates equal footing for all religions.
She said only 3 percent of those questioned said they consciously applied Pancasila. The rest said they did not go out of their way to implement it.
“This contradicts the fact that the results of the survey found that the majority of people, or 90 percent of Indonesians, agree that Pancasila should provide a foundation for everyday action and life,” she said.
The survey’s results, she said, should serve as a serious warning for the MPR and the government that Pancasila is increasingly losing its meaning as an ideology for the nation.
“Seventy-seven percent of the people questioned also expressed concerns that globalization and foreign values and ideologies were pushing out Pancasila,” Eva said.
Meanwhile, thousands of representatives of the country’s six officially recognized religions gathered on Sunday at the House of Representatives in Jakarta to mark World Interfaith Harmony Week. The theme of the gathering was “Diversity Creates Harmony in Indonesia.”
Among those present were Din Syamsuddin, the chairman of the country’s second-largest Islamic organization, Muhammadiyah, Andreas Sewangu of the Indonesian Bishops Council and I Nyoman Udayana of the Indonesian Hindu Dharma Association. Also present were Philip Wijaya from the Buddhist Council and Wawan Wiratman from the Confucian High Council, among others.
“On this occasion, we pledge that there is no religion in Indonesia that refuses to allow diversity,” Syamsuddin said.
“Do not always look for what is different, but look to our similarities to live in harmony and peace in Indonesia.”
Those present also expressed a commitment to maintain harmony in the society and state, under the ideology of Pancasila.
MPR chairman Taufik Kiemas vowed to support every program that promoted interfaith tolerance in the country.
“Each year, the MPR will support events that renew pledges of commitment to interfaith harmony in Indonesia,” he said.
Udayana said the state had a responsibility to maintain interfaith harmony in Indonesia.
“The state guarantees freedom of religion,” he said. “There should be no discrimination between the majority and minority.”
Hajriyanto Thohari, deputy chairman of the MPR, said state institutions should work closely with religious groups to promote unity in diversity and the recognition of the pluralistic nature of the nation.
He also agreed that while most people professed an acceptance of Pancasila and pluralism, this was mainly in theory and not in actual practice.
- Tomy Winata to Build Jakarta's Tallest Building
- Lady Gaga Angers Thai Fans With Fake Rolex Comment
- Lady Gaga Refuses to Tone Down Her Shows: Manager
- Indonesia Set to Cap Bank Owners’ Stakes: Sources
- Djoko Says ‘I Don’t Care’ About FPI Demonstration
- President's Son Nearly Attacked by Angry Mob
- Singapore Cabby Jailed for Molesting Indonesian Maid
- If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Watch, Djoko Says of Gaga
- Indonesia's Chief Justice Demands SBY Explain Corby Clemency
- National Exams' ‘Fantastic’ Passing Rate Suspicious: ICW
-
10:41pm | Djoko Says ‘I Don’t Care’ Abou...
Meanwhile, in complete contrast from what the S.O.B is at liberty to say under the freedom of his beloved Indonesian constitution.... -
10:34pm | Tomy Winata to Build Jakarta's...
As sound as interesting it is, and how people would picture this monumental skyscraper will glorify the skyline of Jakarta. I see no objectives. -
10:34pm | Indonesian Police Consider Ton...
A small but extremely loud group of mentally retarded inbreds. And you know what we do with retarded inbreds: we ignore them. -
10:30pm | If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Wa...
The picture showed People with deepest and darkest hatred for other human beings and showing their true color by calling them KAFIR? You can only s -
10:04pm | Djoko Says ‘I Don’t Care’ Abou...
more on Sobri (lets call him S.O.B. from now on) Jakarta Post 15/4/08 – A videotape screened on Monday showed Islamic Defenders Front (FPI) -
9:42pm | Lady Gaga Concert Promoter Has...
the whole country went gaga over lady gaga -
9:41pm | Two IPB Security Guards Shot D...
Ah Bogor - such a center of peace and piety. -
9:39pm | Lady Gaga Concert Promoter Has...
"a permit from the venue, a recommendation from the Jakarta police, a recommendation from the Tourism and Creative Economy Ministry, a permit for
