Train Roof-Rider Deterrent Could Be Fatal: Rights Group
Mary Anugrah Rasita | January 18, 2012
A worker installs concrete balls above railway tracks in Bekasi on Tuesday. Authorities have gone to imaginative extremes to try to stop commuters from riding on the roofs of trains. JG Photo/Yudhi Sukma Wijaya Related articles
Man Killed on Roof of Indonesian Train 10:18am Feb 15, 2012
Iron Bars the Latest Tactic to Stop Train Roof Riders 10:45am Feb 11, 2012
1,500 Sign Up for Rail Commuter E-Tickets 6:06pm Feb 8, 2012
KAI to Install 3 More Sets Of Dangerous Train Balls 11:38am Jan 21, 2012
Indonesia Begins Yet Another Crack Down on Train ‘Surfers’ 1:59pm Jan 17, 2012
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
492041Didn't take long to get a reaction from human rights groups. I admit the solution is barbaric but that seems to fit with the general model of 'enforcement' in this country.
More carriages would have been the solution or monitoring ticket sales vs seats available, who knows. I'm betting each one of those balls goes for $5000 once every official and businessman has his 'fee'.
The world press is having a field day over this. Almost uniformly the press mocks KAI. The pictures they are showing show the real problem. The trains are so packed that daily commuters have no choice. They have to get to work.
This will only get worst not better. When fuel subsidies are cut more people will look to trains. The population expands and demand increases but like everything else bugger that, why spend money on more trains and coaches and -god forbid- passenger comfort... no just keep selling tickets and use the same over loaded infrastructure.... sounds a bit like the internet providers in Indonesia too!!!!
This is classic lack of planning. KAI will spend the rest of it's life trying to keep up with demand instead of planning ahead to keep the service ahead of demand. This is really nothing less than criminal negligence and the same old story the victims are to blame... "They don't have to sit on the roof" YES THEY DO there is not enough room inside.
Find private financiers or investors for funds & buy more train coaches.
unbelievable..whats next? snipers??
Now just look at the image above - a worker installing the concrete balls. Even this fellow does NOT wear a safety harness to avoid being injured (or even dead) in case he falls off the rail. Nobody seems to have responsibility here and life is just so cheap. Even the installation of these potential death traps is a potential death trap itself...
A rights watchdog has criticized the state railway company for its installation of potentially deadly hanging concrete balls over train tracks to prevent roof surfers.
Yosep Adi Prasetyo, a spokesman for the National Commission on Human Rights (Komnas HAM), said the move by Kereta Api Indonesia to install concrete balls hanging from wires would lead to violations of human rights as the balls had the potential to kill.
“Picture this: If a student has to take the train, he or she would face the threat of being killed by the concrete balls,” he said. “Now his right to get to school safely is simply violated.”
KAI has repeatedly tried to discourage people from the dangerous practice of riding on the roof of trains. It has threatened measures such as fines and detentions, dousing roof riders with colored water and smearing grease on the roof.
KAI even resorted to seeking the help of religious leaders, asking them to speak to their followers about the dangers of riding atop trains.
Adi said those efforts were ineffective because the core problem behind the practice was that there was not enough trains to carry all commuters.
“These people need to get to their workplace on time and they will do whatever it takes to minimize the chances of being late,” Adi said.
He said that during peak hours, trains were so densely packed that even the toilets had commuters crammed in them.
In its latest bid to prevent roof riders, KAI is hoping that the threat of injury, or even death, will put a stop to the practice.
Last Thursday, it announced that it would install concrete balls at rooftop height at stations including in Bekasi, Tambun and Cikarang, as well as at train crossings.
“The construction was started since this afternoon,” KAI spokesman Mateta Rizalulhaq said on Tuesday. “The next destination will be the one that is going to Rangkas, where the trains are pulled by locomotive.”
He added that several things needed to be considered when setting up the concrete balls, including a detailed check of train schedules.
“We have to wait for every train to pass first because it is impossible to put up [the balls] when trains are passing by.”
The measure consists of a row of 20 concrete balls about 10 centimeters apart hanging across the railway track 25 centimeters above the height of a train’s rooftop.
He declined to say how much money it had cost to install the sets of grapefruit-sized balls.
Mateta said that the balls would only be used on tracks served by trains pulled by locomotives, while those served by electric trains will instead use swing doors that allow the pantographs of electrical trains to pass but cause complications for people on the roof.
Activists have previously given several reasons for people riding on train roofs, including a lack of space on board the train, a wish to avoid paying a fare and a desire for a joyride.
- John Kei Just a Puppet in Sanex Steel Hit: Jakarta Police
- Afriani’s Drug Seller Arrested, Police Claim
- Food Stall Owners Slam Jakarta Over New Restaurant Tax
- Knife-Wielding Jakarta Child to Meet Psychiatrist
- Thrill Builds in Jakarta for Architecture in Helsinki
- We Have Evidence to Link John Kei to Murder: Jakarta Police
- Pint-Sized Mariachis Learn Music of Mexico in New York
- My Jakarta: Bernadette Maria, Agnostic
- Indonesia Twitter Fight Turns Violent
- Jakarta Bus Operator Could Lose Routes if Found Liable for Two Accidents
-
2:05pm | Letter to the Editor: Study In...
Yes Yohannes, me too... I resisted entering it for a while but I can see this is like rugby and football... nobody is going to change their stance -
2:01pm | Letter to the Editor: Study In...
DD, as I am sure you are aware, you were one of those I was referring to. You can be successful but it is very hard work and all about ... -
1:59pm | Malaysia Bans British Author's...
@marko1 : quoted you: “Its sad you try to be more Arab than Arab” -> so you think arab is Islam and Islam is arab ?? You are tiring me . -
1:57pm | Letter to the Editor: Study In...
@SirAnthony: It is funny that now you are crying about censorship, while you are the first one trying to undermine my argument by saying that I am -
1:57pm | Indonesia Twitter Fight Turns ...
@Dez: That's nothing pal, a friend of a friend used to know an editor type in Jakarta who assaulted a check in operator for being tardy at Soekar -
1:53pm | Letter to the Editor: Study In...
Have no fear TB, Ay-dolf is still some distance away from make an ill-advised entrance into the proceedings. -
1:50pm | Sneaky Police Janitor Tries To...
"Jakarta Police traffic division chief Dwi Sigit Nurmantyas on Wednesday denied allegations that the force’s tow truck drivers were engaged in su -
1:49pm | Afriani’s Drug Seller Arrested...
I bet he's just a scapegoat. The dealer is within the club.
