Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Thu, February 9, 2012
Archive Search

Two Shariah Police Officers Receive 8-Year Sentences for Rape of Student
Nurdin Hasan | July 16, 2010

Share This Page
59
23
0
7
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

Roland
7:16pm Jul 18, 2010

The judge also said that "eight years was 'relatively heavy' compared to verdicts in other parts of the country for similar offences".

Does that somehow indicate that gang rape by (Sharia) law enforcement officers happens many times and that verdicts, after having a 20 year young girl under an alleged "immoral act" (and here we have this "Moral" thing again!) taken into custody, gang raped (BTW I thought it was originally 3 of them - what happened with No. 3?), caused definitely detrimental harm to the victim’s future (even though the judge declared differently - maybe he's got a crystal ball and is able to read the girls future) and caused severe haemorrhaging to the girl?

Also, “The defendants had never committed a crime before, they were always polite during the trial and they are the breadwinners for their families...” - didn't we all hear that one before?

Wouldn't it have been more appropriate to have a female judge running the proceedings this time?


peterhal1
6:47pm Jul 18, 2010

As to Judge Lukman Bachmid comments " the maximum sentence would have only been given if the offense had cause detrimental harm to the victim’s future" he must be joking. Has he even bothered to have this young lady examined by a team of IMPARTIAL psychiatrists before coming to this conclusion?

As to the rapists, they were always polite during the trial and they are the breadwinners for their families- so bloody what! If they are married then it's adutery so they should be executed. Rape and torture and out in 4 years. One can only hope the other inmates give them their just deserts.


peterR
6:38pm Jul 18, 2010

But then again, it concerns only women, who are of course just vessels, reciprocals.


peterR
6:35pm Jul 18, 2010

Surely these are Islamic criminals?


diggah
11:30pm Jul 17, 2010

diggah, These Sharia crimminals are the very worst crimminal there are, to corrupt the tennants of Sharia Law and abuse the word of the Quran deserves the most severe penalty and punishment that Sharia and Secular Law can provide. This sort of corruption brings shame to the true followers of Islam worldwide.


Banda Aceh. The Langsa District Court in East Aceh on Thursday sentenced two members of the Shariah Police to eight years in prison each for the rape and torture of a 20-year-old female student in January.

The punishment was less than the maximum 12-year jail term demanded by prosecutors, who argued that as members of the Shariah Police, also known as Wilayatul Hisbah, the defendants should have better morals.

Prosecutor Sayed Muhammad had previously pointed out that the offenders, Muhammad Nazir, 29, and Feri Agus, 28, had taken turns raping the woman in a detention cell with another officer in the early hours of Jan. 8. The third suspect, Dedy Setiawan, 27, is still at large.

Both convicts said through their lawyers that they would consider the verdict before deciding whether to appeal.

Judge Lukman Bachmid, the Langsa District Court chief, said on Thursday that both men had received the eight-year sentences because of the harm and trauma inflicted on the victim.

He said that eight years was “relatively heavy” compared to verdicts in other parts of the country for similar offenses.

“The defendants had never committed a crime before, they were always polite during the trial and they are the breadwinners for their families,” he said.

He also said that the maximum sentence would have only been given if the offense had cause detrimental harm to the victim’s future.

The victim, identified only as N, was taken into custody by the Shariah Police for allegedly engaging in an immoral act with her boyfriend. Both she and her boyfriend were detained and questioned by the officers.

The rape occurred early on a Friday, which is considered a holy day for Muslims with mandatory prayers held in the afternoon for Muslim men.

Sayed said that a medical examination confirmed the victim had been sexually assaulted and that she had suffered severe hemorrhaging as a result of the rape.

After the incident was made public, rights activists in Aceh and across the country called for the Shariah Police to be disbanded, saying that it was a law unto itself and did nothing but harass women about their clothes and humiliate young unmarried couples.




  • 2:30pm | Indonesian Art Sales Among Fa...
    Good afternnon, you wrote :"Last year, Indonesia led the art world in auction revenue growth with 39 percent, followed by China’s 38 percent growt
  • 2:26pm | Malaysian Girl Speaks Indonesi...
    I'm a linguist and I know of studies which investigated similar cases (people who appeared to suddenly speak a language they don't know, sometime
  • 2:23pm | Indonesians Buying Up Most Exp...
    Aside from money laundering, this is how they get to evade taxes.
  • 2:22pm | New Indonesian TV Mini-Series ...
    of course the behaviour of our football league and their fans are a role model for tolerance, conflict resolution.... Good try though and we
  • 2:20pm | New Indonesian TV Mini-Series ...
    And will there be non muslims in the teams?
  • 2:17pm | Editorial: When 240 Million Mo...
    Re Rice - only the other day we announced a giant SEO that will generate another 300,000 t per year... Ok with a growing population of 5m pa - that
  • 2:15pm | Editorial: When 240 Million Mo...
    SJ - all the cash in the world wont help when there isnt enough... I think thats the point. Sure money will help short term for a few but not ...
  • 2:14pm | Indonesia Property Demand to R...
    Amir We need to get a few facts on the table Firstly, whilst we are recording excellent GDP the make up of that growth must be understood. O