Religion Minister Defends Indonesia's Blasphemy Law
Anita Rachman & Ulma Haryanto | March 25, 2010
Culture expert Taufiq Ismail testifying during a hearing on the Blasphemy Law at the Constitutional Court on Wednesday. (JG Photo/Safir Makki) Related articles
Blasphemy Law Review Demanded Amid Strife 9:47am Feb 19, 2011
Two Indonesias: Which One Will Emerge From Sectarian Strife? 11:03am Feb 10, 2011
American’s Blasphemy Trial Set to Start 12:18am Sep 29, 2010
Police Seek Dialogue To End Spat In Lombok 12:39am Sep 20, 2010
Confusion Surrounds Blasphemy Allegation 12:23am Sep 18, 2010
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
365540And we have seen exactly how harmony is maintained under this law when opponents of change yesterday physically attacked and assalted those seeking reform.
The Truth is never imposed. It is accepted. Freely. Otherwise it is not the Truth.
How do people become ministers in Indonesia? One more on the list of completely incompetent ones is for sure this Religious Affairs Minister...what the f..k is he talking about when he says people “could establish new religions, declaring new prophets, new angels, it could cause the breakdown of harmony".
We are not living in the dark ages anymore, get rid of this fellow!
- Previous
- 1
- Next
Makassar, South Sulawesi. Minister of Religious Affairs Suryadharma Ali on Wednesday sought the support of the country’s largest Islamic organization, the Nahdlatul Ulama, in maintaining the country’s 1965 Blasphemy Law, which is under review at the Constitutional Court.
“The consequences [if the law is annulled] are that people, figures, could establish new religions, declare new prophets, new angels,” Suryadharma told thousands of NU followers during the group’s 32nd national congress.
“It could be one that could trigger a harmony breakdown. I expect that NU could also [work] together to solve this problem,” he said.
Suryadharma shared a stage with Minister of National Education Mohammad Nuh in Wednesday’s congress to discuss religion and education issues in the country and in NU. He took the opportunity to enlist its support over the law.
The 1965 law recognizes only six religions: Islam, Protestantism, Catholicism, Buddhism, Hinduism and Confucianism. Others are officially banned. It also prohibits alternative interpretations of recognized religions, including Islam.
In 2008, the government used the law to formally ban Ahmadiyah, a minority Islamic sect, because members held that its founder, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, was the last prophet of Islam, a claim that contradicts mainstream Muslim beliefs.
The Constitutional Court is currently reviewing the law following a demand for a review filed by human rights groups and the late former President Aburrahman “Gus Dur” Wahid, who was also a longtime former NU chairman.
The law “should be secured,” he told the plenary to the cheers of NU members attending the session. “Freedom doesn’t have to be absolute. There must still be rules.”
Suryadharma depicted a gloomy picture of conditions if the law was annulled. He said Islam and the Koran could be interpreted at will.
“Maintaining religious harmony is essential, and maintaining harmony within the same religion is already difficult nowadays. Maintaining NU is difficult. There are some that are [moving to the] left and some to the right,” he said, provoking laughter from audience members. “And it will be even more so if there are new religions.”
Meanwhile, at the Constitutional Court, W. Cole Durham Jr., a professor of law and director of the International Center for Law and Religion Studies at Brigham Young University in the United States, testified via video conference. He noted that Indonesia had agreed to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
“Indonesia thereby also accepted the obligation to protect freedom of expression, freedom of association, and equal protection under law, as well as to extend these protections to religious minorities,” Durham said.
He agreed that the challenged provisions in the law were not only inconsistent with international human rights standards, but also open to multiple interpretations.
Also testifying in favor of the plaintiffs were a host of legal and religious scholars and experts and former officials. A verdict will be delivered in mid-April.
- The Secret Catch of South Jakarta
- What US Stop Online Piracy Act Means for Indonesia
- Indonesian Judge Faces 20 Years for Graft
- Jakarta Police Bust Rp 128b Drug Ring
- For Many Indonesians, ‘Facebook’ Is the Only Internet
- Notorious Gang Boss Could Be Behind Sanex Steel Murder: Jakarta Police
- Luxury Property Prices Soar in Jakarta as Economy Fires Up Demand
- Indonesia to Create Giant Palm Oil, Rubber Firm
- More Backpedaling on Indonesia's Plan to Restrict Subsidized Fuel
- My Jakarta: Bagus, Child Busker
-
12:41pm | Who Are the Atheists in Indone...
@DrDez : You said : “..Islam in a no win situation.” …” is imposed via violence, oppression & severe indoctrination” … “ used destroy manki -
12:26pm | Majapahit Artifacts Go Missing...
i thought the very base of Indonesia's existence is leaned on the 2 thallasocratic empires.the Philippinos know about the Madjapahit empire in Sou -
12:17pm | Lighter Than Air Photography T...
I like it. I hope these people do well. -
12:01pm | Yohanes Sulaiman: Indonesia Ca...
Yohanes Are you talking about the same Regan that precipitated the huge economic crisis of 2008? The same Regan that supported dicta -
10:57am | Angelina Sondakh Named a Suspe...
Yes Val - detained for a (edit) banana but allowed to roam free for billions ... -
10:56am | Who Are the Atheists in Indone...
Bowel How do we know if god is against atheism... Interesting point. However what we do know is that Muslims ARE persecuting Atheists (even -
10:30am | Who Are the Atheists in Indone...
@nonredneck: How do we know whether God against or support atheism? Logically God is independent right? Does God need supporters to legitimate God’ -
10:13am | Angelina Sondakh Named a Suspe...
"Abraham said Angelina would not be immediately detained." Guess that gives her time to lose her memory, get sick and leave Indonesia with her mo
