Minorities Tell of Afghan Army’s Ethnic Favoritism
Claire Truscott | January 04, 2011
Related articles
Fighting Season — For Animals — Peaks in Afghanistan 6:22pm Apr 29, 2012
Afghan Official: Haqqanis Blamed For Kabul Attacks 8:53pm Apr 16, 2012
Taliban Militants Raid Pakistani Prison, Free 380 Inmates 7:45pm Apr 15, 2012
Taliban Offer Question-and-Answer Service Online 2:18pm Mar 28, 2012
Villagers: Afghan Slayings Were Act of Retaliation 12:10pm Mar 21, 2012
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
Be the first to write your opinion!
Musa Qala. Disgruntled Afghan soldiers dish out $5 dinner plates of fried rice and potatoes to US Marines at a camp on the frontline against the Taliban in southern Afghanistan.
This culinary sideline, which supplements the US forces’ spartan rations, helps the Afghans save enough cash to bribe their commander to give them time off to see their families, the men say. Some never return.
Speaking in secret afterwards, the Afghan troops said that because they are ethnic minorities in the country’s Pashtun-heavy army, bribery is the only way they can make sure their Pashtun commander gives them a break.
“The commander tells us, ‘search your pockets.’ If somebody gives him money, he can take vacation. I don’t have any money so I can’t go,” said one soldier, a 20-year-old ethnic Hazara man.
“As a non-Pashtun, I’m cheap. I’m not as valuable to the army as a Pashtun soldier,” added a Tajik, who like others requested anonymity for fear of retribution.
The situation is sapping morale among young recruits at a small base in the Musa Qala district of volatile Helmand province, a highly dangerous area and one of Afghanistan’s main Taliban flashpoints.
This is just one of the issues dogging Afghanistan’s 150,000-member national army, whose strength is key to the plan for international troops gradually to withdraw and hand over responsibility for security to Afghan forces by 2014.
A report from the International Crisis Group in May said today’s Afghan army was “incapable of fighting the insurgency on its own,” highlighting ethnic factionalism, illiteracy, drug addiction and desertion.
Its research found that Pashtuns and Tajiks — thought to make up 42 and 27 percent of all Afghans respectively — dominate the officer ranks, while Hazaras, Uzbeks and other groups remain under-represented at that level.
General Mohammad Zaher Azimi of the Ministry of Defence said that the Afghan National Army was ethnically balanced and that it would not stand for any discrimination in the ranks.
“We are not aware of any mistreatment of soldiers from one ethnic group by officers from another ethnic group, or officers taking bribes to give soldiers leave,” he said. “But we will investigate these reports and if we find out they are true, we will take proper measures to solve them. We will not tolerate any kind of discrimination in the national army.”
Feelings of alienation do not help fire up the young recruits for their job, which many admit they find frightening and only stick with for the relatively decent wage of $280 per month.
Dangers lurk both on and off the battlefield — Taliban attacks on army targets in Afghanistan’s towns and cities are frequent, with nine troops killed in one day last month in Kabul and Kunduz.
“I’m scared, who cannot be scared of a Taliban attack? If the foreigners leave, we don’t have anything,” said the young Tajik soldier, who has another three years to serve before he can leave the army.
“Most of us are scared because we just come to get money,” the Hazara soldier added. “Without the Marines’ help we cannot look after Musa Qala.”
Agence France-Presse
- Lady Gaga Angers Thai Fans With Fake Rolex Comment
- Djoko Says ‘I Don’t Care’ About FPI Demonstration
- If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Watch, Djoko Says of Gaga
- New Traffic Flow Around Kuningan Intersection
- 'Stop Treating Indonesia as a Beggar Nation,' Australian Academic Urges
- National Exams' ‘Fantastic’ Passing Rate Suspicious: ICW
- Lady Gaga Concert Promoter Has Two Days Left to Get Permit for Indonesia Show
- Malaysian Authorities Seize Copies of Irshad Manji’s Book
- Porsche With Military Plates Riles Officials
- Singapore Blogger Xiaxue Fights Back Against Facebook Abuse
-
3:42pm | Suharto’s Gone, But Many in In...
Off course. The best days for Indonesia was on 13 and 14 May 1998. Back then we could feel freedom and security -
3:37pm | Yudhoyono Seeks to Take Charge...
Rip Van Winkle wakes up to discover his party, his government and his country is in complete disarray. And his first action on awake -
3:33pm | Ministry Will Probe Images Of ...
What total garbage Religon is a man made industry God has nothing to do with it. -
3:17pm | Yudhoyono Seeks to Take Charge...
Yudhoyono will take charge of the ailing party. When did this weak excuse for a national leader take charge of anything. -
2:44pm | Indonesian Police Consider Ton...
Regardless of what ever the event the organizers will always be open to the professional extortion associations such as the Police military or thug -
2:32pm | Suharto’s Gone, But Many in In...
well if you guys miss him, go join him up there :) -
1:46pm | Djoko Says ‘I Don’t Care’ Abou...
Anon on step further. Arrest Habib, munarman and play lady gaga 24/7 in thier cell..... -
1:44pm | AGO Slow in Responding to BPK ...
exbrit; correct, we are reminded EVERY single day that CRIME PAYS!
