Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Sat, May 26, 2012
Archive Search

Papuans Don’t Understand What They Really Want, Ministers Claim
Camelia Pasandaran & Banjir Ambarita | July 14, 2010

Share This Page
6
1
0
3
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

Markus Hagenauer
3:43pm Jul 14, 2010

Why can´t the Indonesian authoiries see that Papuans are not asking for money, they want freedom. It can´t be compensated by infrastructure. Thats like saying, the military will conitiue to rape you, but if you get pregnant you can give birth in a hospital.

You can get good education, but you will never be allowed to speak out your opineon if it is against the government.

And you can walk away on a broad road, after your village has been burned down. It´s a contumely to tell the Papuans, they would not know what they want.

A referendum might be a solution. But for sure it must be watched closely by the UN to avert a fraud as it happened more than 40 years ago.

djakarta
11:29am Jul 14, 2010

@btmanning:

Indonesia will never allow any referendum to take place. UN is also not interested to revoke its own Resolution in 1969 which acknowledged Papua as part of Indonesia.

Even such a referendum shall not produce vote for independence since more than 50% of the population in Papua are transmigrants.

btmanning
9:51am Jul 14, 2010

There is no doubt the present population of West Papua is divided and it is understandable that non-indigenous, transmigrated people would favour autonomy. However, amongst the Indigenous West Papuans there is a clear majority that wishes Independence.

This question is best resolved by an Internationally supervised Referendum. The 1967 so called 'Act of Free Choice' was not the choice of ALL the people and was secured by intimidation and coersion.

Meanwhile, the land and rich resources are being stolen from the rightful owners.


  • Previous
  • 1
  • Next

If the broad autonomy accorded to Papua had not raised the region’s prosperity it was the local authorities’ fault, government ministers said on Tuesday.

The comments came on the heel of massive protests in Papua last week that demanded a referendum on self-determination and claimed the special autonomy handed to the region in 2001 had failed.

“In Papua there are people demanding freedom from Indonesia,” Justice and Human Rights Minister Patrialis Akbar said.

“Actually, they don’t really understand that what they really want is good welfare. In fact, we have sent Rp 30 trillion [$3.3 billion] to Papua.”

The coordinating minister for political, legal and security affairs, Djoko Suyanto, said it was not up to Jakarta to monitor the region’s special autonomy status.

“If there are funds for the region that have not been disbursed, that is the work of the governor and the DPRP to supervise,” Djoko said, using the acronym for the Papua Legislative Council.

Djoko said that trillions of rupiah had been sent to develop the region, making Papua the largest single recipient of special autonomy funds.

The coordinating minister said that last week he had met twice with representatives of the DPRP and the Papuan People’s Council (MRP) to discuss the calls for a referendum in Papua.

“They have stated what they need to say and we also stated our standing position,” he said.

Salmon Yumame, who heads the United Papua People’s Democracy Forum (Fordem), said that despite the introduction of special autonomy, Papuans remained marginalized.

“The special autonomy with its trillions of rupiah has never touched the lives of our people,” Salmon said.

“Those who enjoy the money are only the elite and bureaucrats,” he added.

Salmon said that special autonomy did not protect or benefit Papua’s native people and that there was a need for the policy to be evaluated.

“In the nine years since special autonomy was given, it has never been evaluated,” he said.

Salmon said that the special status given to the region had failed to raise the dignity of the Papuan people and that the MRP had seen its decisions ignored.

He said that despite the council’s recommendation that heads and lawmakers in Papua be native to the region, many were appointees from outside.

Fordem’s secretary general, Benny Giay, told the Jakarta Globe that another problem giving rise to dissatisfaction in Papua and therefore fueling the demand for a referendum was the wide economic gap between natives and migrants in the region.

“There are also problems of the basic needs and rights of the Papua people, such as education and health, which are not being fulfilled by the government,” Benny said. “This reality has forced some of Papuan people to ask for a referendum.”

He said migration to Papua from other parts of the country should be halted. Benny accused the government in Jakarta of being arrogant and failing to ensure special autonomy in Papua was really implemented.

Discontent in Papua has been fueled by what local people perceive as the siphoning off of the region’s natural resources by non-Papuans and the alleged human rights violations in the region committed in the name of national security.