Welcome Guest   |  Login   |   Signup
JG Logo
Sat, May 26, 2012
Archive Search

Greenpeace Cries Foul as Eviction Papers Are Served
Elisabeth Oktofani & Dofa Fasila | November 09, 2011

FBR members hold a protest in front of Greenpeace office in Kemang, South Jakarta in July. (JG Photo/Dessy Sagita) FBR members hold a protest in front of Greenpeace office in Kemang, South Jakarta in July. (JG Photo/Dessy Sagita)
Share This Page
10
10
0
20
Share with google+ :


Post a comment
Please login to post comment

Comments

Jakartass
3:01pm Nov 11, 2011

Maybe Greenpeace is occupying a property zoned for residential use. However, if all those bars, restaurants and boutiques were served with eviction natices on the same day, none of us would suspect the hidden hand of APP behind City Hall's action!


Comello
9:21am Nov 11, 2011

Well, actually, they call themselves a'CPR-Indonesia is a business lobbying organisation which supports the economic development of Indonesia.'


jchay
9:12am Nov 11, 2011

APP vs. Greenpeace, they're both sitting on the opposite extreme, fighting with their own agenda and politics, on the cost of Indonesian forests and future of our grandkids. Unless we say "stop!" and choose the right competent officials (Ministers, DPR, etc) to fight for the interest of future Indonesia (not individual or party's interest!), the soap opera between these two powers won't ever stop... well maybe until Indonesia has lost everything we have, then there's nothing more to fight for, and nothing more for our grandkids. Indonesia must determine their own future, not APP or Greenpeace.


DrDez
9:08am Nov 11, 2011

Good post Comello - the campaign to reduce poverty is just a sham - so we wait for Alan's reply...

PS - I agree however that Greenpeace are often their own worst enemy - rather like CND - but they play a vital role and to act this way by the govt is just implying to a watching world that they are hiding stuff - which of course they probably are

Come on Alan - respond to Comello


Comello
8:22am Nov 11, 2011

Dr Dez et al.

I've seen a few of Allan Bruce Davies' posts re Greenpeace in which he systematically discredits their efforts in Indonesia.

Some of you have reacted as if he were a regular poster.

I think you should know he is working for the Indonesian government (Campaign to Reduce Poverty).

Their website includes gems as 'At present, there is very little illegal logging in Indonesia. Government licences are strictly observed – especially by the big companies.'

Davies' comments are strictly along the line of CPR - defending the government's standpoint.

I just thought you should consider this when reacting to his posts.


Environmental group Greenpeace has lashed out at the Jakarta administration’s decision to seal off its office for zoning violations, calling the move just the latest attack in a corporate-backed smear campaign against the organization.

Greenpeace Southeast Asia media campaigner Hikmat Soeriatanuwijaya said the group had been unfairly targeted.

“The continued attacks against Greenpeace started when we launched our global campaign against Asia Pulp and Paper by exposing evidence of APP forest destruction in early June this year,” he said.

He declined, however, to say who Greenpeace believed was behind the smear campaign.

“Although we know who it is, we don’t want to mention the particular company or party because we don’t have a capacity to investigate it,” Hikmat said.

The statements came as the Jakarta Building Control and Monitoring Office (P2B) said it had served notice to Greenpeace on Wednesday about the closure and would proceed with sealing off its office on Jalan Kemang Utara in South Jakarta next Monday.

Agus Supriyono, P2B’s head of enforcement, said the office had been built in an area designated for residential buildings only.

“Like any other building that violates regulations, we will have to seal off this building,” he said.

“We will only unseal it once the building owners have restored it as a residential property. So that means that come Monday, Greenpeace must stop all activities at its office.”

Agus denied that his office had been pressured by outside parties to move against Greenpeace, calling the matter a simple zoning issue. He added that an office building next to the Greenpeace office would also be sealed off.

However, several other office and commercial buildings on the same street have been allowed to operate as usual.

“We don’t have a problem with Greenpeace. We’re just doing our job, which is to enforce zoning regulations and take measures against violating buildings,” Agus said.

“If Greenpeace wants to relocate its offices, they’re welcome to do so, just as long as they do so in an area where it’s permissible.”

Widyo Dwiyono, head of the South Jakarta P2B office, echoed the point that the entire Kemang area was designated as a residential zone, making it imperative that Greenpeace move.

Kemang is also home to scores of restaurants, bars, nightclubs and shops, very few of which have ever been sealed off or cited for zoning violations.

Hikmat said Greenpeace found it humorous how its “persecutor” kept coming up with different ways of attacking the organization, including past allegations that it was funded by lottery money and that it was intent on stalling Indonesian economic development by attacking the country’s palm oil industry.

“We’re not against the palm oil industry, nor do we want to stop Indonesian economic development,” he said. “All we are asking for is responsible industrial practices by implementing sustainable industrial development rather than destroying and exploiting the rainforest.

“It needs to be understood that Greenpeace’s campaigns focus on saving the Indonesian rainforest, hence we continue to urge all companies to save the rainforest through sustainable industrial development.”

Hikmat added that Greenpeace was aware it faced opposition to its work, but said attacks and pressure would not stop it from campaigning for better environmental stewardship.

“We just hope that the media and society don’t get the wrong idea about our mission in Indonesia because we just want to save the Indonesian rainforest,” he said.

Last month, a Greenpeace UK forest campaigner was deported from Indonesia for reasons that were never made clear. That incident took place less than a week after the Greenpeace UK director was denied entry into the country despite arriving with a valid visa.

Nur Hidayati, head of Greenpeace Indonesia, said at the time that the group was “coming under attack in Indonesia because of our work to stop deforestation in the country.”

Lawmakers and religious leaders have publicly questioned the source of the group’s funding, while hard-line groups have claimed it is working in the country illegally because it is not registered with the Jakarta administration.

Critics of Greenpeace have also accused it of targeting APP while ignoring foreign companies that operate in Indonesia. APP, though, is foreign, being based in Singapore.