Strategic Asia: In an Age of Self-Invention, Smart Cities Aim for a New Way to Talk About Themselves
David Adam | March 31, 2011
Related articles
No Pain, No Gain When It Comes to Economic Reform — Just Ask China 11:20am May 26, 2012
Asian Crisis of 1997 Holds Lessons for Europe, If Only It Would Put Down Austerity Textbook 11:16am May 26, 2012
US Wants It Both Ways on Israeli And Chinese Territorial Claims 9:07am May 24, 2012
From the Heart of Ambon to All of Indonesia, a Message of Peace and a Call for Connection 9:04am May 24, 2012
For Businesses, Going Green Begins at the Office and Ends With a Profit 9:35am May 23, 2012
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
408151I'm convinced this article must have been written with the aid of some mind-altering substances. While not hitherto familiar with Jakarta or Bandung, I'm finding David Adams definitions of cities as odd:
'In effect they are creating new forms of integrated governance as they go about their business of defining the future of how they talk about themselves.'
Perhaps, David Adams, go have a word or two with Fauzi Bowo about integrated governance.
Will he put his palm to his face and say:'Of course, silly me. I've been doing it all wrong up to now'-?
Maybe in a few years time when some of Jakarta is underwater, we could invent new Olympic sports. Perhaps set a new world-record for the biggest swimming-pool.
'Realizing their brand' - ah yes, when you can't get a job, and you need to feed your family, that's what you must do.
What does this semi-literate, name-dropping pile of marketing horse-manure masquerading as an intelligent article have to do with reality?
Don't get me wrong: I love cultural events whether they be theatre, dance, cinema, book-festivals etc, but somehow they don't belong to a whole city, rather to groups, or even an elite within that city. That elite can make a persuasive argument for governments and fundraisers to invest countless billions on transient events that temporarily enthuse the jaded palates of the lazy elites, while depriving the needy poor for years to come.
The recent Commonwealth games in India spring to mind.
This article should have been in the satirical magazine Private Eye: Pseuds Corner pages.
If you are not familiar with it: try googling for pseuds corner. Guaranteed to make you smile.
"This decision will be underscored if the International Olympic Committee finds an audience for winter sports — and Asia, with its youthful demographic, can readily provide that."
Maybe they could stage the Winter Olympics in Jakarta though. It'd really put the city on the map.
Well this other Globe story from today rather punctures Mr. Adam's thesis in my view:
http://www.thejakartaglobe.com/home/jakarta-chasing-investment-at-cost-to-environment/408202
A Nietzschian radical reinvention of the self is all very well in theory but one has to overcome cultural and social obstacles as well as ingrained beliefs and modes of existence. With this in mind, I can't help thinking that Jakarta is possibly the least likely of these so called global megacities to reconstruct itself and rise like a phoenix from the ashes of old. Problems of demographics and environmental degradation aside, a cultural intransigence exists here that rather puts me in mind of another famous image of Nietzsche's, namely when he has Christ delivering the sermon on the mount to a herd of cattle.
- Previous
- 1
- Next
In Jakarta we live in a megacity, a claim we share with over half the world’s population. By 2050 the United Nations predicts two-thirds of all humans will be living in megacities. These are cities that drive the global economy; they are the junction boxes of economic exchange. And as people, capital and culture become increasingly fluid, every city is competing to absorb that fluidity.
Peter Hall, the great urban chronicler, has referred to cities as “unraveling points,” where “people meet, people talk, people listen to each other’s music and each other’s words, dance each other’s dances, take in each other’s thoughts.”
These unraveling points are ever more global in nature, filled with ever more globally cosmopolitan populations.
That is why the way cities talk about themselves is changing.
Globalization and regional economic growth trends are changing the way cities behave and city branding strategies are moving into a new order.
They’re not about logos, brand values or PR stunts, but rather about what cities stand for.
Cities, regions and nations are creating strategic communications boards while also integrating the aims of the business community with those of the public sector and the cultural institutions that are the life force of the city.
In effect they are creating new forms of integrated governance as they go about their business of defining the future of how they talk about themselves.
Cities and nations cannot rely on tourism campaigns alone to manage their international reputations.
Smart cities know that by attracting major sporting and cultural events they bring the focus to the totality of what their city is about. Cities are not just about one event, or an iconic architectural showcase or a major infrastructural project.
A city must find a voice, vocabulary and story that reflect its economic proposition and its offer among competitors.
Increasingly, cities are moving toward these approaches to realizing their brand, and nowhere is this more true than in Asia. Scores of major events are taking place in cities across Asia, from Delhi to Guanghzou to Singapore.
Almaty is hosting the winter Asian Games in 2011. And don’t be surprised if the 2018 Winter Olympic Games decision goes to Pyeongchang next July.
This decision will be underscored if the International Olympic Committee finds an audience for winter sports — and Asia, with its youthful demographic, can readily provide that.
In the 19th century, Nietzsche was the first philosopher to recommend a course of self-reinvention.
By the 20th century self-reinvention was a neurosis as far as Freud was concerned, but in 21st century city life we have come of age in this line of thinking.
Self-reinvention applies not only to individuals but to cities, regions and nations.
This is especially important in a post-colonial and post-imperial world.
Benedict Anderson, in his classic analysis “Imagined Communities” outlines how we create collective understanding of ourselves and how nationalisms are born and manipulated.
The difference for the 21st century and a global information age is that people and cities are actively taking the mantle and refashioning perceptions and re-imagining their futures.
The opportunity to unshackle oneself from the past and begin a new future in a transformational sense is at the heart of the Asian century.
The youthful demographic bulge of a number of societies across Asia means self-invention will not only be driven by the experience of the past but it will be driven by desire for change.
The most significant feature of self-invention is that it enables you to take the reins and define your future.
Part of reinvention is about picking those bits of the past that you want to celebrate and showing how they are relevant for the future.
Jakarta has finally shaken off the mantle of shame at being a Dutch colony and is starting to celebrate some of the remnants of its Dutch past, with the renovation and preservation of Dutch colonial buildings in Kota.
Other cities like Bandung are also just waking up to the value of their heritage. Bandung isn’t nicknamed Paris Van Java for nothing.
The growth of cities is more than just an economic trend; it is driven by political and social factors too.
People come to cities not just to find work, but to be themselves and to experience the world. In an age of self-invention cities provide the canvas for people to define their futures.
And just as it is important to the individual to re-invent himself or herself, the most successful cities will be those who enable that self-invention.
And naturally, as an extension of this process, cities now want to reinvent themselves on the global stage. In setting its vision for the future, a city not only reinvents itself but what it means to be a citizen in it.
The rapid process of industrialization, urbanization and economic growth taking place across Asia means that the region will redefine what citizenship means in the 21st century.
This is the meaning of the Asian Century. Only time and a lot of soul- searching will determine what it has meant to move from a citizen of Batavia to a citizen of Jakarta.
In Asia, more voices have emerged, tackling the problems of resource constraints and the challenges of pluralism, just as Asian technocrats make technological leapfrogs over the West.
Those voices will redefine what citizenship means in the 21st century. It’s time for them to broadcast that story to the world.
How Jakarta, or other mega cities in Indonesia take up this challenge could mean the difference between becoming a vibrant city or deteriorating into a stopover-metropolis, a viewing point for the brightly lit metropolis on the horizon that has marketed itself as the height of happening.
David Adam is the CEO of Global Cities Ltd and an associate of Strategic Asia Europe.
- Lady Gaga Angers Thai Fans With Fake Rolex Comment
- Lady Gaga Refuses to Tone Down Her Shows: Manager
- Djoko Says ‘I Don’t Care’ About FPI Demonstration
- Indonesia Set to Cap Bank Owners’ Stakes: Sources
- If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Watch, Djoko Says of Gaga
- Singapore Cabby Jailed for Molesting Indonesian Maid
- Indonesia's Chief Justice Demands SBY Explain Corby Clemency
- National Exams' ‘Fantastic’ Passing Rate Suspicious: ICW
- 'Stop Treating Indonesia as a Beggar Nation,' Australian Academic Urges
- Malaysian Authorities Seize Copies of Irshad Manji’s Book
-
12:17pm | Indonesian Police Consider Ton...
padt - as always spot on - In Indonesia it is always a case of 'follow the money'. -
12:03pm | Indonesian Police Consider Ton...
thanks padt; unfortunately the site is blocked by my Indonesian IP provider. Quite odd... -
11:42am | Indonesian Police Consider Ton...
Devine - Asia Sentinel: they alone have said what's been out there for weeks. Think about it. Why is this concert going ahead now? -
11:40am | Indonesia Wants 10,000 Child W...
I wonder what he (MI) is up to, perhaps another new project funding where certain percentage can be squeezed out for their own benefit, a good try -
11:36am | Andi Mallarangeng Denies Bribe...
Everybody being rightfully accused will always deny, including those that accuses them will do their best to fabricate such an undeniable defense -
11:26am | Indonesian Police Consider Ton...
padt, cant find this information anywhere... can you provide a link? -
11:23am | The Thinker: Let Yogya Be Yogy...
Why do the central government want to change situation in Jogja that has already peaceful and calm for years? Why does Jakarta want to "fix" some -
11:02am | Indonesian Police Consider Ton...
PLEASE EXCUSE THE CAPITALS - BUT I NEED TO HAVE MYSELF HEARD!!! FINALLY - ONE NEWS PORTAL ( NOT THIS ONE) HAS ACTUALLY GOTTEN AROUN
