Indonesian Biofuel Dispute May Burn EU
June 29, 2010
Related articles
Used Vegetable Oil Can Fire a Modified Cooking Stove, Say Indonesian Researchers 9:07pm Jan 8, 2010
Biofuel Program Stalls on Poor Planning, Low Prices 8:33pm May 27, 2009
Brazil Hopes Farmers Will Seed Biofuel Growth 5:14pm Aug 25, 2010
Europe Finds Politics and Biofuels a Dangerous Mix 11:19pm Jul 6, 2010
Sampoerna Agro Mulls Making Biofuel from Sago 9:42pm Apr 12, 2010
Share This Page
Post a comment
Please login to post comment
Comments
Be the first to write your opinion!
In recent weeks a war of words has been waged between diplomats representing Indonesia and the European Union over how Europe plans to treat the importation of Indonesian biofuel and other palm-based products. Europe’s diplomats have elected to put European domestic political interest ahead of sound economics and environmental policy. If they don’t reconsider their views, they are risking escalating the dispute into a full-scale trade war. The casualties will be European consumers and the Indonesian economy.
The uproar is over a decision by Europe’s energy commissioner, Gunther Oettinger, and officials in the EU to add new environmental standards for biofuels to have full access to its market.
These new standards will discriminate against producers in Asia, Africa and Latin America, and make Europe’s biofuel policy even more protectionist than it already is.
The effect of new standards will be to limit the importation of foreign biofuels in the European market.
The stakes for Indonesia are high. The new standards run the risk of closing Europe’s market entirely for the nation’s biofuels exporters, jeopardizing both the economy and many jobs.
In an unintended irony, the global environment will also be a casualty of this protectionism as the main effect of Europe’s new move will be to slow down the shift from fossil fuels to cleaner biofuels.
The new rules are the result of months of pressure from a coalition of radical environmental NGOs in Europe and their allies in the European biofuels industry.
But the Indonesian government could put an end to it. Europe’s new policy on biofuels production standards — known as the Renewable Energy Directive — almost certainly runs afoul of international law under World Trade Organization’s regulations.
WTO rules are especially attentive to discrimination and the principle that like products should be treated equally.
There is good reason for this: The architects of the trade group knew that domestic interests pressure governments to trump up bogus charges to keep foreign products out.
Thus a regulation that prevents biofuels from entering Europe’s market just because it has been produced in peat lands, for example, would be met with suspicion by WTO authorities.
And yet this is precisely what the RED intends to do — block Asian biofuel because it is produced in the tropics.
But the physical product characteristics of Indonesian palm-based biofuel will be the same as those for a biofuel produced in Europe, and in the eyes of the WTO, this is what matters.
In similar cases in the past, the Appellate Body, the highest court of the WTO, ruled that methodologies used in the creation of a product can only be the basis for treating product as unlike (i.e. discrimination) if they affect physical characteristics.
This is clearly not the case with Europe’s new land-based criteria for access to its market.
It’s true that the WTO allows members to deviate from its obligations, but rarely. A member country is justified to deviate if it can prove a measure is necessary to protect the environment, for example.
But here Europe runs into problems. A trade restriction against foreign biofuels will limit the supply in Europe and increase prices.
This makes the transition away from more polluting fuels such as oil and gas more difficult.
Indeed, slowing down the shift away from fossil fuels — which the planned European regulation would do — fails to advance broader ecological interests.
EU representatives say they welcome a WTO complaint over its new biofuels standards. Julian Wilson, the head of an EU delegation to Indonesia and Brunei, recently said, “We really hope to have a debate at the WTO on the matter and we welcome it.”
Indonesia should take Wilson up on that invitation.
Rather than retaliating by other means, it is better to solve disputes in a legal and structured form in the WTO. Indonesia also stands a good chance to win. Europe is erring on the side of protectionism.
Fredrik Erixon is a director at the European Center for International Political Economy, a research group in Brussels.
Tension Mounts as Groups Protest Plan to Burn Koran
Indonesian’s Death Sentence Calls Into Question Fairness of Malaysian Courts
Interest Rate Hike Likely Next Year: Bank Indonesia
Bogor Church Congregation Hits Back Over Unfair Closure
Jusuf Kalla: Indonesia Must Be Firm in Border Talks With Malaysia
Over Half of Graft Suspects Beat the Rap
This Fashion Season, Women Skip the Skirts and Wear the Pants
Only One Officer Named as Suspect in Buol Killings: Amnesty Calls for Probe
Jakarta Journo: Housewarming Gift for House of Representatives
8:54am | Rossi leads tributes to tragic Moto2 rider Tomizawa
8:32am | Afridi calls for Pakistan to focus on cricket
8:26am | Emergency extended in NZ's quake-hit Christchurch
8:16am | Germany to extend life of nuclear reactors
7:52am | Scandal-hit Pakistan well beaten by England in cricket Twenty20
7:50am | Nadal moves on at US tennis Open, Murray goes home
6:52am | Nadal leads Spanish charge at US Open
5:52am | 'National tragedy' in Guatemala as landslides kill dozens
11:25pm | Only One Officer Named as Susp...
Well the police got their patsy to smear everything on and the public is of course afraid to come forward to act a witness whcih would implicate other officers.
Basically ...
11:18pm | My Jakarta: Aceng, Bemo Driver...
I like Pak Aceng and his entrepreneurial spirit BUT - question number 2 "...why not start a limousine company" is a bit off for me. Whoever conducted the interview should have ...
11:01pm | Bakrie Life Offers Promises to...
I actually believe that this kind of business was very purposefully set up to gain access to money and, as a side product, to deceive the customers. This money was ...
10:36pm | Bakrie Life Offers Promises to...
"We cover you IN MUD for life"! Haha.
9:53pm | More Parties Join Chorus of Pr...
Hmm...And the dilapidated infrastructure as a whole in and around the capital is being ignored once again.
Are there any politicians with a mutual common sense to pursue a ...
9:40pm | MRT Should Only Be the Beginni...
"The MRT Jakarta is an idea that has been around since the mid-1970s."
The clock is ticking...It is 2010, more talks and soon it will be again an idea ...














